What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

*NBA THREAD* Abe will be missed (5 Viewers)

I don't understand the hate for Kevin Martin and his contract. Sure, hes a little overpaid, but hes still very productive. If you were setting a fair market price for him, he would be paid similarly to guys like JR Smith, Jamal Crawford, and Lou Williams who make $1-1.5M less than him. That's not insignificant, but it shouldn't make or break a team. He's not like Landy Fields or Gerald Wallace where you are paying him to sit on the bench.

 
Can't believe this is getting lost in the Love shuffle. Western conference just got a lot tougher, with the road through Dallas.

Mavs appear to have Al Farouq Aminu locked up for 2 years (on the heels of Jameer Nelson signing)

#CHAMPIONSHIP

 
Thompson is very replaceable on both ends of the court, and with Iguodala, they don't really even need a second lock down defender starting. Kevin Martin would be a better offensive player than Klay, and they could pick up somebody like Aminu of the trash heap to give them a better defensive player than Thompson. They would have to be choosier with matchups, but the combo of somebody like Martin and Aminu (or even Green who is already on the roster) gives them 80% of what Thompson brings, while Love is twice the player Lee is. Its ridiculous that Thompson would hold up a Love trade from GSW's end.
Losing Klay exposes Curry defensively. Iggy is a great defender against wings but not against PGs. All of the sudden Klay is a below average defender. It's like no one watched the play off series vs LAC.

And Love is a top 5-6 player but the upgrade from Lee isn't a great as you are saying. Love is as bad, if not worse, than Lee on the defensive end, and Lee, even with his big contract was an all star solely on his offensive prowess.

 
Thompson is very replaceable on both ends of the court, and with Iguodala, they don't really even need a second lock down defender starting. Kevin Martin would be a better offensive player than Klay, and they could pick up somebody like Aminu of the trash heap to give them a better defensive player than Thompson. They would have to be choosier with matchups, but the combo of somebody like Martin and Aminu (or even Green who is already on the roster) gives them 80% of what Thompson brings, while Love is twice the player Lee is. Its ridiculous that Thompson would hold up a Love trade from GSW's end.
Losing Klay exposes Curry defensively. Iggy is a great defender against wings but not against PGs. All of the sudden Klay is a below average defender. It's like no one watched the play off series vs LAC.

And Love is a top 5-6 player but the upgrade from Lee isn't a great as you are saying. Love is as bad, if not worse, than Lee on the defensive end, and Lee, even with his big contract was an all star solely on his offensive prowess.
Who needs defense when you're hanging 150 on everyone every night?

 
I don't understand the hate for Kevin Martin and his contract. Sure, hes a little overpaid, but hes still very productive. If you were setting a fair market price for him, he would be paid similarly to guys like JR Smith, Jamal Crawford, and Lou Williams who make $1-1.5M less than him. That's not insignificant, but it shouldn't make or break a team. He's not like Landy Fields or Gerald Wallace where you are paying him to sit on the bench.
If GSW takes him they want Levine and/or an unprotected first. They need someone athletic enough to check elite PGs.

 
I don't understand the hate for Kevin Martin and his contract. Sure, hes a little overpaid, but hes still very productive. If you were setting a fair market price for him, he would be paid similarly to guys like JR Smith, Jamal Crawford, and Lou Williams who make $1-1.5M less than him. That's not insignificant, but it shouldn't make or break a team. He's not like Landy Fields or Gerald Wallace where you are paying him to sit on the bench.
If GSW takes him they want Levine and/or an unprotected first. They need someone athletic enough to check elite PGs.
lol take Love for Klay and overpaid lee, and demand their first round pick as well. DELUSIONAL
 
I don't understand the hate for Kevin Martin and his contract. Sure, hes a little overpaid, but hes still very productive. If you were setting a fair market price for him, he would be paid similarly to guys like JR Smith, Jamal Crawford, and Lou Williams who make $1-1.5M less than him. That's not insignificant, but it shouldn't make or break a team. He's not like Landy Fields or Gerald Wallace where you are paying him to sit on the bench.
If GSW takes him they want Levine and/or an unprotected first. They need someone athletic enough to check elite PGs.
lol take Love for Klay and overpaid lee, and demand their first round pick as well. DELUSIONAL
They believe Klay + Lee > Love + whoever and the make up of their team depends on a strong defensive guard to cover for Curry. Sometimes the trade doesn't fit. This isn't fantasy basketball.

