JohnnyU
Footballguy
I would rather see what else I could get for a first round pick, but I've never been a Kirk fan. Once these things get into your brain it's hard to purge it.
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
****OFFICIAL DYNASTY TRADES**** (10 Viewers)
- Thread starter Gottabesweet
- Start date
Ridgeback
Footballguy
I think Kirk's a very underrated WR2, but I'm sure his opportunity is about as good as it's going to get in JAX. Next year, whether it be Ridley or someone else, the targets will be taken from him. I'm at least 2 years away from sniffing the playoffs again, and by that time he will have lost that much more value.
barackdhouse
Footballguy
I did another deal with them
I gave Breece Hall, Gabe Davis (ever heard of my love for him?)
I got 2023 1st (strong candidate for 1.01), 2023 1st (the same late one from trade above)
barackdhouse
Footballguy
great price for him
JohnnyU
Footballguy
12 team ppr dynasty picked off ww then dropped, so you did well to get two 3rd rd picks.
JohnnyU
Footballguy
joey
Footballguy
Tough one since, those who drafted him in the middle of the 1st round this year probably feel like we struck gold with his few really good performances, so to give him up so soon has got to be a gut wrencher. but I can understand anyone who thinks that They’re basically get a free late 1st in this deal (if you agree that Pickens = 1st)
flapgreen
Footballguy
Our draft was a week after the NFL draft, so I got him middle of the 2nd with the 18th pick. I'm also without a first at the moment because I needed a qb badly and traded mine for Hurts.
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
Love Pickens, but you have to smash accept on that deal. Way too much value in the 23 draft to miss out on two picks for a good WR in a sketchy QB situation.
mashedbananas
Footballguy
Superflex and TE Premium, 12 team 28 man rosters (no IR slots). 1 QB, 2RB, 3WR, 1TE, 1 SuperFlex, 2 FLex
After taking a very deep breath, and realizing my team is currently the 3rd worst in the league...
I traded Patrick Mahomes (ouch)
I got 3 First Round Rookie picks and Wan'Dale Robinson. If the draft was right now, those first round picks would be 1.02, 1.08, 1.10 and I still have my 1.03, 2.03, 3.03 and 4.03
After taking a very deep breath, and realizing my team is currently the 3rd worst in the league...
I traded Patrick Mahomes (ouch)
I got 3 First Round Rookie picks and Wan'Dale Robinson. If the draft was right now, those first round picks would be 1.02, 1.08, 1.10 and I still have my 1.03, 2.03, 3.03 and 4.03
Boston
Footballguy
Who are your other QBs?
mashedbananas
Footballguy
Who are your other QBs? |
TartanLion
Footballguy
SuperFlex. Beset by injuries and a chronic QB situation, I wanted a quick re-tool for next year. Currently 2-9. Got 2 ‘23 1st rounders already and both likely top 5
Qb - Geno Smith/Lance/ Brissett/Dalton, Heinicke ( apart from Lance all off of waiver wire )
RB - Kamara/Etienne/Dobbins/Akers/Penny/Pacheco/Algieier/some others
WR - Deebo/Pittman/Gabe Davis/Lazard/Jameson Williams/Allen Robinson/Renfrow/some others
TE - Hurst/Noah Gray/Dissly/Parham/Bellinger
Traded —— Kamara for Javonte Williams and a 23 3rd
Traded —- Heinicke for 23 3rd
Traded —- Dalton for 23 4th
Get short term point getters off my team this year to help the tank and yes, Javonte Williams is a risk but 5 years younger and if he makes it back RB corps could be great
With any luck get 1 of Bryce Young/CJ Stroud
1 of Bijan Robinson/Gibbs
In rookie draft.
Qb - Geno Smith/Lance/ Brissett/Dalton, Heinicke ( apart from Lance all off of waiver wire )
RB - Kamara/Etienne/Dobbins/Akers/Penny/Pacheco/Algieier/some others
WR - Deebo/Pittman/Gabe Davis/Lazard/Jameson Williams/Allen Robinson/Renfrow/some others
TE - Hurst/Noah Gray/Dissly/Parham/Bellinger
Traded —— Kamara for Javonte Williams and a 23 3rd
Traded —- Heinicke for 23 3rd
Traded —- Dalton for 23 4th
Get short term point getters off my team this year to help the tank and yes, Javonte Williams is a risk but 5 years younger and if he makes it back RB corps could be great
With any luck get 1 of Bryce Young/CJ Stroud
1 of Bijan Robinson/Gibbs
In rookie draft.
