I'm going to put it out there and say it...I'm willing to take him in the first round with no hesitation. In my ultra competitive 12 man ppr league he's the talk of the league...I have the 8th pick and I know for a fact the guys at 10, 11, and 12 love him...no chance he makes it back to me in the second.....and he will be mine.
He'll rival Megatron for FF WR 1, consider him Optimus Prime if you will.
92 - 1500 - 15 TD's
Sounds to me like you are taking their bait.
Not sure what bait that would be since I'm basing it on conversations we all had amongst ourselves BEFORE the draft order came out.Point is....when you have a gut feeling about a guy you take him. Look at the option between picks #8 - #14
ADP - Completely off my board since I wouldn't draft him until at least the 3rd round and he'll be gone way before that based on name value alone. Want to talk about history? Let's discuss the drop off in productivity the year following ACL surgery....and it's not like ADP doesn't already have some mileage on him
Charles - I don't care if it happened in week 1 or week 16. An ACL surgery is an ACL surgery. Plus you're spending a pick this high on a guy who's going to be sharing carries and losing all goal line work.
Murray - Anyone who cites injuries or youth/inexperience/sample size as a case against Julio and then advocates taking Murray above him is quite possibly the biggest hypocrite in the history of this message board
MJD - Holding out. No end in sight. Already has a ton of mileage and a backup who looks like he's capable of running with the job if the holdout extends. This pick is the definition of risk.
Chris Johnson - Same as ADP with regards to being off my draft board based on the relative position he gets drafted. I've seen this movie before...it's the one where the guy gets paid a boat load of cash and loses the hunger to excel. We're not talking about a guy who had a bad year cause he got hurt...this guy played all 16 games and never found his groove. If I hear the "even with that he still finished in the top 10" argument again I may throw up. Ask any CJ owner who took him in the first round last year if those "top 10 numbers" helped their teams. The fact is almost any RB with a pulse in the NFL who stays healthy for a full 16 games and gets the workload he gets could stumble into a 1,000 yard season by accident. For the love of humanity, I still remember Kareem Abdul Jabaar getting 1,000 yards for the Phins back in the day. It's a pure volume stat....and furthermore it's not like you're getting him at a discount this year. He'll still cost you a first round pick.
Marshawn Lynch - My league is PPR...with TD's being such a fickle stat I have a hard time taking a guy who doesn't get a lot of receptions this high. Plus...Lynch was mediocre for a good 2 -3 years before he suddenly burst back on the scene in Seattle. I'm skeptical here.
And before anyone brings it up I know for a fact McFadden and Forte will be gone before I pick. It's against my religion to take a QB in the first round of a 4 pt passing td that has ppr.
The only argument I can understand is Jimmy Graham. But in a ultra competitive 12 man league with a flex position you're going to have a hard time recovering throughout the draft in terms of depth at rb/wr if you take a TE this early. I see more value waiting til round 3 or 4 and taking Gates if you really want to take a TE early.
So yeah...given his immediate neighbors in ADP land I just don't see how Julio is a bad pick at 1.08. I'd love to hear arguments on who offers his same upside in this range. This is a league where not many QB's will go in the first...it's entirely possible that one of the big 3 QB's or even Graham could make it back to me in the 2nd. Meanwhile there is zero chance Julio makes it back to me in the 2nd.
It should be noted I'm an upside down drafter to begin with...but even then I can't see the logic in taking any of the options above even if I was hell bent on taking a RB in this range.