****OFFICIAL DYNASTY TRADES**** (30 Viewers)

[JohnnyU]

Nice move, not a fan of Fant but Pierce > Roschon in a vacuum

Dameon Pierce ADP 48.
Johnson 98

Right now……Let’s compare notes this time next year.

After Pierce has another lead back season and Johnson is in a three-way committee at best?

It’s hard to imagine many scenarios where Johnson can significantly out perform Pierce. Hebert and Foreman aren’t just going away.

Gotta be a Bears homer.

Me? Hardly. He is probably right, but a lot can happen in a short period of time. Especially at RB.

No, I was talking about the OP who took a bath acquiring Roschon.
I don't particularly like the Roschon side of the trade, but it's not egregious and maybe this falls under "go get your guy"? RBs other than Bijan and Gibbs this year are all in weird spots.

After Bijan and Gibbs I probably like Miller, Abanikandi, then Roschon Johnson in that order. Obviously Abanikandi landed in a horrible spot. I like Johnson’s landing spot.

 

[jwsbowler]

12 team .75 RB/1.00 WR/1.25 TE PPR Devy

Traded: Ja’Marr Chase, Irv Smith, Jr.

Received: DK Metcalf, 2x 2024 1sts (those teams picked 4th and 9th this year)

Goodbye to my remaining share of Chase. While this is a squad that finished 3rd last year it also has several question marks. I feel that in making this move it not only keeps me competitive for this year but also gives me options for the future with 3 2024 1sts now (strange typing that as I usually never even have my own for long, I suspect that I’ll own zero by the time the draft rolls around) as well as opening up a roster spot once occupied by Smith.

If I am receiving Chase... I HIT A GOLD MINE.

 

[dipandglide]

A couple of recent ones...

12 tm, ppr

Gave: Swift, '24 2nd (should be mid-late)
Got: Dillon, J. Cook
-------------------------
12 tm, superflex, ppr

Gave: Chubb, M. Williams
Got: Flowers, Dillon
----------------------------
16 tm, best ball, superflex, star 2 TE prem

Gave: 1.05 (Stroud)
Got: Tua

 

[menobrown]

FFPC 1 QB league I logged in and seen this offer and before I slam accepted it I had to do a quick look to see if Pierce got suspended for the year or tore his ACL walking his dog or something. I am no huge fan but this was an easy accept and I do like Roschon.

I get Dameon Pierce and Noah Fant
I give Roschon Johnson

Pierce will be valued next year the way Rhamondre is valued right now.

 

[farfromforgotten]

12 team .75 RB/1.00 WR/1.25 TE PPR Devy

Traded: Ja’Marr Chase, Irv Smith, Jr.

Received: DK Metcalf, 2x 2024 1sts (those teams picked 4th and 9th this year)

Goodbye to my remaining share of Chase. While this is a squad that finished 3rd last year it also has several question marks. I feel that in making this move it not only keeps me competitive for this year but also gives me options for the future with 3 2024 1sts now (strange typing that as I usually never even have my own for long, I suspect that I’ll own zero by the time the draft rolls around) as well as opening up a roster spot once occupied by Smith.

If I am receiving Chase... I HIT A GOLD MINE.

I completely understand your stance. I know how much people covet 1st rd picks though. The only pieces of note that this team has are Hurts, Jacobs, Aiyuk, Kirk, Dio Johnson, and now Metcalf. Like I said I finished third but I didn’t see this team contending for the title any time soon even with Chase in the mix. I’m not one who believes in tearing everything down to rebuild though. None of my other players would have brought back what Chase did. I get a 25 year old #1 WR and I’ll add another couple of pieces around that as well. I’ll chime back in on this one after trading away those firsts and then we’ll see what was added to Metcalf for Chase.

 

[dmac37]

12 team PPR just made a deal. Trade calculators all say I lost by a little but I'm happy.

Got

Kamara and Hollywood

Gave

Pittman, Foreman, Thielen

I'm a big Pittman fan but a little worried AR is not a good fit for him to see the targets he has been seeing. I can see Hollywood having equal or more value to end the season. Kamara is certainly a decent buy low right now. I also need to keep reducing my roster size before cut down.

 

[menobrown]

12 team PPR just made a deal. Trade calculators all say I lost by a little but I'm happy.

