This is a good problem to have, friends
Posted on July 11th, 2008 – 9:15 AM
By Howard
Star & Tribune
So there’s been some concern throughout the Territory about what to do when Michael Cuddyer returns to health because the Twins will, at that time, have four outfielders who are being judged capable of full-time play. In some circles, this is being described as a headache. In Section 220, this is called a reason to celebrate.
I mean, really, are our memories so short that we forget when the Twins felt like they had no alternative to starting Jason Tyner, Lew Ford or Rondell White in the outfield? Or, if you go back a few years, hoping that Michael Cuddyer would finally find a position after proving himself less than stellar in the infield. Fortunately, right field worked for him.
At this point, it is obvious that only a fool would return Denard Span to the minors. His performance Thursday — triple, three singles, walk — jolted his offensive numbers to .361 average/.466 on-base percentage/.475 slugging percentage. Granted, we’re talking about 75 plate appearances — but even a 100-point dropoff in OBP would put him fourth among the current everyday players behind Mauer, Morneau and Otnup Kcin.
What to do with four starting outfielders? Play three and have a weapon on the bench.
Against lefties, you can have all four of ‘em in the lineup. Yes, I know this turns Jason Kubel back into a platoon DH and relegates Craig Monroe to the status of exalted pinch hitter. But good teams have those weapons — guys who can come off the bench and deliver and, yes, guys who would likely be starting for other teams. Think about it: When was the last time the Twins had a player sitting on the bench who would be a starter elsewhere?
Gonna try some understatement here: I’m OK with that.
Today it’s being reported that Cuddyer’s finger-injury comeback is being delayed and that he’s frustrated. I feel his frustration and I want him back. But if the Denard debut isn’t a total illusion, everyone is going to have to understand that things have changed in the last few weeks — and for the better.
The good news is that, based on the way he handled Fenway’s right field, Span should be able to play all three outfield positions. In a week of baseball, there are 21 outfield spots. In a pure rotation of some sort, which isn’t going to happen, that’s “5.25 starts per week” for each player. Throw in starts against lefties and adjust for who’s hot and who may need a day — and the Twins should consider themselves outfield enhanced when Cuddyer is fit to play.
That would also be the cue for the Twins to go with 11 pitchers through the end of August and get Brian Bass back to Rochester, even though it includes the risk of losing him to another team via waivers.
For the sake of discussion, the Twins could field a batting order that looks like this: Span, rf; Casilla, 2b; Mauer, c; Morneau, 1b, Young, lf; Kubel/Cuddyer, dh; Buscher/Harris, 3b; Otnup Kcin, ss; Gomez, cf.
Then, the bench would include Cuddyer/Kubel, Harris/Buscher, Monroe, Redmond and Lamb.
Compare that bench to these:
2007: Tyner, Cheerful Jeff Cirillo, Luis Rodriguez, White, Ford, Redmond.
2006: Kubel, Tyner, Rodriguez, JuanCastro and the washed-up cast of Ruben Sierra/Phil Nevin/Tony Batista.
2005: Matt Lecroy, Castro, Rodriguez, Redmond, Terry Tiffee, Mike Ryan.
So what, exactly, is the headache?
A few other thoughts:
*Yes, Span has made some baserunning mistakes — especially the steal of second when Mauer was batting in the 10th yesterday. But I get the sense that he’s a quick study. After watching him play Fenway’s odd right field, I’m wondering what he did before the games started to figure things out.
*Justin Morneau is a game-changing monster: Second in RBI, third in average, 4th in hits and more than holding his own against lefties. The Twins are a rare team that can bat lefties No. 3 and 4 and dare the opposing manager to bring in the Bobby Seays of the world.
*Matt Guerrier is a class act, both in the way he handled his failure on Tuesday in Boston and in the way he bailed out the Twins yesterday afternoon by pitching the 10th and 11th. (Interesting to see Gardy go against the “book” by bringing in Nathan to pitch the bottom of the ninth in a tie game on the road, which was obviously the right time to break that “rule.”) Here’s a Guerrier stat: Since May 1, he’s allowed no runners or one runner in 25 of his 33 appearances. That’s pretty good shutdown work.
Good problem to have