What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

****OFFICIAL DYNASTY TRADES**** (38 Viewers)

12 Team SF, .5 PPR RB/WR, 1 PPR TE

Traded: Ja’Marr Chase, AJ Dillon, Ryan Tannehill, 2023 1.05, 2023 2.05

Received: Justin Fields, Christian McCaffrey, Chase Claypool
I don't play SF so I could be off on my perception... I like the Chase side by a good bit..

How I see the deal:
Tanny + 1.05 for Fields (basically even IMO)
Chase for CMC (Give me Chase, slightly)
Dillon for Claypool (Give me Dillon)
2.05 Bonus / Free / Overpay cost
This is admittedly my first SF league. I just picked up this orphan. In my 1QB dynasty league I have Chase and I love, love, love him and it would take a haul for me to move him there. In this league it still kills me to move him but I needed a QB. I’m not super high on Fields either, but Tannehill feels like he’s almost done to me.

I don’t value rookie picks as much as others and am notorious for moving off of them pretty quickly. At 1.05 I felt like it would be a choice of Richardson, Gibbs, or JSN to me. All fine options but I’d rather go with what I somewhat know (Fields) compared to what might be (Richardson). I never figure to end the season with anything less than a third place finish so I felt like this move helped me immensely for the upcoming season without crippling my future.

I appreciate your input and agree that I sent more value away than I received.
 
10 team SF, PPR, TEP
Team A gets: Lamar, London, and 2023 pick 1.08
Team B gets, Kyler, Njoku, Metcalf, and 2023 Pick 1.10
Oof. Two slightly problematic QBs.

I’ll take the side that has 2 healthy ACLs, and won’t need a study clause in his shiny new contract, whenever he gets one.

I like 1.08 + Metcalf a lot more than 1.10 & London, but yeah - no timetable on Murray’s recovery concerns me, and that dude concerns me when fully healthy.
 
12 Team SF, .5 PPR RB/WR, 1 PPR TE

Traded: Ja’Marr Chase, AJ Dillon, Ryan Tannehill, 2023 1.05, 2023 2.05

Received: Justin Fields, Christian McCaffrey, Chase Claypool
Blockbuster!

Man - I get it. I just don’t know if I could part with Chase. .5 PPR makes it a little easier, and obviously Fields is a massive upgrade from Tannehill.

I like AJD more than most, too.’

Congrats on getting Fields - I hope CMC has a long & productive run ahead of him.

Feels like you could have maybe been able to get this done without the 1.05 - or if you’d been able to get a better WR back than Claypool


But as someone who just paid a lot for Fields yesterday, I get it.
 
Tanny + 1.05 for Fields (basically even IMO)
Not remotely, no. lol

But it is an overpay. Which, to be fair, one often has to do to get a player like Fields, especially in SF. Otherwise where’s the owner’s incentive to click accept?
Like I posted ... I don't know SF & my QB values perception could be off ...
But I think that was a good deal for team acquiring Fields.
 
12 Team SF, .5 PPR RB/WR, 1 PPR TE

Traded: Ja’Marr Chase, AJ Dillon, Ryan Tannehill, 2023 1.05, 2023 2.05

Received: Justin Fields, Christian McCaffrey, Chase Claypool
Blockbuster!

Man - I get it. I just don’t know if I could part with Chase. .5 PPR makes it a little easier, and obviously Fields is a massive upgrade from Tannehill.

I like AJD more than most, too.’

Congrats on getting Fields - I hope CMC has a long & productive run ahead of him.

Feels like you could have maybe been able to get this done without the 1.05 - or if you’d been able to get a better WR back than Claypool


But as someone who just paid a lot for Fields yesterday, I get it.
I appreciate your insight, HSG. These types of responses were what I was expecting and I can’t say that I disagree. I guess we have a lot riding on Fields? Let’s go! 😆
 
Tanny + 1.05 for Fields (basically even IMO)
Not remotely, no. lol

But it is an overpay. Which, to be fair, one often has to do to get a player like Fields, especially in SF. Otherwise where’s the owner’s incentive to click accept?
Like I posted ... I don't know SF & my QB values perception could be off ...
But I think that was a good deal for team acquiring Fields.
I have Tannehill + 1.05 as about 1/2 of Fields value in a 12-team SF
 
I appreciate your insight, HSG. These types of responses were what I was expecting and I can’t say that I disagree. I guess we have a lot riding on Fields? Let’s go! 😆
if ya want a guy, his value is sometimes what the other manager is willing to take to part with him.