 
Thompson is very replaceable on both ends of the court, and with Iguodala, they don't really even need a second lock down defender starting. Kevin Martin would be a better offensive player than Klay, and they could pick up somebody like Aminu of the trash heap to give them a better defensive player than Thompson. They would have to be choosier with matchups, but the combo of somebody like Martin and Aminu (or even Green who is already on the roster) gives them 80% of what Thompson brings, while Love is twice the player Lee is. Its ridiculous that Thompson would hold up a Love trade from GSW's end.
Losing Klay exposes Curry defensively. Iggy is a great defender against wings but not against PGs. All of the sudden Klay is a below average defender. It's like no one watched the play off series vs LAC.

And Love is a top 5-6 player but the upgrade from Lee isn't a great as you are saying. Love is as bad, if not worse, than Lee on the defensive end, and Lee, even with his big contract was an all star solely on his offensive prowess.
I've watched enough Iggy to know he is more than capable against point guards defensively. Its great having two defenders like Iggy and Thompson, but rarely do teams face two great perimeter threats, so its more of a luxury than a necessity. With the roster they have now, if the Warriors need to try to shut down two perimeter guys, Iggy and Green are a nice tandem. With Love floating way out in the perimeter, the spacing issues wouldn't be that big of a deal, especially as Iguodala is a better shooter than his reputation.

If you think Love is worse defensively than Lee, you must not have watched Lee at any point in his career. He is the James Harden equivalent of big men, he's just embarrassingly awful.

 
I don't understand the hate for Kevin Martin and his contract. Sure, hes a little overpaid, but hes still very productive. If you were setting a fair market price for him, he would be paid similarly to guys like JR Smith, Jamal Crawford, and Lou Williams who make $1-1.5M less than him. That's not insignificant, but it shouldn't make or break a team. He's not like Landy Fields or Gerald Wallace where you are paying him to sit on the bench.
If GSW takes him they want Levine and/or an unprotected first. They need someone athletic enough to check elite PGs.
lol take Love for Klay and overpaid lee, and demand their first round pick as well. DELUSIONAL
They believe Klay + Lee > Love + whoever and the make up of their team depends on a strong defensive guard to cover for Curry. Sometimes the trade doesn't fit. This isn't fantasy basketball.
Shortsighted to get that hung up on the current roster. They have a chance to pair a 24 year-old superstar with a 25-year old superstar. That's rare. They can find another defensive guard. It wouldn't even have to be a great shooter - a team with Curry and Love isn't going to have spacing issues.

 
Yeah, replacing Klay's perimeter defense would be a question. But it's not a problem that's large enough to sink the entire trade. Ultimately the positives outweigh the negatives.

 
I wouldn't say Horford is better than Love, but they're certainly in the same tier. Horford would be a better fit for the Dubs over Love. He's not a scorer, but he provides some insurance for Bogut.
Sure we'd like to have the best PF in the game, but we need to solidify backup Center first.

 
Thompson is very replaceable on both ends of the court, and with Iguodala, they don't really even need a second lock down defender starting. Kevin Martin would be a better offensive player than Klay, and they could pick up somebody like Aminu of the trash heap to give them a better defensive player than Thompson. They would have to be choosier with matchups, but the combo of somebody like Martin and Aminu (or even Green who is already on the roster) gives them 80% of what Thompson brings, while Love is twice the player Lee is. Its ridiculous that Thompson would hold up a Love trade from GSW's end.
Losing Klay exposes Curry defensively. Iggy is a great defender against wings but not against PGs. All of the sudden Klay is a below average defender. It's like no one watched the play off series vs LAC.

And Love is a top 5-6 player but the upgrade from Lee isn't a great as you are saying. Love is as bad, if not worse, than Lee on the defensive end, and Lee, even with his big contract was an all star solely on his offensive prowess.
I've watched enough Iggy to know he is more than capable against point guards defensively. Its great having two defenders like Iggy and Thompson, but rarely do teams face two great perimeter threats, so its more of a luxury than a necessity. With the roster they have now, if the Warriors need to try to shut down two perimeter guys, Iggy and Green are a nice tandem. With Love floating way out in the perimeter, the spacing issues wouldn't be that big of a deal, especially as Iguodala is a better shooter than his reputation.

If you think Love is worse defensively than Lee, you must not have watched Lee at any point in his career. He is the James Harden equivalent of big men, he's just embarrassingly awful.
Age and knee problems are beginning to take their toll on Iggy. What you watched early in his career is slightly different than the player he is now.. Agree that Green is a very good perimeter defender, but neither him nor Iggy are very well suited to shut down elite PGs.

