Awesome stuff by Reginald (trying to remember whose alias this is). I can assure you though, the dog picture was a joke

. My current profile is much like you describe with beach pictures, pictures of me playing QB in a competitive flag game (I think this one is quite effective because of the stigma that the QB is the top guy to go for), one getting strung up during one of those play-acting dinner cruise things, etc. I also think every girl I've met so far has commented that 1) they really liked I had a bunch of different photos up and 2) that I look exactly like I did in my photos. The second comment is almost always followed by some horror story of some guy who falsely advertised in his pictures (I love those guys, as they make make me look both more honest and more attractive). However, one point made by Reginald which I strongly disagree with* is having the picture of you and a hot chick up there or a picture where there has clearly been a grl cropped out of the picture. I've had a few dates tell me them immediately close a match if they see this because it means either that the guy may be hung up on his ex or he is a show-off and can't be trusted. I get the psychological effect it can have on a viewer as it is akin to say how a super high price tag can give some object a much higher implied value, but I think if the rest of your photos are good enough and you can put some seemingly impressive things in your profile it is way too big of a risk. This time around I've definitely done the less is more approach by not revealing much at all and simply relying on three things in addition to my photos:
1. Job titles - on paper they sound impressive to mommy and daddy
2. Just moved to town - while true, the main reason I make that known is that I'm no-drama, fresh meat type deal
3. Obsess about some guy thing - I don't know why it works, but girls seem drawn to some guy who has some oddly mild obsession to something. Whether it be cars, tattoos, or in my case, sports. I don't know if it gives them some competitive aspect or tht it makes it seem like my free time is more valuable or what, but it works.
*However, it could have something to do with my angle and approach. I'm on eharmony, a more serious dating site and play the "got my crap together" angle because I think I really do well with the more nice rich girl type thing who is concerned with status and not some hot chick looking to hookup. If that were the case, the picture of a hot chick ploy could work.