Got

Kamara and Hollywood

Gave

Pittman, Foreman, Thielen

I'm a big Pittman fan but a little worried AR is not a good fit for him to see the targets he has been seeing. I can see Hollywood having equal or more value to end the season. Kamara is certainly a decent buy low right now. I also need to keep reducing my roster size before cut down.

I would take Kamara and Hollywood over Pittman.

 

[jwsbowler]

12 team .75 RB/1.00 WR/1.25 TE PPR Devy

Traded: Ja’Marr Chase, Irv Smith, Jr.

Received: DK Metcalf, 2x 2024 1sts (those teams picked 4th and 9th this year)

Goodbye to my remaining share of Chase. While this is a squad that finished 3rd last year it also has several question marks. I feel that in making this move it not only keeps me competitive for this year but also gives me options for the future with 3 2024 1sts now (strange typing that as I usually never even have my own for long, I suspect that I’ll own zero by the time the draft rolls around) as well as opening up a roster spot once occupied by Smith.

If I am receiving Chase... I HIT A GOLD MINE.

I completely understand your stance. I know how much people covet 1st rd picks though. The only pieces of note that this team has are Hurts, Jacobs, Aiyuk, Kirk, Dio Johnson, and now Metcalf. Like I said I finished third but I didn’t see this team contending for the title any time soon even with Chase in the mix. I’m not one who believes in tearing everything down to rebuild though. None of my other players would have brought back what Chase did. I get a 25 year old #1 WR and I’ll add another couple of pieces around that as well. I’ll chime back in on this one after trading away those firsts and then we’ll see what was added to Metcalf for Chase.

Chase is only 23...and an anchor for a team in a rebuild or even a solid team. I am not trading him as it would have taken a lot more than what you received. a top established player or 2 unknowns and Metcalf? The value of this deal is not even close. I wish you luck.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Aging contender looking to retool a bit.

12 team ppr, 1Qb

Chubb/Deebo

For

1.07 (OTC)/1.10 (Johnston/Miller)

I don’t like it, but have been trying to move Chubb and Deebo with no interest. Both were depth pieces.

That seems a somewhat poor return. Feels like there should be a 2nd or a WR2-3 coming back as well.

Hopefully you land some values at 7 & 10

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

12 team .75 RB/1.00 WR/1.25 TE PPR Devy

Traded: Ja’Marr Chase, Irv Smith, Jr.

Received: DK Metcalf, 2x 2024 1sts (those teams picked 4th and 9th this year)

Goodbye to my remaining share of Chase. While this is a squad that finished 3rd last year it also has several question marks. I feel that in making this move it not only keeps me competitive for this year but also gives me options for the future with 3 2024 1sts now (strange typing that as I usually never even have my own for long, I suspect that I’ll own zero by the time the draft rolls around) as well as opening up a roster spot once occupied by Smith.

I don’t love selling Chase, but I do like what you got back for him.

If the 1sts are early you could hit the lotto with MH Jr.

And I like Metcalf coming back as well.

Everyone talks about the godfather offer they’d need for Chase. Seldom are godfather offers advanced.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

The value of this deal is not even close. I wish you luck.

Keep Trade Cut:
Chase side, 13,936
Metcalf + 2x 2024 1sts: 19,111

Dynasty Dominator (sleeper)
Chase side: 395.18
Metcalf + 2x 2024 1sts: 496.59

Dynasty League Football calc:
Chase side: 963
Metcalf + 2x 2024 1sts: 1089

Every calc I’ve run it through favors DKM &
2x 1sts.

Not sure what you’re basing this statement on.

 

[menobrown]

12 team .75 RB/1.00 WR/1.25 TE PPR Devy

Traded: Ja’Marr Chase, Irv Smith, Jr.

Received: DK Metcalf, 2x 2024 1sts (those teams picked 4th and 9th this year)

Goodbye to my remaining share of Chase. While this is a squad that finished 3rd last year it also has several question marks. I feel that in making this move it not only keeps me competitive for this year but also gives me options for the future with 3 2024 1sts now (strange typing that as I usually never even have my own for long, I suspect that I’ll own zero by the time the draft rolls around) as well as opening up a roster spot once occupied by Smith.

If I am receiving Chase... I HIT A GOLD MINE.

