So what kind of return could the Knicks hope for if they dealt Carmelo Anthony?
Very little. A first round pick, not in next years draft.
The two LA teams are out. If the Lakers were going to fire D'Antoni, they would have done it to try to entice Howard to stay, so they are vested with D'Antoni. Melo basically drove Pringles out of NY, along with Lin, so I have serious doubts LA could sign Anthony, and convince him to leave money on the table. A sign and trade is almost impossible as the Lakers are devoid of assets ( no draft picks, no cap space, no young promising players on rookie contracts) Also LA has to face the prospect, if they resign Bryant, of two ball stopping chuckers with bad shot selections , who are really anti Pringles type players, that don't care about defense and who will decline heavily in their next contracts.
The Clippers problems aren't offense, it's defense. Adding Melo the mix doesn't help that team reach the next level. Getting Jordan and Griffin to be true two way threats, esp on defense, is the big key to that team. On Griffin for Melo, Griffin is younger, more marketable, and is at least in good condition.
It's not just Melo, it's his wife, who has a reality show. For that to work, she has to be in NY or LA. He's never shown to have ever left money on the table, which is what it would take to leave the Knicks. He's a minus defender ( though an elite rebounder from the SF slot) and his conditioning leaves much to be desired. His plus is he is complete offensively, and that extra weight he carries helps him as a PF. There's nothing within the realm of scoring that he can't do at an elite level.
His best fit is the Bulls. A team that can hide him defensively and a team who needs someone to take the heavy lifting offensively while they lock down on D. Melo only has to be average on D and Rose, Butler and Noah and Gibson can protect and cover for his weaknesses. I think Melo would ease the offensive burden on Rose and the team can sort of let Melo focus on offense while the focus on all the other aspects of the game. I mean this is what the US did with international play. Surround Melo with a good team, let them worry about defense and all the other dirty work issues and just tell him to score.
Despite his poor shot selection, his conditioning and his crap defense and what I see as generally low BB IQ, Melo will give you about 3 weeks a season where he is pretty much unstoppable. All his shots fall and he's a one man wrecking crew offensively. From a coaching standpoint, the trick is to get him to peak there in your playoff run.
I don't see him leaving NY. If he cared about a ring, he would have signed with NY as a free agent, taken a salary hit and not drained the Knicks of all those assets. His best "Career" move is to go to the Bulls with a paycut. His best "Melo the Limited Celebrity who wants to keep his wife happy as a D Lister" move is to stay in NY, take the max and be a first round exit every year.