So I totally get it.

A friend in my 12-team SF blew up my texts yesterday asking why I’d pay 1.04 + 1.10, + Pacheco for Fields, and that he sees that as a “massive overpay”.

I saw it as a very slight overpay, by approximately Pacheco. Who I deemed expendable.

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. :shrug:

At the end of the day ya got your man. I just hate that it cost you Chase. But I do think Claypool has a bit of upside.

Go bears?
 
I was told there was no one trades in this league
I always take that as a personal challenge.
Same. I just joined this league a couple of days ago and have completed the trade I posted and a separate smaller deal. I also have three offers I just sent out this morning.

Gotta shake **** up! Especially when you’re the new guy.
 
Gotta shake **** up! Especially when you’re the new guy.
Surprised you didn’t get hit with a barrage of terrible offers to see if you were a sucker.

When I took over the 16-team league orphan I was very active on the “what’s the worst dynasty trade you’ve ever been offered” topic. :lol:
Oh, that was last years orphan that I took over. Everyone took a shot at Chase there. And by “shot” I mean offers that came closer to one landing Claypool than Ja’Marr.
 
Tanny + 1.05 for Fields (basically even IMO)
Not remotely, no. lol

But it is an overpay. Which, to be fair, one often has to do to get a player like Fields, especially in SF. Otherwise where’s the owner’s incentive to click accept?
Like I posted ... I don't know SF & my QB values perception could be off ...
But I think that was a good deal for team acquiring Fields.
I have Tannehill + 1.05 as about 1/2 of Fields value in a 12-team SF
That's close to what I was going to say. I think 1.01 is the only pick that gets it done this year.
 
So another trade with the same owner just went through. This one was

Traded: Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, and 2023 1.12

Received: Godwin, 2023 2.05, and 2023 2.08

So the grand total ends up being…

Traded: Chase, Dillon, Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, Tannehill, 2023 1.05, and 2023 1.12

Received: CMc, Fields, Godwin, Claypool, and 2.08

The trade calculator (I know) I use, that considers SF Dynasty, has me receiving a value of 17,863 while giving up 17,806.
 
So another trade with the same owner just went through. This one was

Traded: Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, and 2023 1.12

Received: Godwin, 2023 2.05, and 2023 2.08

So the grand total ends up being…

Traded: Chase, Dillon, Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, Tannehill, 2023 1.05, and 2023 1.12

Received: CMc, Fields, Godwin, Claypool, and 2.08

The trade calculator (I know) I use, that considers SF Dynasty, has me receiving a value of 17,863 while giving up 17,806.
Yeah looking at the earlier trade I was going to say I like it. Obviously giving up Chase is a big deal, as is the 1.05, but CMC/Fields/Godwin is a heck of a get.

Out of curiosity, you said you received the 2.05 in this latest deal but it isn't listed in the grand total. Do you not hold the 2.05 + 2.08 still?

ETA I think I get it now - you crossed out the 2.05 since you paid it once and received it once. But you do actually hold it currently, which is nicer than not.
 
So another trade with the same owner just went through. This one was

Traded: Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, and 2023 1.12

Received: Godwin, 2023 2.05, and 2023 2.08

So the grand total ends up being…

Traded: Chase, Dillon, Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, Tannehill, 2023 1.05, and 2023 1.12

Received: CMc, Fields, Godwin, Claypool, and 2.08

The trade calculator (I know) I use, that considers SF Dynasty, has me receiving a value of 17,863 while giving up 17,806.
Yeah looking at the earlier trade I was going to say I like it. Obviously giving up Chase is a big deal, as is the 1.05, but CMC/Fields/Godwin is a heck of a get.

Out of curiosity, you said you received the 2.05 in this latest deal but it isn't listed in the grand total. Do you not hold the 2.05 + 2.08 still?

