The other piece to keep in mind is that DB's (and CB's especially) are often the most productive in fantasy when they are borderline bench-worthy in real life. In other words, some (or I would even say "most") of the top CB's in FF are only that because they are targets to the opposing offense/QB on a weekly basis. If you can't stop the opposing WR from catching passes, you're going to get a lot of tackles as a CB. Meanwhile, there are usually some pretty good CB's (All-Pro even) who are barely rosterable in FF because opposing QB's just don't throw their way all that often.
Adadi is much closer to the former than the latter, basically. So, while he may be fantasy-relevant one minute, he may be not playing much the next.
You are spot on and Amadi brings the distinct possibility of getting benched mid-game. He will be rated highly but if there is no reason given by the person ranking him, you won’t know that. He is . . . not very good and almost got benched in my semi-final last year. He was so bad he only played like 60% of the snaps. I did not use him for the final.
You always have to watch the fine line between being slightly ineffective with tackle opportunities and getting flat out benched.
I agree one thing that factors in is Mr Norton's preseason IDP review listed him as a possible CB1 . That was why I was trying to find some local knowledge.
Yeah, if there's no context they're assuming standard leagues. This guy was one of the worst players on the field in that abomination that New Orleans threw up in Green Bay. Check that game out. It was . . . disgusting and Amadi didn't help out in any way. He's not good. Check his history. I went over it last year in a different thread. Here's what I wrote back in March about him. I'm not a local, but I have probably put more research into this guy than even the people ranking him. I'm not kidding. They don't really know. Honestly, they're good guys, but they can't account for everything and don't really take it as hard as you will when this guy gets benched or gives you a 50% snap share. But when he is in the slot in the previous (important) coaching staff's defense he did rack up points.
New coach, same talent. If you're picking him up (and I'm not saying that you shouldn't) be wary of the risk. It's pretty high variance, to say the least. They signed him to a one-year deal this offseason. I really don't want to chase you off of him and have him blow up; I just think full disclosure is in order.
New Orleans Saints defensive back Ugo Amadi committed the most egregious flop of the entire NFL season against the Green Bay Packers on Monday night. If
brobible.com
NFL and PFF player stats for New Orleans Saints CB Ugo Amadi on Pro Football Focus.
www.pff.com
Under the radar: Ugo Amadi was CB1 in my league weeks 8-18. Adebo’s gone and Amadi’s back. New DC so we can’t rely on his role being the same, but he should be rostered in case it is.
Huh. Funny. Interesting tip. Do you mind if I expound a little? I dropped him to get down to the Zealots forty-man roster. I watched him at the end of the year, and he can't cover to save his life. They wrote an article about him two days after the Saints got killed up in Green Bay and the writer was not kind to Amadi.
He was in the slot a lot, but he was only getting 50%-70% of the snaps when I...
Thanks that is the kind of info I was looking for, not always easy to get info on all players that easy. That is why I have learned that you have to really check into some of this stuff , if you just believe what you read you will most likely be wrong more times than not. With our league being a 100% keeper league sometimes landing players now can turn into gold. For example I picked up a little know DE out of Western Michigan in 2019 on waivers named Max Crosby.
You're welcome. I checked Our Lads and he's not even listed as their starter at nickel. Alontae Taylor is. I do not know if that will hold.
Great pickup in getting Crosby. I actually drafted Parsons as an LB when he came out in a tackle-heavy league and was so excited to get him. Then the transition to DL and . . . I was cursing IDP and our league until I traded him for Brian Thomas Jr., which given the disparity in offense and defense in our league was such a pull for me (at least it was last year). I was thrilled.
Good luck with your season.
u2 thx for the info
Hey, I found this. It's from a newsletter I get called "Johny The Greek's Cornerback Corner" and it discusses pretty much every cornerback in every game (if you have a dedicated CB slot to fill, I highly recommend signing up for it). He had this to say about the New Orleans corners. Note the STAR position. Muy bueno. He tells you to stay away from the guys in this game, but still gives you the analysis.
Cardinals v. Saints
Outlook: We’ve got another lower total at just 42.5 points here, and Arizona is favored by 6.5 points. The New Orleans offense has a new quarterback under center, so we’ll be ignoring last season’s pass rankings for them. Arizona was in the middle of the pack for passing yards per game last season, but only targeted their wide receivers the 29th most across the league. That’s not what we’re looking for.
Between the recent tendency we’ve seen from Arizona to be a “run first” offense and their lack of wide receiver targets last season, this setup doesn’t look great for our New Orleans corners. And for the reverse, I won’t have any Arizona corners going up against Spencer Rattler and a team that was the second worst across the league for targeting wide receivers last season (with a similar level of quarterback talent).
This one is a skip for me, but we’ll list the relevant cornerback options below as is tradition.
Arizona Cardinals
Will Johnson (CB): SIT. The rookie has great draft capital, but we’ve historically seen rookies take a few weeks to get up to the kind of playing time we find acceptable, and the matchup itself is not great at all.
Max Melton (CB): SIT, he’s probably fine if you need a warm body in much deeper leagues, but the matchup is not ideal, and his playing time and production from last season were anything but eye-watering.
Garrett Williams (CB): SOLID, much deeper leagues only due to the matchup. Williams at least played a bunch last season and had some decent weeks of production.
New Orleans Saints
Isaac Yiadom (CB): SOLID, much deeper leagues only due to the matchup. All the offseason news and depth charts I’ve consulted agree that Yiadom will be a starter; they disagree on which exact slot, though.
Koolaid McKinstry (CB): SOLID, much deeper leagues only due to the matchup, he’ll play every snap barring an injury or a blowout either way.
Alontae Taylor/Ugo Amadi (CB): SOLID, if healthy, Taylor is still nursing a groin injury and hasn’t practiced in weeks. Amadi would be his direct backup if he’s inactive. Taylor is slotted to play the STAR role for New Orleans. This role includes run defense, edge pressure, and plenty of slot snaps, according to beat writers. He would be a good start in medium to deeper leagues if he can play in Week 1.