Sweet J
Footballguy
AA is a funny thing. You get different feels depending on the particular meeting you go to. Some are more heavy handed, some are not. Regarding the indoctrination thing -- this is such a tricky issue because to tackle something like giving up alcohol, for an alcoholic, is so huge and life changing that you almost HAVE to be indoctrinated into a different way of life, almost like a religion. If giving up drinking were easy, it wouldn't be an issue. Some people HAVE to feel like they are in a cult, or at least close to a religious experience, in order to give up something that has been such a way of life for them for so many years.Keys, there are a lot of insights in the Big Book. You should take some time alone and page through it. It addresses some of these issues (along with the idea of believing in a higher power, which is suprizingly important). Good luck either way, gb.this may be the only telling sign so far in what I have read that you may actually have a problem.I didnt think you did before. I thought you were being a little over dramatic. I still pretty much feel that way. However, i think that many people who do have a problem have a very strong reaction against AA. So You should at least make sure you examine this closely to make sure it is not a defensive move.Thanks John. Maybe I am, maybe I'm not. Still feel I am, but that program is just NOT for me.Hey Keys -I have never done AA but know guys that have. To be honest I didn't think you were an alcoholic, at least compared to the guys that I know that entered the program - those guys were serious binge drinkers that would go on 3-4 day benders - I am talking being drunk all the time. I think so long as you don't crave the sauce you should be o.k. I like to drink but I really only go out once maybe twice a week - if anything I think I need to go out more. I also have a fridge stocked with beers and I never drink them when I am alone - to health conscious.So, I might be headed back in here soon, although cautiously.
AA has been a HUGE disappointment. After two weeks, it feels like a cult, and it's making me extremely uncomfortable. The no-dating thing was fine...until they started laying on more "rules" that had nothing to do with stopping drinking. It's sad that I have to do the whole sobriety thing on my own, but they kept telling me what a bad person I was in EVERY aspect of my life, and how horrible my life is right now, and that they had the only solution.
Sounds way too much like I'm being indoctrinated, rather than helped.
As far as this is concerned, it'll be a little bit until I'm sure I can handle this on my own, but I don't see the harm in coming back.
Not trying to be the devil here, but if it is not working for you I say get out. The way you describe it, it almost sounds like it is run in a church by a pragmatic preacher or something.
Edit: Here is chapter 4 of the big book, in case you haven't read it. It may be helpful for some of what you are experiencing.
Last edited by a moderator: