fatness said:
Have a WR corps of Moss, ARE, and Caldwell/Rookie/Mix would be decent.
I don't agree. Considering how much he's hurt, Moss is about an average WR#1 at best. Randle El is a below average WR#2. Caldwell/Mix are at best an average WR#3, and perhaps worse than that. A rookie is just an unknown at this time.
I think its decent, not good and by no means great. Considering the alternative of not having an experienced guy like Caldwell there, it definately looks decent to me. Would I rather see them have different WRs all together? Perhaps, but I don't see that as a realistic option. Also, I think you're selling ARE short as a below average #2. I thought he played pretty well last year. He's not a prototypical possession type #2 WR, but to call him a below average #2 is selling him short imo. Take a look at a few #2 WRs from the NFC. Crayton, Toomer, Reggie Brown, Berrian, Brandon Lloyd, Ike Hilliard, Hackett, Driver, Lance Moore, Horn/Jenkins, Engram, Boldin, Bruce and Bennett. ARE fits somewhere in the middle of the pack there. He's certainly not better than Boldin, Driver or Berrian, but he certainly is better than Lloyd, Lance Moore, Horn/Jenkins, and Hilliard. The rest I think are comparable but could be argued one way or the other.