What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

***New York*** (1 Viewer)

Pulled the trigger on Columbus Day trip to NYC for fun with the kids.  Plenty of time to work out a rough itinerary, but I'd welcome some thoughts on where to stay as I look into airBNB type places.  My kids are 8 and 10.  Plan to be tourists for the weekend, hitting the usual beats (SOL, Broadway show, Times Square) and food experiences.

I've been to Manhattan several times, but have mostly stayed in Mid-town hotels for work.  What neighborhoods would you recommend to look at where we can have easy access to subway, feel comfortable walking down the street to bars, cafes and kids are generally comfortable? We will be staying 4 nights and would rather be among locals than in mega hotel chain.  

My sense is that Gramercy or East Village would be good, but I'm open to ideas. I think I'd prefer to stay in Manhattan than trying to save a buck.
Times Square, eh. Dirty again, unfortunately.

I'd be looking to be close to CPS and 5th Ave with kids, imo.

 
I don't dine out for Italian much but when I do it's normally at Supper in the East Village.  Not an old school red sauce joint but I enjoy the food and atmosphere.   You could also completely sell out and just kick it at Eataly ;)
literally around the corner from me- one of the many spots I was referencing earlier.

 
Pulled the trigger on Columbus Day trip to NYC for fun with the kids.  Plenty of time to work out a rough itinerary, but I'd welcome some thoughts on where to stay as I look into airBNB type places.  My kids are 8 and 10.  Plan to be tourists for the weekend, hitting the usual beats (SOL, Broadway show, Times Square) and food experiences.

I've been to Manhattan several times, but have mostly stayed in Mid-town hotels for work.  What neighborhoods would you recommend to look at where we can have easy access to subway, feel comfortable walking down the street to bars, cafes and kids are generally comfortable? We will be staying 4 nights and would rather be among locals than in mega hotel chain.  

My sense is that Gramercy or East Village would be good, but I'm open to ideas. I think I'd prefer to stay in Manhattan than trying to save a buck.
Soho and Union Square are your safest bets, have the most going on and centrally located.  West Village, Gramercy, East Village and Tribeca are also great choices.  Upper East and West are options but a bit bland.  You really can't lose anywhere in Manhattan but I'd avoid midtown as most areas lack that neighborhood feel.  It's all fairly safe.  I'd recommend staying between 2nd ave and 9th ave for subway purposes.    Have fun Brony!

 
thanks for the input on neighborhoods. Got some decent potential options via airBNB.  Leaning East Village, but still very open.

 
This is very-NYC specific, but the UWS elementary zoning fight has hit the bigtime:

http://www.wsj.com/articles/ideas-for-rezoning-schools-unsettle-upper-west-side-1468545732

Little Sammyinho is in the G&T program in 166 for next year.  We live in 452's current zone (in the same building with crazy Caroline who made the stupid Schwab House posting though I don't know that I would call the building upscale).  To show you how things change.  I now want 452 moved since 166 would now pick up some of 9's zone (more wealthier families) and the building would revert to 87 (which is where it was to begin with 6 years ago).  

Keep in mind all this is to divvy up the Amsterdam housing project which is at the furthest southern part of the district.  

Just another aside everything south of 70th on the Hudson is a luxury Trump building, most currently zoned to 199.  The apartments in those buildings are already taking a hit in price with the Trump name (it doesn't help that the 1BR and 2BR are small and the buildings are out of the way) and this won't help as they'll get put with 191 going forward.   

 
This is very-NYC specific, but the UWS elementary zoning fight has hit the bigtime:

http://www.wsj.com/articles/ideas-for-rezoning-schools-unsettle-upper-west-side-1468545732

Little Sammyinho is in the G&T program in 166 for next year.  We live in 452's current zone (in the same building with crazy Caroline who made the stupid Schwab House posting though I don't know that I would call the building upscale).  To show you how things change.  I now want 452 moved since 166 would now pick up some of 9's zone (more wealthier families) and the building would revert to 87 (which is where it was to begin with 6 years ago).  

Keep in mind all this is to divvy up the Amsterdam housing project which is at the furthest southern part of the district.  