I completely understand your stance. I know how much people covet 1st rd picks though. The only pieces of note that this team has are Hurts, Jacobs, Aiyuk, Kirk, Dio Johnson, and now Metcalf. Like I said I finished third but I didn’t see this team contending for the title any time soon even with Chase in the mix. I’m not one who believes in tearing everything down to rebuild though. None of my other players would have brought back what Chase did. I get a 25 year old #1 WR and I’ll add another couple of pieces around that as well. I’ll chime back in on this one after trading away those firsts and then we’ll see what was added to Metcalf for Chase.

Hope the trade works out for you, not sure if the first have more value in Devy leagues but in my standard leagues I'd have held Chase. One of those reasons is my feelings on Metcalf being off on yours, I no longer see him as a WR1 in fantasy. More like a low end WR2 type.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

Not sure what you’re basing this statement on.

Trade calculators don't account for three dimes for a quarter type trades. Not that this one necessarily fits that mold, but it's along those lines.

I get offers from people throwing in a package of four to five marginal guys for one stud where my potential trade partner shows me the calculator points that show I'm winning the trade. I chuckle to myself.

This trade isn't on that scale but Chase >>> Metcalf and picks aren't guaranteed.

 

[JohnnyU]

Not sure what you’re basing this statement on.

Trade calculators don't account for three dimes for a quarter type trades. Not that this one necessarily fits that mold, but it's along those lines.

I get offers from people throwing in a package of four to five marginal guys for one stud where my potential trade partner shows me the calculator points that show I'm winning the trade. I chuckle to myself.

This trade isn't on that scale but Chase >>> Metcalf and picks aren't guaranteed.

There comes a time when you obtain players that will be the foundation of your dynasty team and shouldn't be trying to trade. Chase falls in that category IMO. I'm not saying certain players are NOT for trade under all circumstances, but for the most part they should be. Sure, if someone offers something ridiculously good you have to listen, but there are players I wouldn't be shopping in dynasty. This is just how I think.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Not sure what you’re basing this statement on.

Trade calculators don't account for three dimes for a quarter type trades. Not that this one necessarily fits that mold, but it's along those lines.

I get offers from people throwing in a package of four to five marginal guys for one stud where my potential trade partner shows me the calculator points that show I'm winning the trade. I chuckle to myself.

This trade isn't on that scale but Chase >>> Metcalf and picks aren't guaranteed.

Sure, I completely understand that (and have said it many times myself)

But in this case it’s a lesser WR1 + 2x 2024 1sts

That’s a totally fair package.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

That’s a totally fair package.

Yes, getting a stud WR back plus two firsts is nothing to sneeze at for sure which is why I said this trade doesn't quite fit the three dimes for a quarter type deals - but if you sit and break it down, it's probably not a smart move as all of the risk flows to the picks side. JSN being added into the Seattle mix, also brings Metcalf's value down a bit since there's only so many targets to go around on a run first offense.

I do agree with the overall point that it's far from terrible or "not close" though. It's close but I agree with Johnny here (it happens once is while ) that Chase is a perpetual hold for me.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

I do agree with the overall point that it's far from terrible or "not close" though. It's close but I agree with Johnny here (it happens once is while ) that Chase is a perpetual hold for me.

Oh, of course. In my initial post I prefaced it by saying I didn’t love dealing Chase.

He’s a player you build around, not trade away, IMO.

That said, having gone through a full rebuild I understand sometimes needing to make sacrifices of big name players to start the process.

But overall I agree with you that the fairness of this trade will ultimately be determined by the success of those draft picks.

 

[JohnnyU]

12 team .75 RB/1.00 WR/1.25 TE PPR Devy

Traded: Ja’Marr Chase, Irv Smith, Jr.

Received: DK Metcalf, 2x 2024 1sts (those teams picked 4th and 9th this year)

Goodbye to my remaining share of Chase. While this is a squad that finished 3rd last year it also has several question marks. I feel that in making this move it not only keeps me competitive for this year but also gives me options for the future with 3 2024 1sts now (strange typing that as I usually never even have my own for long, I suspect that I’ll own zero by the time the draft rolls around) as well as opening up a roster spot once occupied by Smith.

If I am receiving Chase... I HIT A GOLD MINE.

I completely understand your stance. I know how much people covet 1st rd picks though. The only pieces of note that this team has are Hurts, Jacobs, Aiyuk, Kirk, Dio Johnson, and now Metcalf. Like I said I finished third but I didn’t see this team contending for the title any time soon even with Chase in the mix. I’m not one who believes in tearing everything down to rebuild though. None of my other players would have brought back what Chase did. I get a 25 year old #1 WR and I’ll add another couple of pieces around that as well. I’ll chime back in on this one after trading away those firsts and then we’ll see what was added to Metcalf for Chase.