ETA I think I get it now - you crossed out the 2.05 since you paid it once and received it once. But you do actually hold it currently, which is nicer than not.
You got it. Thanks for chiming in. I prefer to try and win right away in FF. It’s all about ‘ships for me. I feel that I am definitely a lot closer to achieving that goal after the moves I’ve made so far.
 
Traded: Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, and 2023 1.12

Received: Godwin, 2023 2.05, and 2023 2.08
I feel like this was a bit of an overpay as well, but again, if you like the player, there ya go. The picks help, and as I understand it this is a short bench format, so maybe Pacheco, Sutton & Chig were bubble players for you?

Here’s hoping Mayfield peppers Godwin. Of all the receivers in TB, I like his chances the best. Assuming Baker is the QB.
 
Traded: Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, and 2023 1.12

Received: Godwin, 2023 2.05, and 2023 2.08
I feel like this was a bit of an overpay as well, but again, if you like the player, there ya go. The picks help, and as I understand it this is a short bench format, so maybe Pacheco, Sutton & Chig were bubble players for you?

Here’s hoping Mayfield peppers Godwin. Of all the receivers in TB, I like his chances the best. Assuming Baker is the QB.
I get your take here. I’m hoping that the trades work out for the both of us. Like I said, I like championships, and I think I’m closer than I was before. Truthfully I’m not that high on Pacheco being the long term answer in KC and I’m down on Sutton in DEN. I like Chiggy a lot actually but I do have Pitts and Engram at the position already. The 1.12 doesn’t mean much to me all things considered.
 
16 team, non SF:

Team A gave Josh Palmer and a 2025 1st and a 2025 2nd

Team B gave 1.4 and Zach Wilson

Team A isn't very good currently, but who knows in 2025? He has 4 1s this year. Just hard for me to see giving up 1.4 for 2025 picks, but team B is in perpetual rebuild mode
 
So another trade with the same owner just went through. This one was

Traded: Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, and 2023 1.12

Received: Godwin, 2023 2.05, and 2023 2.08

So the grand total ends up being…

Traded: Chase, Dillon, Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, Tannehill, 2023 1.05, and 2023 1.12

Received: CMc, Fields, Godwin, Claypool, and 2.08

The trade calculator (I know) I use, that considers SF Dynasty, has me receiving a value of 17,863 while giving up 17,806.
Yeah looking at the earlier trade I was going to say I like it. Obviously giving up Chase is a big deal, as is the 1.05, but CMC/Fields/Godwin is a heck of a get.

Out of curiosity, you said you received the 2.05 in this latest deal but it isn't listed in the grand total. Do you not hold the 2.05 + 2.08 still?

ETA I think I get it now - you crossed out the 2.05 since you paid it once and received it once. But you do actually hold it currently, which is nicer than not.
I prefer to try and win right away in FF. It’s all about ‘ships for me.
That's how I roll, too. People can brag about their perceived murky value on paper all they want while we stack hardware.
 
Traded: Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, and 2023 1.12

Received: Godwin, 2023 2.05, and 2023 2.08
I feel like this was a bit of an overpay as well, but again, if you like the player, there ya go. The picks help, and as I understand it this is a short bench format, so maybe Pacheco, Sutton & Chig were bubble players for you?

Here’s hoping Mayfield peppers Godwin. Of all the receivers in TB, I like his chances the best. Assuming Baker is the QB.
I get your take here. I’m hoping that the trades work out for the both of us. Like I said, I like championships, and I think I’m closer than I was before. Truthfully I’m not that high on Pacheco being the long term answer in KC and I’m down on Sutton in DEN. I like Chiggy a lot actually but I do have Pitts and Engram at the position already. The 1.12 doesn’t mean much to me all things considered.
I have that second trade as the 1.12, then Okonkwo, who I like but isn't stopping anyone from acquiring Godwin, then Sutton who I think is about to wash out and is impossible to trade (so kudos on that), and Pacheco who I also think is wise to flip if possible (so kudos as well). And you got a couple current 2nds back in a deep RB class. Honestly, I think you're crushing it.
 
