Justin Upton or Matt Kemp? (1 Viewer)

[bosoxs45]

Of the two best young outfielders in the NL West, who will have a more productive career? Justin Upton of the Diamondbacks or Matt Kemp of the LA Dodgers?

 

[pollardsvision]

i would say kemp (for this year only), but i don't trust kemp to get the ABs.

both have the talent, but only one has a true opportunity.

 

[Eephus]

Definitely Upton in a keeper. Three extra years of potential development (age 20 vs 23) is a huge difference.

 

[B Maverick]

right now upton, at least until kemp stops pouting and learns to hit the curve ball (insert jobu joke here).

Kemp should be the starting RF for LA for the next 10 years. BUT he isnt hitting and rumors are he isnt taking the sitting very well. Could be a long season.

 

[bosoxs45]

right now upton, at least until kemp stops pouting and learns to hit the curve ball (insert jobu joke here).Kemp should be the starting RF for LA for the next 10 years. BUT he isnt hitting and rumors are he isnt taking the sitting very well. Could be a long season.

Is that why Joe Torre's starting Juan Pierre instead?

 

[B Maverick]

right now upton, at least until kemp stops pouting and learns to hit the curve ball (insert jobu joke here).Kemp should be the starting RF for LA for the next 10 years. BUT he isnt hitting and rumors are he isnt taking the sitting very well. Could be a long season.

Is that why Joe Torre's starting Juan Pierre instead?

thats the rumors. i mean how could anyone justify Pierre over anyone?

 

[prosopis]

J Upton and it is not close.

 

[westyplz]

right now upton, at least until kemp stops pouting and learns to hit the curve ball (insert jobu joke here).Kemp should be the starting RF for LA for the next 10 years. BUT he isnt hitting and rumors are he isnt taking the sitting very well. Could be a long season.

Is that why Joe Torre's starting Juan Pierre instead?

thats the rumors. i mean how could anyone justify Pierre over anyone?

How could ANYONE justify Kemp over JUpton?