Also, one thing about the draft picks in that league. It's a DEVY league and those picks can be used on incoming rookies or underclassman. We can roster a total of 12 DEVYs. Here is a list of currently rostered DEVYS in this league: Williams, Caleb FA QB, Allen, Braelon FA RB, Baxter Jr., Cedric FA RB, Judkins, Quinshon FA RB, Henderson, TreVeyon FA RB, Harrison Jr., Marvin FA WR, Sanders, Raheim FA RB, Egbuka, Emeka FA WR, Bowers, Brock FA TE, Sanders, Ja'Tavion FA TE, Worthy, Xavier FA WR, Singleton, Nicholas FA RB

 

[Marauder]

Not sure what you’re basing this statement on.

Trade calculators don't account for three dimes for a quarter type trades. Not that this one necessarily fits that mold, but it's along those lines.

I get offers from people throwing in a package of four to five marginal guys for one stud where my potential trade partner shows me the calculator points that show I'm winning the trade. I chuckle to myself.

This trade isn't on that scale but Chase >>> Metcalf and picks aren't guaranteed.

There comes a time when you obtain players that will be the foundation of your dynasty team and shouldn't be trying to trade. Chase falls in that category IMO. I'm not saying certain players are NOT for trade under all circumstances, but for the most part they should be. Sure, if someone offers something ridiculously good you have to listen, but there are players I wouldn't be shopping in dynasty. This is just how I think.

This is the same way I see it. If someone offers me a "fair deal" for Chase it's an instant reject. For me to trade him it has to be a deal that blows me away.

 

[humpback]

12 team .75 RB/1.00 WR/1.25 TE PPR Devy

Traded: Ja’Marr Chase, Irv Smith, Jr.

Received: DK Metcalf, 2x 2024 1sts (those teams picked 4th and 9th this year)

Goodbye to my remaining share of Chase. While this is a squad that finished 3rd last year it also has several question marks. I feel that in making this move it not only keeps me competitive for this year but also gives me options for the future with 3 2024 1sts now (strange typing that as I usually never even have my own for long, I suspect that I’ll own zero by the time the draft rolls around) as well as opening up a roster spot once occupied by Smith.

If I am receiving Chase... I HIT A GOLD MINE.

I completely understand your stance. I know how much people covet 1st rd picks though. The only pieces of note that this team has are Hurts, Jacobs, Aiyuk, Kirk, Dio Johnson, and now Metcalf. Like I said I finished third but I didn’t see this team contending for the title any time soon even with Chase in the mix. I’m not one who believes in tearing everything down to rebuild though. None of my other players would have brought back what Chase did. I get a 25 year old #1 WR and I’ll add another couple of pieces around that as well. I’ll chime back in on this one after trading away those firsts and then we’ll see what was added to Metcalf for Chase.

Also, one thing about the 1st round picks in that league. It's a DEVY league and those picks can be used on incoming rookies or underclassman. We can roster a total of 12 DEVYs. Here is a list of currently rostered DEVYS in this league: Williams, Caleb FA QB, Allen, Braelon FA RB, Baxter Jr., Cedric FA RB, Judkins, Quinshon FA RB, Henderson, TreVeyon FA RB, Harrison Jr., Marvin FA WR, Sanders, Raheim FA RB, Egbuka, Emeka FA WR, Bowers, Brock FA TE, Sanders, Ja'Tavion FA TE, Worthy, Xavier FA WR, Singleton, Nicholas FA RB

Ouch

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

This is the same way I see it. If someone offers me a "fair deal" for Chase it's an instant reject. For me to trade him it has to be a deal that blows me away.

I don’t disagree.

I only disagree with the statement that “The value of this deal is not even close”

It is in fact close, and most resources have it in favor of dealing Chase. Some by enough that it could be considered a “blown away” package.

Personally I would find a way to build around Chase, but I’m commenting on a trade that was made, not what trade I would make.

 

[JohnnyU]

12 team .75 RB/1.00 WR/1.25 TE PPR Devy

Traded: Ja’Marr Chase, Irv Smith, Jr.