Just another aside everything south of 70th on the Hudson is a luxury Trump building, most currently zoned to 199.  The apartments in those buildings are already taking a hit in price with the Trump name (it doesn't help that the 1BR and 2BR are small and the buildings are out of the way) and this won't help as they'll get put with 191 going forward.   
Unreal. Jacking around families that may have made their biggest life decision (where to buy) based on the zoning. 

 
This is very-NYC specific, but the UWS elementary zoning fight has hit the bigtime:

http://www.wsj.com/articles/ideas-for-rezoning-schools-unsettle-upper-west-side-1468545732

Little Sammyinho is in the G&T program in 166 for next year.  We live in 452's current zone (in the same building with crazy Caroline who made the stupid Schwab House posting though I don't know that I would call the building upscale).  To show you how things change.  I now want 452 moved since 166 would now pick up some of 9's zone (more wealthier families) and the building would revert to 87 (which is where it was to begin with 6 years ago).  

Keep in mind all this is to divvy up the Amsterdam housing project which is at the furthest southern part of the district.  

Just another aside everything south of 70th on the Hudson is a luxury Trump building, most currently zoned to 199.  The apartments in those buildings are already taking a hit in price with the Trump name (it doesn't help that the 1BR and 2BR are small and the buildings are out of the way) and this won't help as they'll get put with 191 going forward.   
:loco:

 
any mention of who's going to be playing? could be some good local and far away talent for it...
only seeing 'Straight to Hell' tribute band thus far, but my ex hit this last year and said they were damn good 

but, Joe's birthday ... Brooklyn ... who knows who might pop in for a set, or two  :shrug:

gonna be hitting it w/a few mates from the old 'hood, sounds like a cool evening.  

 
just looked at RUSF's (eta: nope... RC94, not RUSF) restaurant master list, linked in the OP, page 1... mentions Vincent's on Mott st. 

I've never been- but thought I'd throw it out there. also wanted to give a big up to the man for that list... still really relevant 5 years later, even if some of the spots have gone.
I recently changed my avatar to a picture of the World Trade Center - v1 so that may be part of the mix-up.  It's been years since I have updated that list but I was actually thinking about  adding to it a few weeks ago.  I know there are several I would add.  I am open to other suggestions. 

If you guys want to add to the list, please give me the name of the restaurant and a link to the yelp page so people can follow that to the restaurant's website and other info and I will make some edits to that list.

 
but, money
New York is expensive in general, but if you are going to spend money on something it's worth it to spend it on transportation from and back to the airport.  I think you maybe save something like $40 by taking public transportation so it's not going to make much of a difference on your money situation.

 
Adding Vincent's, Il Mulino, and Il Cortile to the list.
Il Mulino is good, but not that spectacular IMO. If you want Italian and that's your price range, check out Carbone. It's overpriced just like Il Mulino, but the food is top notch.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Pulled the trigger on Columbus Day trip to NYC for fun with the kids.  Plenty of time to work out a rough itinerary, but I'd welcome some thoughts on where to stay as I look into airBNB type places.  My kids are 8 and 10.  Plan to be tourists for the weekend, hitting the usual beats (SOL, Broadway show, Times Square) and food experiences.

I've been to Manhattan several times, but have mostly stayed in Mid-town hotels for work.  What neighborhoods would you recommend to look at where we can have easy access to subway, feel comfortable walking down the street to bars, cafes and kids are generally comfortable? We will be staying 4 nights and would rather be among locals than in mega hotel chain.  

My sense is that Gramercy or East Village would be good, but I'm open to ideas. I think I'd prefer to stay in Manhattan than trying to save a buck.
I might be a contrarian with this recommendation, but consider the Financial District. Not touristy, every subway in NYC at Fulton St, quiet after 6pm, close to Brooklyn (Brooklyn Bridge Park is a must IMO with family), and an overall cool area. Also close to Battery Park/Statue of Liberty.

 
I might be a contrarian with this recommendation, but consider the Financial District. Not touristy, every subway in NYC at Fulton St, quiet after 6pm, close to Brooklyn (Brooklyn Bridge Park is a must IMO with family), and an overall cool area. Also close to Battery Park/Statue of Liberty.
Good Christ no.  

 
Back when I was like 23 and saving every penny, I tried train to bus to LGA...

