KellysHeroes
Footballguy
i thought this would be fun...
PPR scoring, pre-draft... who has more value. MBIII or the 1.01 rookie draft pick
PPR scoring, pre-draft... who has more value. MBIII or the 1.01 rookie draft pick
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
MBIII vs Rookie 1.01 (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter KellysHeroes
- Start date
Fullback Fro
yesno
see mine
Hip Hop Harry
Footballguy
The Player
comfortably numb
Footballguy
Voted for 1.1.....and 1.2
KellysHeroes
Footballguy
it is a very tough call....
If Dmac goes too Oak, he loses a ton of value... heck; he may not even be 1.01 for me anymore.
Then theres the RBBC situation in big D... reports are that their looking at RB for either of the 2 1st rd picks or 2nd rd.
If Dmac goes too Oak, he loses a ton of value... heck; he may not even be 1.01 for me anymore.
Then theres the RBBC situation in big D... reports are that their looking at RB for either of the 2 1st rd picks or 2nd rd.
Sweet Love
IBL Representative
Interesting...Birdie048 said:
KellysHeroes
Footballguy
Rookie 1.01's role should be very clear.
Team Legacy
Footballguy
Voted 1.1.
KellysHeroes
Footballguy
I will be shocked if one of thier 1st 3 picks is not an RB.. I got the feeling their looking at Flex Jones as a nice counter part to MBIII.I voted for 1.01 myself... but they are very close
Last edited by a moderator:
Brutis
Footballguy
I dont think whoever dallas drafts for RB's will get a significant amount of carries. Unless you consider 5-8 carries a game significant.
frank_da_tank
Footballguy
voted for 1.1. IMO....... DMC is special. These types of backs find a way to shine. Critics started doubting him pre -combine, "poof" 
- 4.29-. Watch 
he will do great things.. He is not as good as ADP but will be a better pro than Bush. I would consider Bush better than MB3 in my PPR league. Ergo, DMC is of more value to me than MB3.
MB3 is a very good back with a very good o-line. Would he be as good somewhere else? The boys will bring in another back but his touches will be better than 2007.
As a 1.1 owner, I will hold if offered MB3 straight up.
- 4.29-. Watch he will do great things.. He is not as good as ADP but will be a better pro than Bush. I would consider Bush better than MB3 in my PPR league. Ergo, DMC is of more value to me than MB3.MB3 is a very good back with a very good o-line. Would he be as good somewhere else? The boys will bring in another back but his touches will be better than 2007.
As a 1.1 owner, I will hold if offered MB3 straight up.
KellysHeroes
Footballguy
The plan will alway too keep MBIII fresh.. similar to BJ; try to keep him under 20 touches
mlball77
Footballguy
I voted Barber. I guess it largely depends on what you're doing with your team. Assuming this is a dynasty league, if you are in more of a rebuild mode then 1.01 is the way... but if you can compete this year, I think Barber is a much safer bet for the next year or two (particularly in that potent Dallas offense).
Boston
Footballguy
It's all speculation until you see how the draft pans out. Does Dallas add a legit RB to their stable like a Maurice Jones-Drew or is it a more complimentary RB like a Kevin Faulk? As for McFadden you need to see where he goes. He's a potential big time RB but what happens if's he's still standing at #7 and the Pats draft him as the best player available and he's sharing time with Maroney?
The bottomline is this is a trade I would not be in a rush to make whether I had Barber or the #1 pick. There's just too much room for error until we see who Barber's backfield partner is or where McFadden ends up. If forced to make a decision ight now (i.e. as of 3/12) I'd go with Barber. He'll only be 25 yeards old in June, doesn't have big mileage on him, has seen the end zone 28 times in the last two years and is a known commodity. The kid is a big time RB who seems poised to really break out next year without Julius Jones in the fold.
The bottomline is this is a trade I would not be in a rush to make whether I had Barber or the #1 pick. There's just too much room for error until we see who Barber's backfield partner is or where McFadden ends up. If forced to make a decision ight now (i.e. as of 3/12) I'd go with Barber. He'll only be 25 yeards old in June, doesn't have big mileage on him, has seen the end zone 28 times in the last two years and is a known commodity. The kid is a big time RB who seems poised to really break out next year without Julius Jones in the fold.
