Out of the ordinary situation;
Last February 1st, we leased our 2 bedroom house to 2 single women. We leased to them on the same contract, so they were both individually responsible for the entire lease if one of them flaked. They treated it as a 50/50 lease, each gave half of the 2 month deposit and we received two checks every month, each of half the rent. Everything has gone well.
One of the women has purchased a home of her own and wants to move out at lease end (January 31st).
The other (Tenant#1) would like to stay and sign a 12 month lease. She would have qualified on her own to rent the place, she has the income (but not great credit) and she was renting an apartment, on her own, at the same rent as our place, prior to moving in.
She would like to find another room mate, and our preference would be to sign a new lease with 2 people (each fully responsible), but some of her options are not sure they'll want to stay a full 12 months (and also sound to be indefinite on the length of time they'd like to stay).
Has anyone ran into a situation like this? Right now, I can see 3 options:
1. Signing a new 12 month lease with her alone and allow her to choose a room mate to lessen her load.
2. Signing a shorter term lease with her and her new room mate, based on the expected duration of their stay and allowing them to go month to month until they finally move out (then starting over with a new room mate and an uncertain plan).
3. Signing a 12 month lease that holds Tenant#1 responsible for the remainder of the lease should a new tenant move out.
Any advice? Any questions I can clear up to provide better advice?