Last edited:
BearsFan4Life
Footballguy
Got Barkley for nothing it seems to me.
barackdhouse
Footballguy
FFPC SuperFlex not involved:
Team A gave Fields, ETN
Team B gave Dak, Waddle, 2023 2nd (late)
Different FFPC SF:
I gave Hurst
I got M Gordon, 2023 3rd (early)
Different FFPC SF:
I gave Doubs, 2023 4th
I got Gesicki
FFPC 1QB:
I gave Garoppolo, 2023 5th
I got 2023 3rd (wide range)
FFPC 1QB not involved:
Team C gave Bateman, 2023 2nd (late)
Team D gave Geno
Team A gave Fields, ETN
Team B gave Dak, Waddle, 2023 2nd (late)
Different FFPC SF:
I gave Hurst
I got M Gordon, 2023 3rd (early)
Different FFPC SF:
I gave Doubs, 2023 4th
I got Gesicki
FFPC 1QB:
I gave Garoppolo, 2023 5th
I got 2023 3rd (wide range)
FFPC 1QB not involved:
Team C gave Bateman, 2023 2nd (late)
Team D gave Geno
barackdhouse
Footballguy
FFPC SuperFlex
I gave D Pierce, 2023 1st (late*), 2023 2nd (early)
I got CMC
I mean I'm in the 6 seed and CMC *should* help me make this late.
I gave D Pierce, 2023 1st (late*), 2023 2nd (early)
I got CMC
I mean I'm in the 6 seed and CMC *should* help me make this late.
Wow, that's a ton for Geno.
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Especially in a start 1QB league
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Rather have Hurst
BearsFan4Life
Footballguy
14 team .. no ppr
Chubb
for
Javonte Williams and Deebo
Chubb
for
Javonte Williams and Deebo
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Williams and Deebo by a lot. I probably wouldn’t trade either for Chubb in dynasty.
Jayded
Footballguy
Swung two deals tonight...
-----
16 team, TE Premium, Superflex, IDP (Start 11 O, 11 D)
Team A receives - Brock Bowers + Alec Pierce
Team B receives - Michael Mayer + Brandon Joseph + Kyren Williams
-----
14 team, TE Premium, Superflex, IDP (Start 11 O, 11 F)
Team A receives - AJ Brown
Team B receives - DJ Moore, Skyy Moore, Tremaine Edmunds
-----
16 team, TE Premium, Superflex, IDP (Start 11 O, 11 D)
Team A receives - Brock Bowers + Alec Pierce
Team B receives - Michael Mayer + Brandon Joseph + Kyren Williams
-----
14 team, TE Premium, Superflex, IDP (Start 11 O, 11 F)
Team A receives - AJ Brown
Team B receives - DJ Moore, Skyy Moore, Tremaine Edmunds
barackdhouse
Footballguy
FFPC SuperFlex
I gave 2023 1st (late)
I got Montgomery, 2023 3rd (early)
9-2 #1 seed but nobody else behind Jacobs.
I gave 2023 1st (late)
I got Montgomery, 2023 3rd (early)
9-2 #1 seed but nobody else behind Jacobs.
joey
Footballguy
Win Now. I like that move, especially with Herbert on IR for a bit and not stealing carries
Last edited:
ComfortablyNumb
Footballguy
In my FFPC $500 league a guy just acquired Justin Fields for Trey Lance, James Robinson, a 4th and a 6th!!
I am not happy.
I am not happy.
barackdhouse
Footballguy
FFPC 1QB (our Sharkpool League)
I gave Aiyuk
I got Mooney, Jamaal Williams, 2023 4th
currently in the 3 seed but probably the worst RB situation in my entire arsenal of teams. I like Aiyuk a bit more than Mooney but I do have Fields to stack with him so it feels right.
I gave Aiyuk
I got Mooney, Jamaal Williams, 2023 4th
currently in the 3 seed but probably the worst RB situation in my entire arsenal of teams. I like Aiyuk a bit more than Mooney but I do have Fields to stack with him so it feels right.