Received: DK Metcalf, 2x 2024 1sts (those teams picked 4th and 9th this year)

Goodbye to my remaining share of Chase. While this is a squad that finished 3rd last year it also has several question marks. I feel that in making this move it not only keeps me competitive for this year but also gives me options for the future with 3 2024 1sts now (strange typing that as I usually never even have my own for long, I suspect that I’ll own zero by the time the draft rolls around) as well as opening up a roster spot once occupied by Smith.

If I am receiving Chase... I HIT A GOLD MINE.

I completely understand your stance. I know how much people covet 1st rd picks though. The only pieces of note that this team has are Hurts, Jacobs, Aiyuk, Kirk, Dio Johnson, and now Metcalf. Like I said I finished third but I didn’t see this team contending for the title any time soon even with Chase in the mix. I’m not one who believes in tearing everything down to rebuild though. None of my other players would have brought back what Chase did. I get a 25 year old #1 WR and I’ll add another couple of pieces around that as well. I’ll chime back in on this one after trading away those firsts and then we’ll see what was added to Metcalf for Chase.

Also, one thing about the 1st round picks in that league. It's a DEVY league and those picks can be used on incoming rookies or underclassman. We can roster a total of 12 DEVYs. Here is a list of currently rostered DEVYS in this league: Williams, Caleb FA QB, Allen, Braelon FA RB, Baxter Jr., Cedric FA RB, Judkins, Quinshon FA RB, Henderson, TreVeyon FA RB, Harrison Jr., Marvin FA WR, Sanders, Raheim FA RB, Egbuka, Emeka FA WR, Bowers, Brock FA TE, Sanders, Ja'Tavion FA TE, Worthy, Xavier FA WR, Singleton, Nicholas FA RB

Ouch

One correction, it is any pick can be used on a rookie or devy (as long as there hasn't been 12 devys already on rosters).

 

[titusbramble]

Not sure what you’re basing this statement on.

Trade calculators don't account for three dimes for a quarter type trades. Not that this one necessarily fits that mold, but it's along those lines.

KTC does. Whether it does a good job of it is a different question entirely

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Not sure what you’re basing this statement on.

Trade calculators don't account for three dimes for a quarter type trades. Not that this one necessarily fits that mold, but it's along those lines.

KTC does. Whether it does a good job of it is a different question entirely

I’ll add that KTC & Dynasty Dominator also account for roster spots.

They’re much more advanced tools than we used to have access to - while still not perfect, there needs to be a bit of human intuition when using them (like any data analysis). But they’re getting better for sure.

 

[JohnnyU]

Not sure what you’re basing this statement on.

Trade calculators don't account for three dimes for a quarter type trades. Not that this one necessarily fits that mold, but it's along those lines.

KTC does. Whether it does a good job of it is a different question entirely

Trade calculators are just a guide. Anyone depending on them on trades are going about it all wrong. Also, you can't really count the fluff / throw-ins. Someone offering me a bunch of crap for a stud I just reject and don't reply back. If they're just balancing the trade I can see it and just look at the bones of the trade offer and decide. I believe people who depend on trade calculators are doing themselves a disservice.

 

[smbkrypt24]

12 team PPR. Start 1 QB. 1-4 RB, 1-4 WR, 1 TE. (Total of 5 between RB and WR)

Gave: Lamb, Bateman, 2.04, 3.04, 2024 2nd, 2024 2nd, 2024 2nd

Received: AJ Brown, Kamara, 2024 1st

Going into this trade I had 6 2024 1sts. 8 2024 2nds, and 4 2024 3rds. This now puts me at 7 2024 1sts, 5 2024 2nds, and 4 2024 3rds. I had little depth at RB so also liked picking up Kamara there.

 

[ghostguy123]

Trade calculators are basically a broken clock is right twice a day type of tool.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Trade calculators are basically a broken clock is right twice a day type of tool.

Like any tool, they’re only as good a the person using it.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

12 team PPR. Start 1 QB. 1-4 RB, 1-4 WR, 1 TE. (Total of 5 between RB and WR)

Gave: Lamb, Bateman, 2.04, 3.04, 2024 2nd, 2024 2nd, 2024 2nd

Received: AJ Brown, Kamara, 2024 1st

Going into this trade I had 6 2024 1sts. 8 2024 2nds, and 4 2024 3rds. This now puts me at 7 2024 1sts, 5 2024 2nds, and 4 2024 3rds. I had little depth at RB so also liked picking up Kamara there.

In principal I like it, but I’m not a fan of Kamara going forward

 

[titusbramble]

Trade calculators are basically a broken clock is right twice a day type of tool.