So another trade with the same owner just went through. This one was

Traded: Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, and 2023 1.12

Received: Godwin, 2023 2.05, and 2023 2.08

So the grand total ends up being…

Traded: Chase, Dillon, Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, Tannehill, 2023 1.05, and 2023 1.12

Received: CMc, Fields, Godwin, Claypool, and 2.08

The trade calculator (I know) I use, that considers SF Dynasty, has me receiving a value of 17,863 while giving up 17,806.
Yeah looking at the earlier trade I was going to say I like it. Obviously giving up Chase is a big deal, as is the 1.05, but CMC/Fields/Godwin is a heck of a get.

Out of curiosity, you said you received the 2.05 in this latest deal but it isn't listed in the grand total. Do you not hold the 2.05 + 2.08 still?

ETA I think I get it now - you crossed out the 2.05 since you paid it once and received it once. But you do actually hold it currently, which is nicer than not.
You got it. Thanks for chiming in. I prefer to try and win right away in FF. It’s all about ‘ships for me. I feel that I am definitely a lot closer to achieving that goal after the moves I’ve made so far.
One more question - I don't wanna do the math - how many roster spots did you clear?
 
So another trade with the same owner just went through. This one was

Traded: Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, and 2023 1.12

Received: Godwin, 2023 2.05, and 2023 2.08

So the grand total ends up being…

Traded: Chase, Dillon, Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, Tannehill, 2023 1.05, and 2023 1.12

Received: CMc, Fields, Godwin, Claypool, and 2.08

The trade calculator (I know) I use, that considers SF Dynasty, has me receiving a value of 17,863 while giving up 17,806.
Yeah looking at the earlier trade I was going to say I like it. Obviously giving up Chase is a big deal, as is the 1.05, but CMC/Fields/Godwin is a heck of a get.

Out of curiosity, you said you received the 2.05 in this latest deal but it isn't listed in the grand total. Do you not hold the 2.05 + 2.08 still?

ETA I think I get it now - you crossed out the 2.05 since you paid it once and received it once. But you do actually hold it currently, which is nicer than not.
You got it. Thanks for chiming in. I prefer to try and win right away in FF. It’s all about ‘ships for me. I feel that I am definitely a lot closer to achieving that goal after the moves I’ve made so far.
One more question - I don't wanna do the math - how many roster spots did you clear?
Good question. Three.
 
So another trade with the same owner just went through. This one was

Traded: Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, and 2023 1.12

Received: Godwin, 2023 2.05, and 2023 2.08

So the grand total ends up being…

Traded: Chase, Dillon, Pacheco, Sutton, Okonwo, Tannehill, 2023 1.05, and 2023 1.12

Received: CMc, Fields, Godwin, Claypool, and 2.08

The trade calculator (I know) I use, that considers SF Dynasty, has me receiving a value of 17,863 while giving up 17,806.
Yeah looking at the earlier trade I was going to say I like it. Obviously giving up Chase is a big deal, as is the 1.05, but CMC/Fields/Godwin is a heck of a get.

Out of curiosity, you said you received the 2.05 in this latest deal but it isn't listed in the grand total. Do you not hold the 2.05 + 2.08 still?

ETA I think I get it now - you crossed out the 2.05 since you paid it once and received it once. But you do actually hold it currently, which is nicer than not.
You got it. Thanks for chiming in. I prefer to try and win right away in FF. It’s all about ‘ships for me. I feel that I am definitely a lot closer to achieving that goal after the moves I’ve made so far.
One more question - I don't wanna do the math - how many roster spots did you clear?
Good question. Three.
There is a lot of real value in those spots.
 
12 Team SF, .5 PPR RB/WR, 1 PPR TE

Traded: Ja’Marr Chase, AJ Dillon, Ryan Tannehill, 2023 1.05, 2023 2.05

Received: Justin Fields, Christian McCaffrey, Chase Claypool
Blockbuster!

Man - I get it. I just don’t know if I could part with Chase. .5 PPR makes it a little easier, and obviously Fields is a massive upgrade from Tannehill.

I like AJD more than most, too.’

Congrats on getting Fields - I hope CMC has a long & productive run ahead of him.