King of the Jungle
Footballguy
Love Aiyuk as a player but feels like there is a lot up in the air for him. They did not pay Deebo all that money to not use him and I feel like the shift to get him the ball more will happen. Throw in McCaffrey and Kittle as well and it could be tough to get consistent touches in a run first offense. Next up at QB you have to assume they shift back to Lance next year which could present another set of hurdles. I took a 2024 1st for him as I think it is a good time to unload with his recent production.
barackdhouse
Footballguy
and then I followed that up with this today:
I gave Kupp/Waller/2023 3rd (early the one from trade above)
I got Kittle/Carter/Mooney
Needed that help at TE pretty bad as well.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
16 team IDP PPR TE-P dynasty league.
My team (took it over this offseason) is among the top 8 in scoring, despite losing Lance & Hall. My record is 3-8. This week I was the 2nd highest scoring team. And lost to the highest scoring team. I’ve had not one, but TWO wins turn into losses on Thursday stat changes. Just one of those years.
Soon after taking over the team, i discovered that sacks for loss are rewarded preposterously in this league with distance scoring. Like, a sack for a loss could be as much as 20+ points. Unfortunately, my team didn’t really have many difference making DEs.
Playoff-bound team showed interest in a player, and after a couple back & forths, we got this deadline deal done:
I gave: Michael Pittman
I received: Kwity Paye, Darnell Mooney, 2023 5th, 2023 6th
I felt like this was a nice return on Pittman, and while I like Pittman, I don’t really see him as a WR1. And Ryan isn’t young, so the future at QB could be bleak in Indy.
I have Paye as a potential top 10 DE, and he’s only 24. And I like Mooney’s upside. The draft picks give me a couple of darts to throw in the draft, too.
Feeling pretty good going into next year.
My team (took it over this offseason) is among the top 8 in scoring, despite losing Lance & Hall. My record is 3-8. This week I was the 2nd highest scoring team. And lost to the highest scoring team. I’ve had not one, but TWO wins turn into losses on Thursday stat changes. Just one of those years.
Soon after taking over the team, i discovered that sacks for loss are rewarded preposterously in this league with distance scoring. Like, a sack for a loss could be as much as 20+ points. Unfortunately, my team didn’t really have many difference making DEs.
Playoff-bound team showed interest in a player, and after a couple back & forths, we got this deadline deal done:
I gave: Michael Pittman
I received: Kwity Paye, Darnell Mooney, 2023 5th, 2023 6th
I felt like this was a nice return on Pittman, and while I like Pittman, I don’t really see him as a WR1. And Ryan isn’t young, so the future at QB could be bleak in Indy.
I have Paye as a potential top 10 DE, and he’s only 24. And I like Mooney’s upside. The draft picks give me a couple of darts to throw in the draft, too.
Feeling pretty good going into next year.
Last edited:
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Aiyuk is their best WR. Deebo is a great player, but he’s not better than Aiyuk as a WR.
That said, I don’t mind that deal, though Jamaal Williams is 27, which is a little long in the tooth for a RB. Short-term, solid add though who will help.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Looks like you’re going for it. I respect that. Hard to lose Aiyuk but you’ve definitely given yourself a shot at the ‘ship with those acquisitions, but yeah - took on some aging assets to do it.
barackdhouse
Footballguy
that's a different league, the Jamaal Williams one is from a 1QB league with the Sharkpool. This series of trades above the aging asset is Kittle, who is younger than Waller.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
You slayed that deal.
Doesn’t matter what you needed, you got out of an injury prone 28 year old & landed a talented young WR & Knox. In a world of dart throw TEs, he’s one of them. lol
I like your side by a lot.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
It’s sad that only @rockaction will care about this deal.16 team IDP PPR TE-P dynasty league.
My team (took it over this offseason) is among the top 8 in scoring, despite losing Lance & Hall. My record is 3-8. This week I was the 2nd highest scoring team. And lost to the highest scoring team. I’ve had not one, but TWO wins turn into losses on Thursday stat changes. Just one of those years.
Soon after taking over the team, i discovered that sacks for loss are rewarded preposterously in this league with distance scoring. Like, a sack for a loss could be as much as 20+ points. Unfortunately, my team didn’t really have many difference making DEs.
