Dan Balz's Take
Decision Time for Clinton
By Dan Balz
Hillary Clinton arrived back in Washington early Wednesday morning after a tumultuous and deeply disappointing Tuesday night with no good options, just hard decisions.
The irony is that she produced the split decision in Indiana and North Carolina that everyone said would be enough to keep her candidacy alive. The cruelty is that the "experts" were wrong. By the time she was declared the winner in Indiana, it was clear she had lost virtually all room to maneuver.
I sent a message to one of her most loyal supporters early Wednesday morning asking what are her realistic options? "She has only one option," he replied. "Gracefully exit and help unify the party to beat [John] McCain." How quickly, he was asked. "I would advise them to figure out how to do it as soon as this weekend," he replied.
Another veteran Democrat who has backed Clinton was equally pessimistic in his private assessment. "It's hard to see a path toward the twin goals of Hillary winning and the party uniting," he wrote. "Her strategy cannot be to destroy the village in order to save it. The superdelegate dam is about to break. Hillary losing [George] McGovern is like LBJ losing [former CBS News anchor Walter] Cronkite."
Dealing in analogies of unwinnable wars is where the Clinton camp found itself Wednesday morning. What was mostly implausible on Monday appeared even more implausible Wednesday.
The decision by McGovern, the party's 1972 nominee, to defect to Obama represented a major psychological blow to Clinton's candidacy. On the October day when he endorsed Clinton, McGovern told me he regarded Obama as "another Lincoln." He had decided to support Clinton because he believed Obama was young enough to have a long future -- and, in his estimation, because he believed Clinton could be a better president than was her husband.
At the time, his decision was a blow to the Obama camp, where officials had hoped his obvious admiration for the Illinois senator would translate into a high-profile endorsement. Now McGovern sees Clinton's continued candidacy as a threat to party unity and to the Democrats' chances of winning in November. Clinton's desire to keep going will run smack into that sentiment in many corners of the party.
Two other Democrats described Clinton's options is dire terms. "Withdraw with honor and grace, or lose without either, forever cementing her -- their -- image as selfish, indifferent to party or cause," wrote one of them. The other put it this way: "Wait for him to blow up, which is unlikely given his track record. Or, blow up the party, which party leaders are unlikely to let her do."
Two Democrats made a similar point, which is that that race did not change fundamentally as a result of what happened in Indiana and North Carolina, and yet Clinton emerged in far worse shape than she was the day before the voting.
"The race is, as it has been for some time, in the hands of the superdelegates," wrote Mark Mellman, a Democratic pollster. "They seem inclined to support the candidate who wins the most pledged delegates, which will be Obama. To shake that psychology she has to demonstrate that Obama is unelectable. She failed to do that last night, and doesn't have many other opportunities. So at this point she seems largely dependent on a direct, clarion call from Heaven -- which could take the form of a ghastly, but highly unlikely, mistake by Obama."
The other strategist, Jonathan Prince, who was a top adviser to John Edwards's campaign, agreed that the fundamentals Wednesday were as they had been Tuesday: Obama was and is ahead in the delegate count; both still need superdelegates to win the nomination. To gain the nomination she needed and still needs to convince superdelegates that he is a risky choice. To do that, she would try to point to continued victories and Obama's continued weaknesses among white, working-class voters
"Now, that imagined scenario is off the table," he wrote. "Which leaves only this one -- stay in the game, stay focused and hope that he raises doubts again so she can convince superdelegates he's too risky. Basically, she needs an extra-electoral event to push super-
delegates her way (extra as in extra-terrestrial)."
The options are limited for Clinton because she is at a huge financial disadvantage. The campaign announced that she has loaned her campaign another $6.4 million, on top of the $5 million she provided in January. But she will be no match for Obama. As one strategist put it months ago, the one reason candidates quit campaigns is that they run out of money. Clinton could face that in the weeks ahead.
Her route to the nomination also depends on a favorable resolution to the question of seating the Florida and Michigan delegations -- and counting their votes in the tally of popular votes. The Democratic Committee's Rules and Bylaws Committee does not meet until May 31 to try to deal with that problem. Given Clinton's precarious situation, it is more difficult to envision an outcome that is as favorable as Clinton needs.
The last six states will award just 217 pledged delegates and there is no realistic prospect for Clinton to overtake Obama in that count. That leaves it up to superdelegates. Clinton will meet with a group of them on Wednesday and Obama will meet with a group on Thursday.
Pat Eddington, a former DNC member from Alabama who was in town for Clinton's Wednesday fundraiser, said the New York senator should stay in the race through the end of the primaries, in part to give the remaining states a chance to participate. Calls from Clinton supporters back home were almost unanimous in that view, she said.
Eddington is an old friend of Clinton's and has raised more than $300,000 for the campaign. She believes that, whether in the White House or in the Senate, Clinton will go down as "one of the greatest fighters" the party has ever seen.
But even in encouraging Clinton to stay in, she does not discount how dire her situation is now -- or the care that must be exercised in the days ahead. "She has to be very positive from this point on." Eddington said.
Eddington, like other Democratic insiders, does not want to see the party ruptured by this battle, and she made clear she would be ready to rally behind Obama at an appropriate time. "I am for Hillary," she said. "
But if Obama is the nominee, you will think I gave birth to him."
(

)
No one will try to force Clinton out of the race. Campaigning in West Virginia early Wednesday afternoon, she said she would stay in "until there is a nominee." But what she needed on Tuesday did not happen, and she must now rewrite her script for the final stage of the nomination campaign.