***Official OHIO STATE-MICHIGAN Thread*** (1 Viewer)

[The Commish]

Dude, just stop. Stop presuming that people haven't moved away. Stop presuming that moving away defines how avid a fan someone is. And stop implying that your particular brand of fan is superior.

Yes, there are people who are bigger fans than others. It's a spectrum like anything else. What is your point?

And although not relevant, I don't like to miss an opportunity to post this: my team

I haven't posted anything about anyone else other than the other OSU fans I have run into here in SC. It's been my personal experiences, no one elses. Sorry you are reading into what I am saying, but I have no control over that. I don't presume anything. I only speak of the way things have unfolded for me and the folks who have had similar paths as me. Sorry that's so difficult to understand. I am sure there are those who have moved away and miss all the "passion" greatly and want nothing more than to be right in the middle of it. I understand for a lot of people the fighting, hate, bickering etc is what they live for. It's simply not for me.

 

[TxBuckeye]

Oddly enough, there was a whole big thread about that very topic. The OP insisted you could only truly be a fan of a college team if you went there. I wish I could find it.

 

[Bobcat10]

Oddly enough, there was a whole big thread about that very topic. The OP insisted you could only truly be a fan of a college team if you went there. I wish I could find it.

That's just messed up. Same with the "it's just an observation" schtick.

 

[GreatLakesMike]

Just so Commish knows he isn't on an island... As you can tell, I moved from Ohio (that's what the Buckeye part of the nick means, has nothing to do with OSU) to Texas a long time ago. While I do route for OSU to this day, I didn't get even remotely wound up about this game. Yes, I understand the rivalry and all that. But what the Commish says is true for me too, right now, it's just another game. No title implications at all. It has stolen a lot of the luster away from the game. Admittedly, I didn't even see the second half this year. Wife had some errands she wanted to run so we went and ran them. Didn't even Tivo the game. Wanted OSU to win, sure. But it wasn't worth missing out on other thngs for. Not sure if moving away is solely responsible. I think getting older is too. I don't get riled up to anywhere near the extent I did when I was younger. But I would never hang my season on one game. People that say things like "Well we went 1-10, but at least we beat XXX" really baffle me. That's the sound of just accepting losing.

I know I am not on an island. Actually, I think my/your view is more the norm, not the exception. Once you get away from that area you see it. I moved into a neighborhood here in SC where everyone in my cul-de-sac is an OSU fan. NONE of them have that "passion" people in that area claim to have. We enjoy giving each other the business (my neighbor went to UM also), but at the end of the day it's a football game. We don't care if the country thinks the game is or isn't the best rivalry in football/sports. What they think doesn't change what it means to us personally.

On a side note....I have YET to meet an OSU fan that actually graduated from there. I know there is one or two floating around here, but even in Cincy, none of the guys or their wives went to school there. It's very odd to me.

Nice to meet ya. Class of 2000 THE Ohio State University College of Optometry. Grew up 20 minutes from campus.

Class of 99

 

[beer 30]

I'll support Commish's hypothesis on this one. Big time OSU fan, graduated from Akron U. We never had a decent football team at Akron (still don't but there is a kick ### stadium now) and it was essentially a commuter school when I went there. 20,000+ students and probably less than 5,000 on-campus students. There was just never any support for them. OSU was drilled into my head by the old man, just like all my friends so we always just supported them. We went to Akron games but I don't go out of my to find an Akron game on tv.

 

[Leroy Hoard]

Oddly enough, there was a whole big thread about that very topic. The OP insisted you could only truly be a fan of a college team if you went there. I wish I could find it.

Unless you work for or played for the franchise you really should not root for any pro team either.

 

[Bobcat10]

I'll support Commish's hypothesis on this one. Big time OSU fan, graduated from Akron U. We never had a decent football team at Akron (still don't but there is a kick ### stadium now) and it was essentially a commuter school when I went there. 20,000+ students and probably less than 5,000 on-campus students. There was just never any support for them. OSU was drilled into my head by the old man, just like all my friends so we always just supported them. We went to Akron games but I don't go out of my to find an Akron game on tv.

If you didn't "grow up" rooting for the Buckeyes, then you would have just been rooting for some other large school, possibly in the area (Big10, Pitt, WVU, etc), if you are a college football fan. What's the difference? This "hypothesis" makes zero sense. It's not like you were branded Akron U from birth as the college you were going to go to. I went to Ohio U and didn't start "rooting" for them until I went there. Now they are my MAC team of preference.

