Joe Flacco vs. Matt Ryan (1 Viewer)

[Garts]

Which gunslinger do you pick?

 

[Sudoku_in_the_Bathtub]

I think there's another topic on this, but I'd take Ryan hands down. More talented IMO, dome, and as time wears on I think he becomes the Peyton Manning-like figure in Atlanta.

Comparison sake:

Ryan = P.Manning (consistent top 5 QB)

Flacco = throw in a QB that'll be ranked between 10-15 consistently with a 1 or 2 top 5-6 seasons)

 

[treat88]

I think there's another topic on this, but I'd take Ryan hands down. More talented IMO, dome, and as time wears on I think he becomes the Peyton Manning-like figure in Atlanta. Comparison sake:Ryan = P.Manning (consistent top 5 QB)Flacco = throw in a QB that'll be ranked between 10-15 consistently with a 1 or 2 top 5-6 seasons)

I agree, but am not quite so optimistic about Flacco.I don't foresee any truly elite seasons and see a few below league average performances.He's surprised the hell out of me with how well he has played this year, but i am not a believer yet.I am 100% onboard with the Ryan comments.

 

[Sudoku_in_the_Bathtub]

I think there's another topic on this, but I'd take Ryan hands down. More talented IMO, dome, and as time wears on I think he becomes the Peyton Manning-like figure in Atlanta.

Comparison sake:

Ryan = P.Manning (consistent top 5 QB)

Flacco = throw in a QB that'll be ranked between 10-15 consistently with a 1 or 2 top 5-6 seasons)

I agree, but am not quite so optimistic about Flacco.I don't foresee any truly elite seasons and see a few below league average performances.

He's surprised the hell out of me with how well he has played this year, but i am not a believer yet.

I am 100% onboard with the Ryan comments.

I'm not that overly optimistic on Flacco either (fantasy-wise). I should of entered the word possible into my 1 or 2 top 5-6 seasons. I view him as a QB2 for dynasty purposes. Surprised as well with how he's doing.It's very hard to gauge him because he has exceeded expectations (at least mine) so much thus far.

 

[Native]

I would take Flacco. Stronger arm, higher upside (imo) plus he still has plenty of accuracy and good leadership skills.

I think hes going to be a star...

 

[TheDirtyWord]

Ryan = Manning/Brady

Flacco = Roethlisberger

 

[PlasmaDogPlasma]

Who gets surrounded by the best weapons?

 

[mlball77]

Who gets surrounded by the best weapons?

This is a very important question to consider. Both young QBs have proven more than capable. Right now, I like Ryan a bit better. Before the season started, I liked Flacco a bit more as a long-term QB in dynasty. But Ryan has proven to be the real deal. I still think that with Flacco it is incredible that he has fared so well given where he came from in college and the level of competition he faced. I think he could develop a tremendous amount further in the next year or two.