Feels like you could have maybe been able to get this done without the 1.05 - or if you’d been able to get a better WR back than Claypool


But as someone who just paid a lot for Fields yesterday, I get it.
I’d rather have the Chase side
 
16 team, non SF:

Team A gave Josh Palmer and a 2025 1st and a 2025 2nd

Team B gave 1.4 and Zach Wilson

Team A isn't very good currently, but who knows in 2025? He has 4 1s this year. Just hard for me to see giving up 1.4 for 2025 picks, but team B is in perpetual rebuild mode
1.04 wins
Meh. In nonSF the first break is 1.3, but 2025 is too far away IMO, so I agree.
 
16 team, non SF:

Team A gave Josh Palmer and a 2025 1st and a 2025 2nd

Team B gave 1.4 and Zach Wilson

Team A isn't very good currently, but who knows in 2025? He has 4 1s this year. Just hard for me to see giving up 1.4 for 2025 picks, but team B is in perpetual rebuild mode
1.04 wins
Meh. In nonSF the first break is 1.3, but 2025 is too far away IMO, so I agree.
I also tend to look at 1.04 in non SF as a means to trade up to 1.03
;)
 
16 team, non SF:

Team A gave Josh Palmer and a 2025 1st and a 2025 2nd

Team B gave 1.4 and Zach Wilson

Team A isn't very good currently, but who knows in 2025? He has 4 1s this year. Just hard for me to see giving up 1.4 for 2025 picks, but team B is in perpetual rebuild mode
1.04 wins
Meh. In nonSF the first break is 1.3, but 2025 is too far away IMO, so I agree.
I also tend to look at 1.04 in non SF as a means to trade up to 1.03
;)
Yeah.
 
Man, all the work over the last 2 seasons rebuilding, and today one of the top 3 teams announced he’s retiring from all FF sports.

So I hooked up my buddy with the opening and I have to admit I’m a little ticked. He walks into a top team, light on picks but loaded with assets (Hurts/Murray, like 10 decent RBs, 4 good TE, several solid WR)

And I look at my team and the work I’ve put in the last 2 years. It’s just not right. lol

As soon as he joins imma flood him with trade offers. :lol:
 
16 team, non SF:

Team A gave Josh Palmer and a 2025 1st and a 2025 2nd

Team B gave 1.4 and Zach Wilson

Team A isn't very good currently, but who knows in 2025? He has 4 1s this year. Just hard for me to see giving up 1.4 for 2025 picks, but team B is in perpetual rebuild mode
1.04 wins
Meh. In nonSF the first break is 1.3, but 2025 is too far away IMO, so I agree.
I also tend to look at 1.04 in non SF as a means to trade up to 1.03
;)
I traded Corderelle Patterson and the 1.04 to move up to the 1.03.
 
16 team, non SF:

Team A gave Josh Palmer and a 2025 1st and a 2025 2nd

Team B gave 1.4 and Zach Wilson

Team A isn't very good currently, but who knows in 2025? He has 4 1s this year. Just hard for me to see giving up 1.4 for 2025 picks, but team B is in perpetual rebuild mode
1.04 wins
Meh. In nonSF the first break is 1.3, but 2025 is too far away IMO, so I agree.
I also tend to look at 1.04 in non SF as a means to trade up to 1.03
;)
I traded Corderelle Patterson and the 1.04 to move up to the 1.03.
When, 3 years ago?
 
16 team, non SF:

Team A gave Josh Palmer and a 2025 1st and a 2025 2nd

Team B gave 1.4 and Zach Wilson

Team A isn't very good currently, but who knows in 2025? He has 4 1s this year. Just hard for me to see giving up 1.4 for 2025 picks, but team B is in perpetual rebuild mode
1.04 wins
Meh. In nonSF the first break is 1.3, but 2025 is too far away IMO, so I agree.
I also tend to look at 1.04 in non SF as a means to trade up to 1.03
;)
I traded Corderelle Patterson and the 1.04 to move up to the 1.03.
When, 3 years ago?
I mean, yeah - that wouldn’t get it done this year obviously. :lol:

But it’s a much easier deal for 1.03 if you’re holding 1.04

Not everyone has the same tier breaks. It’s an often overlooked factor of trading - your trade partner might believe they’re essentially getting 💯 free assets for moving 1 spot down.

