Krafty Veteran vs Upstart Rookie (1 Viewer)

[varmint cong]

Barnett is the proven and consistant one, Ryans has the upside but is still "green", both play for bad teams and will prob be on the field alot. Who do you want and why?(.5 for tackles , 2 pts for sacks)

 

[The_Hunchback]

Ugh, they both are about the same. Ryans could wear down as the season goes along since it is his rookie season. I'm not a big guy on Barnett and would likely go with Ryans myself.

 

[sholditch]

Ryans. 12 tackles his first pro game vs. a stout Philly line. Great things to come on the way to DROY

help:

http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...howtopic=268422

 

[mario8723]

Is this a keeper league? If so, I would go with Ryans as Barnett may be forced to the strong side next year or possibly wind up somewhere else (which could hurt his value)