I'm not ripping LeBron at all. I love the move he made.
It's just that he and Melo made very similar decisions. Yet LeBron is a hero and Melo only cares about money.
Lebron's team will be competing for an eastern conference championship while Melo will be watching the competition unfold.
Maybe, but 95% of the reason for that is the difference between LeBron and Melo himself.
I like LeBron's spot, but there's a ton of unknown. At the end of the day, he's joining a 33 win team who's other big addition is still a rookie. He's not maximizing his chance to win a ring in 2014-15.
But I'm really talking about Melo. That team could absolutely go win 45 games this year.
In the East, 45 wins means you might host a Playoff series (if Wiggins doesn't develop really quickly, it's no guarantee that the Cavs win a ton more than that, btw).
Melo can play meaningful play-off games this year, and beginning the following year, he's in NYC with Phil and capspace. That's a scenario that you can absolutely win with.
Hell, if LeBron had chosen the Knicks, we'd probably be talking about he honorable it is that he chose to accept the challenge of bringing a Title to MSG (after folks stopped crying for CLE fans, of course).