Due to work, a lot of my subway travel over the last 10 years I was still in NY was heading home at off hours, like 2-4am. It was pretty tense at times back then and that was pre-Covid. I don't think my wife would be able to sleep at night now knowing I was coming home that way. I'd probably have to Uber just for her peace of mind.
Yikes, man... That's the magic hours of ****s gonna go down.
It definitely had its moments but I found that most people that would start **** were passed out during those times. Thankfully I never had any major incidents, at least not where I was directly involved.
Moved there in 2004, I always was very forgiving of the subway, and I never worried about criminals because there's usually easier prey around than me. But crazy doesn't care about picking fights. Crazy will fight anyone, and there's a lot more crazy. Whether they are crazy, or sane people on drugs doesn't really matter.
Off hour subway is much worse than before Sandy/Covid. If you rely on the trains regularly outside of the 7 am-9 pm hours, you may have to adapt on the regular. Lot of shutdowns, someone is always running on a different line, or skipping stations, on and on. You always had this, but now it's moreso.
If you catching a sorth/south line in Manhattan during regular business hours, you good still, I assume.
I rode the trains after midnight in 2005, and 2023, and it's not even comparable.