Say what you want about Lee, at least he gives effort and will sacrifice rebounding position to make a rotation or contest a shot. Love is awful on the defensive end and is a closer comparison to Harden with his lackadaisicalness on that end.

 
-Thompson ranked 15th on GS in DRTG just ahead of Crawford, Nedovic and Dedmon.

-His DRTG (106) was far worse than the teams overall DRTG (102.6)

-He was 5th in DWS shares on the team

-5th in simple rating of guys that played over 1000 minutes

-4th worst in D-ASPM and one of 4 guys who were net negatives on defense on GS

-ESPN RPM had him 28th in the league @ SG in DRPM and he was a negative defender

Conclusion:

Lock down defender

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't understand the hate for Kevin Martin and his contract. Sure, hes a little overpaid, but hes still very productive. If you were setting a fair market price for him, he would be paid similarly to guys like JR Smith, Jamal Crawford, and Lou Williams who make $1-1.5M less than him. That's not insignificant, but it shouldn't make or break a team. He's not like Landy Fields or Gerald Wallace where you are paying him to sit on the bench.
Thank you! :coffee:

 
Juxtatarot said:
Bulls always come in 2nd in these type things.
Ever since the greatest player of all time fell to them at the #3 pick and they won 6 titles in 8 years and then subsequently won another draft lottery and drafted an MVP that poor franchise just can't seem to catch a break. :kicksrock:

 
Juxtatarot said:
Bulls always come in 2nd in these type things.
Ever since the greatest player of all time fell to them at the #3 pick and they won 6 titles in 8 years and then subsequently won another draft lottery and drafted an MVP that poor franchise just can't seem to catch a break. :kicksrock:
Lol

Meanwhile in the same arena, the Blackhawks are racking up Cups.

HOW DOES CHICAGO FAN EVEN GET UP EVERY DAY

 
-Thompson ranked 15th on GS in DRTG just ahead of Crawford, Nedovic and Dedmon.

-His DRTG (106) was far worse than the teams overall DRTG (102.6)

-He was 5th in DWS shares on the team

-5th in simple rating of guys that played over 1000 minutes

-4th worst in D-ASPM and one of 4 guys who were net negatives on defense on GS

-ESPN RPM had him 28th in the league @ SG in DRPM and he was a negative defender

Conclusion:

Lock down defender
You are right, Klay is horrible. Makes you wonder why MIN is even targeting him.

 
-Thompson ranked 15th on GS in DRTG just ahead of Crawford, Nedovic and Dedmon.

-His DRTG (106) was far worse than the teams overall DRTG (102.6)

-He was 5th in DWS shares on the team

-5th in simple rating of guys that played over 1000 minutes

-4th worst in D-ASPM and one of 4 guys who were net negatives on defense on GS

-ESPN RPM had him 28th in the league @ SG in DRPM and he was a negative defender

Conclusion:

Lock down defender
You are right, Klay is horrible. Makes you wonder why MIN is even targeting him.
I'm kind of shuked as to why they are. Getting him so they can overpay him next year and remain a bottom-feeder doesn't seem like a good plan to me :shrug:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Juxtatarot said:
Bulls always come in 2nd in these type things.
Ever since the greatest player of all time fell to them at the #3 pick and they won 6 titles in 8 years and then subsequently won another draft lottery and drafted an MVP that poor franchise just can't seem to catch a break. :kicksrock:
Lol

Meanwhile in the same arena, the Blackhawks are racking up Cups.

HOW DOES CHICAGO FAN EVEN GET UP EVERY DAY
:lmao:

 
-Thompson ranked 15th on GS in DRTG just ahead of Crawford, Nedovic and Dedmon.

-His DRTG (106) was far worse than the teams overall DRTG (102.6)

-He was 5th in DWS shares on the team

-5th in simple rating of guys that played over 1000 minutes

-4th worst in D-ASPM and one of 4 guys who were net negatives on defense on GS

-ESPN RPM had him 28th in the league @ SG in DRPM and he was a negative defender

Conclusion:

Lock down defender
You are right, Klay is horrible. Makes you wonder why MIN is even targeting him.
Yeah, some of the defensive confusion in this thread is just terrible. Even network statheads have pretty much given up on the idea of trying to quantify defensive contributions. Your individual strengths can show up better in teammates' results, since you're taking burdens off of them, and manning up against other teams' best. Your individual weaknesses, especially if they are -- like Love's -- weaknesses in quickness and athleticism, tend to collapse your team's efforts and render your teammates' efforts useless. Meaning you come off looking ok, and your teammates take the brunt of the stat hit, even though the problems lie 100% on your shoulders.

