NFL MVP after 5 weeks? (1 Viewer)

[Wingnut]

Why are so many people questioning the Poll master??

His poll, his rules.

It aint rocket surgery.

for the record...the "Poll master" is ***officially*** Fullback Fro

you must be able to make a working poll to be a master

557 requests says otherwise.And if it pleases the Shark Pool, change "master" to "meister". Poll Meister. Zat better?

 

[PennOaks]

I voted other, Peyton Manning would get my vote. He is undefeated and is involving more of his team this season. He may not be posting extraordinary numbers but he is winning.

 

[bicycle_seat_sniffer]

Did the playoffs start yet???

NO

The question is: If the season ended today(meaning, yes, the playoffs are about to start) then who is the MVP?

There is the flaw in your poll then.#1 - Seattle and SD are one game apart.

#2 - their stats are similar, I think LT is doing it while playing in the tougher AFC.

This award usually goes to a QB anyway, but I'd vote LT if I had a vote, and it look like about 30 other people agree.

 

[Wingnut]

I voted other, Peyton Manning would get my vote. He is undefeated and is involving more of his team this season. He may not be posting extraordinary numbers but he is winning.

But who are they leaning on when the passing game isnt in high gear? Edge and the defense. I dont know that Manning is the MVP of his own team this year (so far), let alone the league.

 

[Vykng]

#1 Shaun Alexander#2 Carson Palmer#3 Edgerrin James#4 Dwight FreeneyHonorable Mention = Cato June.Overrated Mention = LT, GREAT Player but IF the Season ended today no way would he get MVP.

 

[Stinger Ray]

Did the playoffs start yet???

NO

The question is: If the season ended today(meaning, yes, the playoffs are about to start) then who is the MVP?

There is the flaw in your poll then.#1 - Seattle and SD are one game apart.

#2 - their stats are similar, I think LT is doing it while playing in the tougher AFC.

This award usually goes to a QB anyway, but I'd vote LT if I had a vote, and it look like about 30 other people agree.

how is #1 a flaw? they play in different conferences and their records compared to each other is irrelevant in a playoff picture.

 

[jwvdcw]

Why are so many people questioning the Poll master??

His poll, his rules.

It aint rocket surgery.

for the record...the "Poll master" is ***officially*** Fullback Fro

you must be able to make a working poll to be a master

557 requests says otherwise.And if it pleases the Shark Pool, change "master" to "meister". Poll Meister. Zat better?

 

[salty dawg]

I'm a Vikings fan and i have to go with the Bears QB Rex Grossman. He has been dominant the whole year so far.

 

[boubucarow]

I'm a Vikings fan and i have to go with the Bears QB Rex Grossman. He has been dominant the whole year so far.

My reply to that is that this thread is from last year.

 

[Wingnut]

I'm a Vikings fan and i have to go with the Bears QB Rex Grossman. He has been dominant the whole year so far.

 

[Golden]

grossman

 

[Marc Levin]

I'm a Vikings fan and i have to go with the Bears QB Rex Grossman. He has been dominant the whole year so far.

My reply to that is that this thread is from last year.

Buh-bye, thread.