I think Kenny Irons is very underrated from a dynasty perspective due to the fact that he will not give you immediate returns (barring an injury to Rudi). However, I think he will have the second best fantasy career of any RB drafted this year because:
1. Rudi won't be around as long as you think. He only has 2 years left on his contract and he has had a lot of carries the last few years. This is his 7th season in the NFL. The Bengals won't bring him back, IMO.
2. Chris Perry isn't a long term threat. He can't stay healthy and the Bengals don't love his rehab effort.
3. Kenny Irons has looked fantastic in both the rookie camps and early in training camp. He has a burst that Rudi does not and in his prime will likely put up even better numbers than Rudi (Why? Rudi did not have a single 25 yard run last year. )
4. The Bengals offense will be one of the league's best for a looooong time. Carson Palmer is signed through 2014 and is just 26. Chad Johnson is signed through 2011. Chris Henry, if he can get his life together, will be a very dangerous long term #2. LT Levi Jones just signed a huge long term contract and the Bengals are decently well stocked with good young OL (Whitworth, Andrews, Ghiachuc).
Overall, I see Kenny Irons as a guy who in 2 years will be in a situation as good as or better than Joseph Addai. He will be the man at RB in what very well could be the NFL's best offense. If you can deal with 2 seasons of him getting mediocre numbers (barring injury), I think there is a very good chance that he will end up being a good #1 Fantasy RB. And judging by where he is going in both rookie and other dynasty drafts, that would make him a HUGE steal.
1. Rudi won't be around as long as you think. He only has 2 years left on his contract and he has had a lot of carries the last few years. This is his 7th season in the NFL. The Bengals won't bring him back, IMO.
2. Chris Perry isn't a long term threat. He can't stay healthy and the Bengals don't love his rehab effort.
3. Kenny Irons has looked fantastic in both the rookie camps and early in training camp. He has a burst that Rudi does not and in his prime will likely put up even better numbers than Rudi (Why? Rudi did not have a single 25 yard run last year. )
4. The Bengals offense will be one of the league's best for a looooong time. Carson Palmer is signed through 2014 and is just 26. Chad Johnson is signed through 2011. Chris Henry, if he can get his life together, will be a very dangerous long term #2. LT Levi Jones just signed a huge long term contract and the Bengals are decently well stocked with good young OL (Whitworth, Andrews, Ghiachuc).
Overall, I see Kenny Irons as a guy who in 2 years will be in a situation as good as or better than Joseph Addai. He will be the man at RB in what very well could be the NFL's best offense. If you can deal with 2 seasons of him getting mediocre numbers (barring injury), I think there is a very good chance that he will end up being a good #1 Fantasy RB. And judging by where he is going in both rookie and other dynasty drafts, that would make him a HUGE steal.