Unless you're homeless, I agree with Major, what a ####### disaster.

 
New York is expensive in general, but if you are going to spend money on something it's worth it to spend it on transportation from and back to the airport.  I think you maybe save something like $40 by taking public transportation so it's not going to make much of a difference on your money situation.
Plus, if its more than just one person, cabs become competitive with public transportation rather quickly.  

 
I might be a contrarian with this recommendation, but consider the Financial District. Not touristy, every subway in NYC at Fulton St, quiet after 6pm, close to Brooklyn (Brooklyn Bridge Park is a must IMO with family), and an overall cool area. Also close to Battery Park/Statue of Liberty.
I could see it.  Nothing much to do in the area, but its certainly easy to get around from there.  Plus, it's pretty eerie on Sundays.  

 
Furls- there's a spot in hunts point where you can ride share... kinda like hitch-hiking. you might even make a buck or two out of it.

 
Furls- there's a spot in hunts point where you can ride share... kinda like hitch-hiking. you might even make a buck or two out of it.
Lol.  If that doesn't work, heard good things about Uber's carpool option.  Haven't used it but seems like it could save you some cash from the airport.  

 
Sandy Hook beaches... anybody been? which one do you prefer? we'll be taking our 5 and 9yos and knowing my wife, enough food for them to feed a football team.

 
Also... just got a text from a group of my HS friends- guys I partied with constantly but weren't in my immediate circle- who are in town for the Giants/Yankees series. they're air bnbing it in the EVil. I'm going to be drinking a lot this weekend.

 
Sandy Hook beaches... anybody been? which one do you prefer? we'll be taking our 5 and 9yos and knowing my wife, enough food for them to feed a football team.
Why Sandy Hook? I know quite a lot about the area...

Assuming you're taking a ferry and Sandy Hook looks convenient from there? Correct me if I'm wrong...

Anyways, if this is the case, I'd recommend going south instead of north from the ferry. Check out Sea Bright, much better IMO. If you head a little further south, Avon and Belmar are also nice. 

Although with the family Id prob do Avon over Belmar, but prob Sea Bright over both. Long Branch is really a cool little beach/town too. It was kinda ####ty 20 years ago, but they've done a great job building it up. 

 
FC..we're taking the ferry,  so its sandy hook..Was looking for advice about which specific beach in sandy hook.

We go to Ocean Grove for nj beach. Big fan.

 
Why Sandy Hook? I know quite a lot about the area...

Assuming you're taking a ferry and Sandy Hook looks convenient from there? Correct me if I'm wrong...

Anyways, if this is the case, I'd recommend going south instead of north from the ferry. Check out Sea Bright, much better IMO. If you head a little further south, Avon and Belmar are also nice. 

Although with the family Id prob do Avon over Belmar, but prob Sea Bright over both. Long Branch is really a cool little beach/town too. It was kinda ####ty 20 years ago, but they've done a great job building it up. 
ok- just got back.

being able to take the ferry (from Wall St, pier 11) and 30 minutes later be at Sandy Hook itself was pretty awesome. rangers and internet research said to go to Beach D for families... so we waited for the shuttle bus. not a long wait, but long enough in the heat. Beach D was packed- like, Coney Island packed, with dueling music boom boxes, towels/umbrellas on top of each other and way too much garbage (no garbage cans). you literally had to make wide circumnavigations around the density of camped out people just to get to the water. beach was meh (lots of shells/stones so not clean and soft, water was nice to get into on a hot day, not too wavey (but no flotation devices allowed for little ones, which sucked) but oddly green/brown and colder than last weekend's trip to Ocean Grove. 

we decided to skip out a little earlier for the 3-something ferry instead of the 5-something ferry, given the crowd of people waiting for the shuttle buses when we got off the ferry. so we got back on line and waited for the shuttle bus... about 20 minutes and the line was huge- barely got on the bus. then we got out to wait for the ferry- another 30 or so minutes in the backing sun and again, the line was already huge to get on the ferry. 

if it wasn't so hot, the waiting might not have been so bad... but I'm not a fan of waiting in lines like this regardless. very cool to be able to take an easy (but relatively pricey) ferry-ride, very cool to able to see the city from the beach, but overall the experience was not one we'll likely repeat. other beaches we prefer with nicer water, beach, crowds and amenities. I think being a hostage to the shuttle bus and then the ferry were a bit much for us. (caveat- this might have been better at the walkable North Beach which I heard was also less crowded)

 
Why Sandy Hook? I know quite a lot about the area...