When a team builds around a Kevin Love, they design their defense around his weaknesses, design a counterattacking offense around his strengths, and at the end of the day he can look passable in the defensive half of the stat page, even though the team ends up a bottom feeder both against overall scoring in the paint, and in the standings because of it. And for the people who have played organized ball, the reasons that these problems all trail back to Love are pretty glaring.

Likewise, when a team builds around a Curry, they do everything they can to make sure he doesn't have to get annihilated out there on D. Klay ain't Iggy or Paul George, but he's doing yeoman's work against guys who would eviscerate Curry, and opponents recognize this. That's why he's in greater demand than a run of the mill three specialist, and why fans are scratching their heads that he seems to be some sort of sticking point in trade negotiations for guys who light up the stat sheet. His contributions aren't easily quantified, but they're obvious if you know what to look for. And guys like Golden State and Minnesota GM's obviously know what to look for. These people aren't idiots who don't understand Hollinger. They're experts who know that Hollinger and his lot are trying to quantify the unquantifiable.

None of that's to say Love and Curry aren't priceless. They are. And they're worth working around. But don't underestimate the statistical havoc those work-arounds can cause on the players around them, and how those same work-arounds can seem to mitigate their own deficiencies.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
-Thompson ranked 15th on GS in DRTG just ahead of Crawford, Nedovic and Dedmon.

-His DRTG (106) was far worse than the teams overall DRTG (102.6)

-He was 5th in DWS shares on the team

-5th in simple rating of guys that played over 1000 minutes

-4th worst in D-ASPM and one of 4 guys who were net negatives on defense on GS

-ESPN RPM had him 28th in the league @ SG in DRPM and he was a negative defender

Conclusion:

Lock down defender
When you have to pull out some mess called DRTG, DWS shares, D-ASPM, ESPN RPM, DRPM, and "simple rating" to make your case... you look rigadamndiculous. :shrug:

Our eyeballs tell us he is neither great nor awful on defense. This is enough.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Before this whole Klay for Love nonsense was anyone ever saying how good Klay is at defense? I recall him being an OK defender but GS fans are making him out to be like some wildebeest out there on the defensive end.
Defensive rating on whatifsports was only 51 this year.
Didnt you see that clip of Klay shutting down Chris Paul on that one play? No chance he is a 51 rating
Ricky Rubio had more all-defensive votes than Klay.

:coffee:

19-5!!!
Imagine Rubio and Wiggins. Shut down city.
You can't score on us but we can't score on you! (OK I'm mostly talking about Rubio's shooting, and Wiggins can still improve his)

 
-Thompson ranked 15th on GS in DRTG just ahead of Crawford, Nedovic and Dedmon.

-His DRTG (106) was far worse than the teams overall DRTG (102.6)

-He was 5th in DWS shares on the team

-5th in simple rating of guys that played over 1000 minutes

-4th worst in D-ASPM and one of 4 guys who were net negatives on defense on GS

-ESPN RPM had him 28th in the league @ SG in DRPM and he was a negative defender

Conclusion:

Lock down defender
When you have to pull out some mess called DRTG, DWS shares, D-ASPM, ESPN RPM, DRPM, and "simple rating" to make your case... you look rigadamndiculous. :shrug:

Our eyeballs tell us he is neither great nor awful on defense. This is enough.
Can't tell if serious or shtick.

 
-Thompson ranked 15th on GS in DRTG just ahead of Crawford, Nedovic and Dedmon.

-His DRTG (106) was far worse than the teams overall DRTG (102.6)

-He was 5th in DWS shares on the team

-5th in simple rating of guys that played over 1000 minutes

-4th worst in D-ASPM and one of 4 guys who were net negatives on defense on GS

-ESPN RPM had him 28th in the league @ SG in DRPM and he was a negative defender

Conclusion:

Lock down defender
You are right, Klay is horrible. Makes you wonder why MIN is even targeting him.
I'm kind of shuked as to why they are. Getting him so they can overpay him next year and remain a bottom-feeder doesn't seem like a good plan to me :shrug:
All part of the Flip[ master plan to drive up the bids for Love?

 
I can't wait for the season to get here, so everybody can stop worrying about this inconsequential LeBron-Love crap and focus on the Hornets, Raptors, and Wiz battling for the 1-seed.