And if you think they're useless, you need to pay attention to them so you know in which way they're useless in order to exploit them to your advantage

 

[Dez]

Nice move, not a fan of Fant but Pierce > Roschon in a vacuum

Yes Fant is now my 8th TE and we have to cut to 20 to start the year so I am going to try and trade him for scraps. He only threw him in because that was his 4th TE and he was cutting him.

I was super weak at RB last year my starters were McKinnon and Perine. Now I have Gibbs, Pierce, Perine and McKinnon.

Still not really playing for this year I had 6 1st round picks after punting the startup last year which was botched left and right this team could been so much better.

Anyway I have 3 1st round picks in 2024 stashed away and will likely not compete for a playoff spot but can try and win the #1 pick for 2024.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Trade calculators are basically a broken clock is right twice a day type of tool.

And if you think they're useless, you need to pay attention to them so you know in which way they're useless in order to exploit them to your advantage

This 100%

Because others in your leagues use them.

It’s like exploiting site rankings in redraft.

 

[Tau837]

12 team PPR, start 1Q, 2R, 3W, 1T, 2F (R/W/T), 1K, 1DST

My team traded Gibson, Antonio WAS RB for Burks, Treylon TEN WR

I have a partner on this team, and he threw out this offer along with a few others after our rookie draft. I did not expect the offer to be accepted, so pretty pleased about it.

 

[farfromforgotten]

I appreciate all of the replies in here. Good conversations going on. I agree that typically Chase would be the piece to build around and the sentiment that draft picks are complete unknowns. I’m not planning on having these picks when the draft comes around however. Others seem to value draft picks more than I. I will move them for younger players already in the league that maybe others have soured a bit on that I still like, more than likely. I listed my other notable players above. No one is bringing back close to anything for what I got for Chase. Which is how it should be. But I feel that anyone else worth dealing, maybe outside of Hurts, would have ended up being a lateral move at best. In this case I get a very good WR with several prime years remaining and picks to play with. A big thing will be what I turn those picks into. I haven’t had much time of late but I’m going to start looking into now.

 

[jabarony]

Trade calculators are basically a broken clock is right twice a day type of tool.

And if you think they're useless, you need to pay attention to them so you know in which way they're useless in order to exploit them to your advantage

This 100%

Because others in your leagues use them.

It’s like exploiting site rankings in redraft.

Yeah but the problem is I don't want to pay for a crappy tool just to have insight to the crappy tool my leaguemates may, or may not, be using.

 

[Hot Sauce Guy]

Trade calculators are basically a broken clock is right twice a day type of tool.

And if you think they're useless, you need to pay attention to them so you know in which way they're useless in order to exploit them to your advantage

This 100%

Because others in your leagues use them.

It’s like exploiting site rankings in redraft.

Yeah but the problem is I don't want to pay for a crappy tool just to have insight to the crappy tool my leaguemates may, or may not, be using.

Some of the tools
1. Are free (keep trade cut)
2. Come with excellent content (DLF)
3. Aren’t crappy tools

 

[kyter1]

12 TM PPR & .25/carry QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, Fl (RB, WR, TE)

Gave: 1.03, 1.06, 2.06, 3.05
Got: 1.01

Roster after:
Goff, Ridder
Robinson, Walker, Z. White, Haskins, Ingram, Hunt
Olave, Pickens, JuJu, rest don’t matter
Dulcich, Knox, Fant, Bellinger

1.05, 2.05 4.05

 

[eighsse2]

12 TM PPR & .25/carry QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, Fl (RB, WR, TE)

Gave: 1.03, 1.06, 2.06, 3.05
Got: 1.01

Roster after:
Goff, Ridder
Robinson, Walker, Z. White, Haskins, Ingram, Hunt
Olave, Pickens, JuJu, rest don’t matter
Dulcich, Knox, Fant, Bellinger

1.05, 2.05 4.05

Cha-ching

 

[Dez]

Yes Fant is now my 8th TE and we have to cut to 20 to start the year so I am going to try and trade him for scraps. He only threw him in because that was his 4th TE and he was cutting him.