Playoff-bound team showed interest in a player, and after a couple back & forths, we got this deadline deal done:
I gave: Michael Pittman
I received: Kwity Paye, Darnell Mooney, 2023 5th, 2023 6th
I felt like this was a nice return on Pittman, and while I like Pittman, I don’t really see him as a WR1. And Ryan isn’t young, so the future at QB could be bleak in Indy.
I have Paye as a potential top 10 DE, and he’s only 24. And I like Mooney’s upside. The draft picks give me a couple of darts to throw in the draft, too.
Feeling pretty good going into next year.
We gotta get the rest of y’all on board the IDP train. Choo chooo!
rockaction
Footballguy
It’s sad that only @rockaction will care about this deal.
I read it about twenty minutes ago and thought you gave up too much but I don't know your scoring system. Kwity Paye, I believe, had bombed out last year but is having a dynamic year this year. But I haven't followed him like I should. I also missed that you picked up Mooney, because when I see Mooney, my eyes glaze over. Now that Fields is showing signs of competence, I like this deal for you.
Pittman is walking into a terrible QB situation. But I recently gave McLaurin up for similar reasons and boy am I regretting that particular player in the deal. So. . .who knows?
But I like the deal for you if sacks are around 20 points. That's absurd, really, compared to the league I'm in. But Gally will tell you that true IDP leagues weight big plays like that.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Yeah, my redraft has sacks comparable with TD (6)
This league has the same, but every yard lost is another 3 points, and more for different positions.
Paye has been a little bit injury prone this year, and he’s not a tackle heavy guy - but this league is sack heavy scoring, and I do see him as a future elite DE. It is only his 2nd year.
joey
Footballguy
This makes no sense to me.
When both healthy, Williams and Aiyuk are probably close to equal in value (though I’d have Aiyuk ranked higher personally) and now Mike Williams proves yet again that he can’t stay on the field after only a few minutes in a game, and someone trade Aiyuk PLUS a piece for Williams? I guess that’s what makes the world go around.
King of the Jungle
Footballguy
That is the case this year, was not last year. Thing evolve and it could continue to be the case, but today does not necessarily mean it will be tomorrow. There is a lot of talent on that run first offense and I doubt Deebo continues to be as quiet as he has been.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Deebo isn’t as good a route runner & Niners drafted Aiyuk for that ridiculous wingspan / catch radius.
Deebo isn’t that guy. Totally different skill set. Complimentary, but definitely a “wideback” more than a WR.
King of the Jungle
Footballguy
I don’t disagree, but Deebo had 1400 yards receiving last year and they just paid him a boatload. I think it balances out more by end of year as Kyle can scheme whomever he wants to get the ball. Just a guess on my part. Long term is more concerning considering a QB change in a run first scheme.
PantherThunder
Footballguy
Best ball 12 team ppr league. Sitting in 6th(last) playoff spot. I figured I would get in and get beat first round. So I needed to do something. I have lost mckissic and Gordon from my rb stable. Burkhead has been disappointing this year. I have Jacobs and Chubb
Traded 23 2nd, 23 3rd, and York PK
For Latavis Murray, and Cordelle Paterson
Figure this secures my spot and gives be a punchers chance in the playoffs. If I miss then I should be a favorite in the toilet bowl to win the 13 pick(1st) or 26(2nd), and get one of my picks back
Traded 23 2nd, 23 3rd, and York PK
For Latavis Murray, and Cordelle Paterson
Figure this secures my spot and gives be a punchers chance in the playoffs. If I miss then I should be a favorite in the toilet bowl to win the 13 pick(1st) or 26(2nd), and get one of my picks back
barackdhouse
Footballguy
FFPC 1QB not involved
Team A gave TB DEF, 2023 3rd x2
Team B gave Keenan Allen
That is definitely the cheapest I've seen Allen go. *Nobody* has been buying him anywhere for a long time now going back before last season, but this is remarkably low.
Team A gave TB DEF, 2023 3rd x2
Team B gave Keenan Allen
That is definitely the cheapest I've seen Allen go. *Nobody* has been buying him anywhere for a long time now going back before last season, but this is remarkably low.
Birdie048
Footballguy
Cheap? Almost given away .... two 3rds? wow!
