McFadden or Hillis? (1 Viewer)

[wlwiles]

Both were projected to be #2 or #3 RB for their team, both got opportunities due to injury, and both stepped up to the challenge quite nicely (DMac for 3 games and Hillis only 1 so far).

Who would you rather have?

 

[todisco1]

Hillis looks terrific but I'd rather have McFadden by a large margin.

 

[Otis]

I'd rather have McFadden by a large margin.

by a landslide

 

[SSOG]

When was McFadden projected to be the #2 in Oakland? I know a lot of journalists and fantasy owners loved playing "if I owned the Raiders" over the offseason, but the closest anyone with any authority ever came to calling McFadden the #2 back was back in June when Tom Cable said he had two #1s.

 

[Resident A]

I drafted both. I traded Hillis away for QB help. If a team wants McFadden from me, they're gonna have to pry him from my cold dead hands.