Just traded Fant and a 5th for a 4th "championship"

 

[Keith R]

12 TM PPR & .25/carry QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, Fl (RB, WR, TE)

Gave: 1.03, 1.06, 2.06, 3.05
Got: 1.01

Roster after:
Goff, Ridder
Robinson, Walker, Z. White, Haskins, Ingram, Hunt
Olave, Pickens, JuJu, rest don’t matter
Dulcich, Knox, Fant, Bellinger

1.05, 2.05 4.05

Thanks for posting this. I'm trying to figure out a balanced trade for the 1.01 and this is the only recent example I have seen. (I'm thinking of floating 1.02, 2.09 and 2.12 for the 1.01 FWIW)

 

[farfromforgotten]

12 team .75 RB/1.00 WR/1.25 TE PPR Devy

Traded: Ja’Marr Chase, Irv Smith, Jr.

Received: DK Metcalf, 2x 2024 1sts (those teams picked 4th and 9th this year)

Goodbye to my remaining share of Chase. While this is a squad that finished 3rd last year it also has several question marks. I feel that in making this move it not only keeps me competitive for this year but also gives me options for the future with 3 2024 1sts now (strange typing that as I usually never even have my own for long, I suspect that I’ll own zero by the time the draft rolls around) as well as opening up a roster spot once occupied by Smith.

One of my 2024 1sts was moved overnight.

Traded: Josh Jacobs, 2024 1st (mine)

Received: Chris Olave

 

[Blick]

12 TM PPR & .25/carry QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, Fl (RB, WR, TE)

Gave: 1.03, 1.06, 2.06, 3.05
Got: 1.01

Roster after:
Goff, Ridder
Robinson, Walker, Z. White, Haskins, Ingram, Hunt
Olave, Pickens, JuJu, rest don’t matter
Dulcich, Knox, Fant, Bellinger

1.05, 2.05 4.05

Thanks for posting this. I'm trying to figure out a balanced trade for the 1.01 and this is the only recent example I have seen. (I'm thinking of floating 1.02, 2.09 and 2.12 for the 1.01 FWIW)

If I was dealing the 1.01, I'd want the 1.02 or 1.03 and at least another 1st and 2nd. Probably two firsts.

 

[eighsse2]

Nice move, not a fan of Fant but Pierce > Roschon in a vacuum

Yes Fant is now my 8th TE and we have to cut to 20 to start the year so I am going to try and trade him for scraps. He only threw him in because that was his 4th TE and he was cutting him.

I was super weak at RB last year my starters were McKinnon and Perine. Now I have Gibbs, Pierce, Perine and McKinnon.

Still not really playing for this year I had 6 1st round picks after punting the startup last year which was botched left and right this team could been so much better.

Anyway I have 3 1st round picks in 2024 stashed away and will likely not compete for a playoff spot but can try and win the #1 pick for 2024.

8th TE

 

[foxco]

Thanks for posting this. I'm trying to figure out a balanced trade for the 1.01 and this is the only recent example I have seen. (I'm thinking of floating 1.02, 2.09 and 2.12 for the 1.01 FWIW)

I'd guess that offer would be an Instant reject or a simple ignore till it expires.

 

[Flying Elvis]

12 TM PPR & .25/carry QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, Fl (RB, WR, TE)

Gave: 1.03, 1.06, 2.06, 3.05
Got: 1.01

Roster after:
Goff, Ridder
Robinson, Walker, Z. White, Haskins, Ingram, Hunt
Olave, Pickens, JuJu, rest don’t matter
Dulcich, Knox, Fant, Bellinger

1.05, 2.05 4.05

Thanks for posting this. I'm trying to figure out a balanced trade for the 1.01 and this is the only recent example I have seen. (I'm thinking of floating 1.02, 2.09 and 2.12 for the 1.01 FWIW)

I took over an orphan that has serious holes but had the 1.01 so I traded it in the hopes of speeding up the rebuild. I would not have considered anything that didn't start with 2 firsts .