Assuming you're taking a ferry and Sandy Hook looks convenient from there? Correct me if I'm wrong...

Anyways, if this is the case, I'd recommend going south instead of north from the ferry. Check out Sea Bright, much better IMO. If you head a little further south, Avon and Belmar are also nice. 

Although with the family Id prob do Avon over Belmar, but prob Sea Bright over both. Long Branch is really a cool little beach/town too. It was kinda ####ty 20 years ago, but they've done a great job building it up. 
just curious- how were we supposed to get to those places from the ferry?

 
I didn't want to rain on your parade, but now that it's over and you won't be returning, I'll say it less gently... Sandy Hook kinda stinks. Of all the beaches in NJ, that's near the bottom of my list in almost all categories. 

I've prob been to the jersey shore 1000x, and the beaches that are all 10-30 minutes south of there are soooooo much better. Sea Bright is really nice, as is Long Branch (two beach 2-3 miles north of Ocean Grove), Ocean Grove (as you mentioned), and Avon/Bradley/Belmar (3 beaches immediately south of Ocean Grove). 

Ferry makes for an expensive day (family of 4 prob in $150 range round trip), but you could Uber from the ferry to any of these beaches for $12-$25 bucks. As an alternative, you could also rent a car for the day for like $50-$60 bucks... Factoring tolls/gas/parking, I'd say your around $100 all-in, but sacrificing the convenience of the ferry. 

Hope your next trip out to that area is a little better. I'm confident to say that NJ has some of the best beaches on the east coast if you know what you're looking for. 

For a family vacation, I can't recommend Cape May highly enough, that place is family paradise IMO.

 
Also... just got a text from a group of my HS friends- guys I partied with constantly but weren't in my immediate circle- who are in town for the Giants/Yankees series. they're air bnbing it in the EVil. I'm going to be drinking a lot this weekend.
Yeah. Herro.

 
Back when I was like 23 and saving every penny, I tried train to bus to LGA...

Unless you're homeless, I agree with Major, what a ####### disaster.
Can you guys be more specific on what the issue is with doing this?  We've been in Manhattan for 5 days and been taking the subway with no issues.  Is it the bus part of the trip?  What about taking the M as close as possible to the airport and then doing Uber?  

Absolutely love the city - first time visiting and it's incredible.  Was going to post some trip highlights when I get back - this thread and My GB Kutta were a big help in our planning.

 
Can you guys be more specific on what the issue is with doing this?  We've been in Manhattan for 5 days and been taking the subway with no issues.  Is it the bus part of the trip?  What about taking the M as close as possible to the airport and then doing Uber?  

Absolutely love the city - first time visiting and it's incredible.  Was going to post some trip highlights when I get back - this thread and My GB Kutta were a big help in our planning.
How much gear so you have? Schlepping luggage from train to bus to terminal is a pain. If I recall there are quite few stairs. It's also slow as frak. 

 
How much gear so you have? Schlepping luggage from train to bus to terminal is a pain. If I recall there are quite few stairs. It's also slow as frak. 
3 suitcases that I will check.  I'm a block from the M line - I'm traveling on a Tueaday - based on what I've seen I'm not too worried about getting on the train.  Coming out of the subway will be a PITA.  Do the buses have luggage areas underneath?  That would suck if not.  What about when they drop you at the terminal - is baggage check not there?  Will be first time flying out of LGA so not sure where it is.

 
3 suitcases that I will check.  I'm a block from the M line - I'm traveling on a Tueaday - based on what I've seen I'm not too worried about getting on the train.  Coming out of the subway will be a PITA.  Do the buses have luggage areas underneath?  That would suck if not.  What about when they drop you at the terminal - is baggage check not there?  Will be first time flying out of LGA so not sure where it is.
It's a city bus so no, I don't believe there is a luggage compartment. Bite the bulletin, take a cab from your curb to curb side check. Thank us later!

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top