Keep QB's only (1 Viewer)

[ddarroch4]

In order to increase the value of QBs I'm thinking of allowing all teams to keep 2 QBs after every season (beginning after next season / no keepers at any other position). Do you think could be a good keeper rule? I do not have any interest in turning the league into a start 2 QB league, I find that kind of lame so please don't suggest or mention why you like that form of ff.

 

[mr roboto]

In order to increase the value of QBs I'm thinking of allowing all teams to keep 2 QBs after every season (beginning after next season / no keepers at any other position). Do you think could be a good keeper rule? I do not have any interest in turning the league into a start 2 QB league, I find that kind of lame so please don't suggest or mention why you like that form of ff.

What's the point of the restriction? Also, why 2 QB keeper when you start just one?Sounds kinda lame.

 

[Jewell]

In order to increase the value of QBs I'm thinking of allowing all teams to keep 2 QBs after every season (beginning after next season / no keepers at any other position). Do you think could be a good keeper rule? I do not have any interest in turning the league into a start 2 QB league, I find that kind of lame so please don't suggest or mention why you like that form of ff.

That dispoportionately hurts the teams with bad QBs. If Team A has awesome QBs, but Team B has crap QBs, Team A already has a marked advantage heading into the next season. Different teams have different strengths. Best to let each owner decide what his strengths are.

 

[ddarroch4]

In order to increase the value of QBs I'm thinking of allowing all teams to keep 2 QBs after every season (beginning after next season / no keepers at any other position). Do you think could be a good keeper rule? I do not have any interest in turning the league into a start 2 QB league, I find that kind of lame so please don't suggest or mention why you like that form of ff.

That dispoportionately hurts the teams with bad QBs. If Team A has awesome QBs, but Team B has crap QBs, Team A already has a marked advantage heading into the next season. Different teams have different strengths. Best to let each owner decide what his strengths are.

Every team would know going into next years draft that everyone can keep their QBs after that season. If a team draft 2 crappy QBs that's their fault. But if they have Aaron Rodgers and Cam Newton they're pretty happy.

 

[Hipple Long Ware & Peete]

why do you want to increase QB value?

 

[massraider]

why do you want to increase QB value?

Yeah.

 

[Ping Pong]

In order to increase the value of QBs I'm thinking of allowing all teams to keep 2 QBs after every season (beginning after next season / no keepers at any other position). Do you think could be a good keeper rule? I do not have any interest in turning the league into a start 2 QB league, I find that kind of lame so please don't suggest or mention why you like that form of ff.

This might be the dumbest thing I've ever read. You try to inflate QB value through some obscure keeper rule that makes no sense, and then trash leagues that actually thoughtfully and successfully increase QB value. If you want to inflate QBs without starting more of them, just increase the points QBs get for TDs, yards, completions, etc.

 

[massraider]

+6 points every week if the player in question is white.

 

[Tito the Builder]

Why don't you just go to a 2 QB setup?

 

[LittlePhatty]

Not fun in my opinion.

My main league is a Keep 3, and hardly anyone chooses to keep QB. RBs are much more fun to stash.

 

[Topes]

why do you want to increase QB value?

 

[manny]

Just make the change - 2 QB leagues should be the norm. 1 QB leagues are dumb - they minimize the importance of the most important position (by far) in the game. 2 QB leagues shifts the balance back to where it should be.

Dancing around it with weird gimmicks like having people keep 2 QBs only, while only being able to start one is missing the boat.

 

[Paul Bremer]

I prefer Start-2 QB leagus because I find them more of a challenge. The create a scarcity at the position which increases their value. Plus, they more properly emulate the NFL game, where there are always (at least) two QBs in every game.