As opposed to trying to deal players or later picks, which can be much more difficult.
 
16 team, non SF:

Team A gave Josh Palmer and a 2025 1st and a 2025 2nd

Team B gave 1.4 and Zach Wilson

Team A isn't very good currently, but who knows in 2025? He has 4 1s this year. Just hard for me to see giving up 1.4 for 2025 picks, but team B is in perpetual rebuild mode
1.04 wins
Meh. In nonSF the first break is 1.3, but 2025 is too far away IMO, so I agree.
I also tend to look at 1.04 in non SF as a means to trade up to 1.03
;)
I traded Corderelle Patterson and the 1.04 to move up to the 1.03.
When, 3 years ago?
agreed I have patterson on a RB needy team and he is my first cut
 
FFPC SuperFlex it's getting drastic out here

I gave Kittle, Carter, Claypool, 2024 3rd
I got Dulcich, Gibson, Chark, Juwan Johnson, 4.01, 4.02, 4.07

Not planning on keeping either player here so in my mind I cleared a roster spot. I'm also well over 50% hit rate on 3rd and 4th round rookie selections over the years so I actually kind of love these picks that everyone hates. Kittle is getting older and has lots of comp for targets. I love Dulcich and I think Gibson is criminally undervalued right now. Just a depth RB at this point but a solid one IMO. @menobrown that's one less Claypool share.

ETA I'm still at 19 if I cut Chark and JJ and have more work to do. I have way too many WR3/4 types.
 
FFPC SuperFlex same as one above w/Kittle

I gave 2024 5th
I got Shaheed

I am already counting this among my 19. Right now my three cuts would be Cade Otton/Likely/CEH. Would love to make a couple more deals made.
 
FFPC SuperFlex it's getting drastic out here

I gave Kittle, Carter, Claypool, 2024 3rd
I got Dulcich, Gibson, Chark, Juwan Johnson, 4.01, 4.02, 4.07

Not planning on keeping either player here so in my mind I cleared a roster spot. I'm also well over 50% hit rate on 3rd and 4th round rookie selections over the years so I actually kind of love these picks that everyone hates. Kittle is getting older and has lots of comp for targets. I love Dulcich and I think Gibson is criminally undervalued right now. Just a depth RB at this point but a solid one IMO. @menobrown that's one less Claypool share.

ETA I'm still at 19 if I cut Chark and JJ and have more work to do. I have way too many WR3/4 types.
Wow do I need to target dulcich or what? What am I missing. He your big 2nd year TE breakout?
 
FFPC SuperFlex it's getting drastic out here

I gave Kittle, Carter, Claypool, 2024 3rd
I got Dulcich, Gibson, Chark, Juwan Johnson, 4.01, 4.02, 4.07

Not planning on keeping either player here so in my mind I cleared a roster spot. I'm also well over 50% hit rate on 3rd and 4th round rookie selections over the years so I actually kind of love these picks that everyone hates. Kittle is getting older and has lots of comp for targets. I love Dulcich and I think Gibson is criminally undervalued right now. Just a depth RB at this point but a solid one IMO. @menobrown that's one less Claypool share.

ETA I'm still at 19 if I cut Chark and JJ and have more work to do. I have way too many WR3/4 types.
Wow do I need to target dulcich or what? What am I missing. He your big 2nd year TE breakout?
More than anything it is that I think Kittle is overrated (for fantasy) as he heads into his 30yo season. But yes I'm pretty big on Dulcich in Sean Payton's pass friendly system. Even though I moved him the other day for Otton and 3.01 in a different spot. But the roster spot crunch is a really big factor here. Although I've gotten away from posting it, my value system for players and picks has this trade like this:

I gave Kittle, Carter, Claypool, 2024 3rd 28+9+11+5=53 franchise points (think super similarly to the Hindery system)
I got Dulcich, Gibson, Chark, Juwan Johnson, 4.01, 4.02, 4.07 21+18+3+3+3=47 but I also consider roster spots in FFPC to be worth ~7 points so=54 FPs
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top