Anyway, that is my story. People who adopt are seriously fantastic. Kudos to all of you.
Believe me, I'm not criticizing you or pissing on your post. But this comment did bring up an interesting point that I thought I'd share. My wife and I adopted our son a couple of years ago and went through the whole international process.Anyway, I just think you have to be careful heaping praise on people who choose to adopt. I know what you're trying to say, and again, I don't disagree with your sentiment, but when people praise others for adopting it starts to head down the slippery slope of praising them for "saving some child."
Maybe in your brother's case, that's exactly what happened. I'm not disputing that or saying that adoption isn't good. But the unintended side effect of those types of comments can put undue pressure on some children who are adopted because they then feel like they have to "live up to" that great thing their parents did by adopting them. If they're told by people how lucky they are to have been adopted and removed from a supposedly bad situation, for instance, that can have negative side effects too.
I think the thing that needs to be focused on is how lucky we parents are that decided to adopt and that the option is out there for us. That's my only point. I don't think people who decide to adopt are any "better" than people who choose to have a biological child.
There are right and wrong ways to convey any point. I agree with you to the extent that you want the child first and foremost to believe he/she's "normal", and no different in any meaningful way from any other child. That's why they're now advocating that you talk about adoption with your child from the beginning, and add more detail to the story as they grow up and mature, and are capable of understanding and processing the information. OTOH, "adoption" still has social stigma attached to it, and that needs to be countered. Your adopted child
will be the exception (even though far more people are adopted than we usually suspect), and they need to know that they're special too and that their adoptive parents' relationship with them is no less special than biological parents'. How are you going to convey that without telling the child that you
did in fact choose them?
The fact is that my wife and I
did do something special with our son. We went from being DINK's to being parents literally overnight. Neither of us is looking for a medal and we're not heroes, but that's the way it happened and that's the story of our child's life. We're not going to lie to him.