(16 team IDP)
Gave: Year 2023 Draft Pick 1.01
Received: Year 2023 Draft Pick 1.05; Year 2023 Draft Pick 1.13; Year 2023 Draft Pick 5.05; Year 2024 Round 2 Draft Pick from All City Champions; Year 2024 Round 5 Draft Pick from All City Champions

 

[Gally]

(16 team IDP)
Gave: Year 2023 Draft Pick 1.01
Received: Year 2023 Draft Pick 1.05; Year 2023 Draft Pick 1.13; Year 2023 Draft Pick 5.05; Year 2024 Round 2 Draft Pick from All City Champions; Year 2024 Round 5 Draft Pick from All City Champions

yes it's two firsts but really nothing of impact for those firsts. Mostly just hopes and dreams. If those two hit (which they could), then it likely pays off. The chances of hitting on those are minimal (IMO) so it's likely not enough for me to part with 1.01

 

[Dez]

12 TM PPR & .25/carry QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, Fl (RB, WR, TE)

Gave: 1.03, 1.06, 2.06, 3.05
Got: 1.01

Roster after:
Goff, Ridder
Robinson, Walker, Z. White, Haskins, Ingram, Hunt
Olave, Pickens, JuJu, rest don’t matter
Dulcich, Knox, Fant, Bellinger

1.05, 2.05 4.05

Thanks for posting this. I'm trying to figure out a balanced trade for the 1.01 and this is the only recent example I have seen. (I'm thinking of floating 1.02, 2.09 and 2.12 for the 1.01 FWIW)

Sorry but 1.02 + those picks not even close.

I have offered 1.02+ my future 1st for 1.01 got turned down.

I also offered 1.03, 1.06, 2.12 and got turned down

 

[Dez]

12 TM PPR & .25/carry QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, Fl (RB, WR, TE)

Gave: 1.03, 1.06, 2.06, 3.05
Got: 1.01

Roster after:
Goff, Ridder
Robinson, Walker, Z. White, Haskins, Ingram, Hunt
Olave, Pickens, JuJu, rest don’t matter
Dulcich, Knox, Fant, Bellinger

1.05, 2.05 4.05

Thanks for posting this. I'm trying to figure out a balanced trade for the 1.01 and this is the only recent example I have seen. (I'm thinking of floating 1.02, 2.09 and 2.12 for the 1.01 FWIW)

I took over an orphan that has serious holes but had the 1.01 so I traded it in the hopes of speeding up the rebuild. I would not have considered anything that didn't start with 2 firsts .

(16 team IDP)
Gave: Year 2023 Draft Pick 1.01
Received: Year 2023 Draft Pick 1.05; Year 2023 Draft Pick 1.13; Year 2023 Draft Pick 5.05; Year 2024 Round 2 Draft Pick from All City Champions; Year 2024 Round 5 Draft Pick from All City Champions

Awful return for your 1.01

I traded someone the 1.05, 1.13 and a future 1st for his 1.01 and I think I got a steal. Your trade was way worse you got a 2nd rounder plus 1.13 to move down to 1.05 ? Yikes.

I am thinking some of you need to float your trade offers on this forum before actually making trades when you are giving up the golden goose like the 1.01 pick or a Chase.

 

[Da Franchise]

12 TM PPR & .25/carry QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, Fl (RB, WR, TE)

Gave: 1.03, 1.06, 2.06, 3.05
Got: 1.01

Roster after:
Goff, Ridder
Robinson, Walker, Z. White, Haskins, Ingram, Hunt
Olave, Pickens, JuJu, rest don’t matter
Dulcich, Knox, Fant, Bellinger

1.05, 2.05 4.05

Thanks for posting this. I'm trying to figure out a balanced trade for the 1.01 and this is the only recent example I have seen. (I'm thinking of floating 1.02, 2.09 and 2.12 for the 1.01 FWIW)

I took over an orphan that has serious holes but had the 1.01 so I traded it in the hopes of speeding up the rebuild. I would not have considered anything that didn't start with 2 firsts .

(16 team IDP)
Gave: Year 2023 Draft Pick 1.01
Received: Year 2023 Draft Pick 1.05; Year 2023 Draft Pick 1.13; Year 2023 Draft Pick 5.05; Year 2024 Round 2 Draft Pick from All City Champions; Year 2024 Round 5 Draft Pick from All City Champions

Sorry but you got absolutely hosed.

 

[farfromforgotten]

I am thinking some of you need to float your trade offers on this forum before actually making trades when you are giving up the golden goose like the 1.01 pick or a Chase.

I have to assume part of this is about me. I’ve been doing this ‘95. I’ll make the mistake of trading Chase all on my own. Thank you very much. Lol.

I’ve got Metcalf and Olave in tow now. I’m in discussions to land another stud under 25 year old WR possibly using some combination of the two ‘24 firsts I have remaining and WRs that are now 3rd, 4th, 5th in line on my roster. If that isn’t ultimately considered enough of a return for moving Chase then I’m not sure that we could ever come to an agreement on what is.