 
I can't wait for the season to get here, so everybody can stop worrying about this inconsequential LeBron-Love crap and focus on the Hornets, Raptors, and Wiz battling for the 1-seed.
My first thought was that this would finally silence the conspiracy theory nutjobs. Then I realized that if the Eastern Conference Finals were Toronto vs Charlotte this year the conspiracy theorists would be telling us that Adam Silver fixed the playoffs to help grow the game in Canada and to get Michael Jordan back in the spotlight.

 
Does anyone have a study or article (or just info) about how much a defensive rebound is worth on a points basis? Love may not play much D, but keeping the offense from getting another shot is certainly of a quantifiable value.







 
Last edited by a moderator:
I can't wait for the season to get here, so everybody can stop worrying about this inconsequential LeBron-Love crap and focus on the Hornets, Raptors, and Wiz battling for the 1-seed.
My first thought was that this would finally silence the conspiracy theory nutjobs. Then I realized that if the Eastern Conference Finals were Toronto vs Charlotte this year the conspiracy theorists would be telling us that Adam Silver fixed the playoffs to help grow the game in Canada and to get Michael Jordan back in the spotlight.
If the NBA had it's way Cleveland will be the 4th seed and Miami the 5th.

Oh the drama. I can tell you down here all we are talking about is getting this match-up in the post season. I am sure we will probably get this in the regular season on Christmas day. I just wonder if they will make us the home team or gift wrap it for Lebron to play at home on Christmas day.

When does the schedule come out?

 
Does anyone have a study or article (or just info) about how much a defensive rebound is worth on a points basis? Love may not play much D, but keeping the offense from getting another shot is certainly of a quantifiable value.
I'm sure there are different methodologies, but this says .783 points. http://www.keeperofthecourt.com/2012/08/09/on-defensive-rebounding-and-its-impact/So by my math, Love actually averaged 117 points per game last year.

I'm also wondering why the dubs don't just flip Kevin Martin for Paul George in order to replace Thompson.

Going back to doing the Love Shuffle now. Let me know if anyone finds that frank caliendo video reading the letter.

Edit: /webrep

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Does anyone have a study or article (or just info) about how much a defensive rebound is worth on a points basis? Love may not play much D, but keeping the offense from getting another shot is certainly of a quantifiable value.
Does anyone have a study or article (or just info) about how much a defensive rebound is worth on a points basis? Love may not play much D, but keeping the offense from getting another shot is certainly of a quantifiable value.
I don't see how it can be a fixed value when you have players who obviously put forth less effort, yielding easier opportunities for their opponent, in order to maintain better rebounding position.

 
The Love experts are out. It's a wonder he gets all those rebounds with no athleticism or quickness.
It's really just cause he's standing in the paint while the other 4 guys on his team are defending. At least that's what my eyes see.
It's because he's got a really strong lower body, is excellent at understanding, establishing, and using position. Same reason he's way above average as an isolation post defender, yet his team is terrible at defending the paint. :shrug:

It's because he can't move well, and ever person in the NBA is aware of this. Fans, mostly, aren't.

 
Does anyone have a study or article (or just info) about how much a defensive rebound is worth on a points basis? Love may not play much D, but keeping the offense from getting another shot is certainly of a quantifiable value.
Does anyone have a study or article (or just info) about how much a defensive rebound is worth on a points basis? Love may not play much D, but keeping the offense from getting another shot is certainly of a quantifiable value.
I don't see how it can be a fixed value when you have players who obviously put forth less effort, yielding easier opportunities for their opponent, in order to maintain better rebounding position.
Love is also pretty cerebral in this. He's worked really hard to become an excellent outlet passer. Arguably the league's best at it. He knows (as do his coaches and teammates) that he (and they) will be giving up easy opportunities in the paint more often than other teams. They counter that by guaranteeing themselves easy opportunities in the counterattack. :shrug:

It's smart. It's a flaw that has to be accounted for and covered, either with personnel or strategy. Love's doing the best he can to maximize what he can do. Can't fault a guy for that. And he's practically unlimited offensively. Guy's a stud. A flawed stud. But still a stud.

 
My point is that getting the rebound off the shot IS a defensive measure. It changes possession and keeps the opponent from scoring, which is the goal of the defense. The difference is that it allows the D to have shot the ball in the first place. But what's better: a defender whose efforts turn a 50% shooter in to a 42% shooter or a defender whose efforts turn a 50% shooter in to a 58% shooter BUT who doesn't allow a second shot to happen? Or something like that...






 
Last edited by a moderator:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top