 

[derek245583]

I live in Cincinnati. I graduated from UC, but it was my second college choice....I couldnt afford UM and I got a monster scholarship to UC.

The people down here are embarrassing. They are OSU fans in football and UC fans in basketball (Well up until Huggins got shafted a few years ago).

When asked why they are OSU fans, they say "They are my hometown team" What about UC?

They say they follow UC for basketball cause they are their "hometown team"

If UC didnt have a football program, ok I get....but they do and always have.....you cant pick and choose which programs to follow...

The real answer is "UC is the good basketball program in the general vicinity and OSU is the good football program in the general vicinity, so that is who I follow"

Its really getting dicey now that UC is better than OSU in football (I said it!)

 

[The Commish]

I'll support Commish's hypothesis on this one. Big time OSU fan, graduated from Akron U. We never had a decent football team at Akron (still don't but there is a kick ### stadium now) and it was essentially a commuter school when I went there. 20,000+ students and probably less than 5,000 on-campus students. There was just never any support for them. OSU was drilled into my head by the old man, just like all my friends so we always just supported them. We went to Akron games but I don't go out of my to find an Akron game on tv.

If you didn't "grow up" rooting for the Buckeyes, then you would have just been rooting for some other large school, possibly in the area (Big10, Pitt, WVU, etc), if you are a college football fan. What's the difference? This "hypothesis" makes zero sense. It's not like you were branded Akron U from birth as the college you were going to go to. I went to Ohio U and didn't start "rooting" for them until I went there. Now they are my MAC team of preference.

What exactly is my hypothesis again? I wasn't aware I was forming one.

 

[The Commish]

Oddly enough, there was a whole big thread about that very topic. The OP insisted you could only truly be a fan of a college team if you went there. I wish I could find it.

That's just messed up. Same with the "it's just an observation" schtick.

Ok...why does it bother you so?

 

[Glass Joe]

I live in Cincinnati. I graduated from UC, but it was my second college choice....I couldnt afford UM and I got a monster scholarship to UC.

The people down here are embarrassing. They are OSU fans in football and UC fans in basketball (Well up until Huggins got shafted a few years ago).

When asked why they are OSU fans, they say "They are my hometown team" What about UC?

They say they follow UC for basketball cause they are their "hometown team"

If UC didnt have a football program, ok I get....but they do and always have.....you cant pick and choose which programs to follow...

The real answer is "UC is the good basketball program in the general vicinity and OSU is the good football program in the general vicinity, so that is who I follow"

Its really getting dicey now that UC is better than OSU in football (I said it!)

As far as I've seen people in Cincinnati by and large dont root for OSU. It's a relatively crappy Buckeye town.And UC being better than OSU? Maybe this year, but it's only a matter of time before Kelly moves on to a big time program and returns UC to the afterthought it's always been.

 

[Bobcat10]

Oddly enough, there was a whole big thread about that very topic. The OP insisted you could only truly be a fan of a college team if you went there. I wish I could find it.

That's just messed up. Same with the "it's just an observation" schtick.

Ok...why does it bother you so?

Doesn't bother me, you can think how you want and I could care less. My finding something ridiculous doesn't mean I'm losing sleep over it. Surely, being in SC and all, you are finding many Clemson and USC fans that didn't go to college there. That is, if you are being observant.

 

[Glass Joe]

I'll support Commish's hypothesis on this one. Big time OSU fan, graduated from Akron U. We never had a decent football team at Akron (still don't but there is a kick ### stadium now) and it was essentially a commuter school when I went there. 20,000+ students and probably less than 5,000 on-campus students. There was just never any support for them. OSU was drilled into my head by the old man, just like all my friends so we always just supported them. We went to Akron games but I don't go out of my to find an Akron game on tv.

If you didn't "grow up" rooting for the Buckeyes, then you would have just been rooting for some other large school, possibly in the area (Big10, Pitt, WVU, etc), if you are a college football fan. What's the difference? This "hypothesis" makes zero sense. It's not like you were branded Akron U from birth as the college you were going to go to. I went to Ohio U and didn't start "rooting" for them until I went there. Now they are my MAC team of preference.

Class of 93 Miami University.

 

[Bobcat10]

I'll support Commish's hypothesis on this one. Big time OSU fan, graduated from Akron U. We never had a decent football team at Akron (still don't but there is a kick ### stadium now) and it was essentially a commuter school when I went there. 20,000+ students and probably less than 5,000 on-campus students. There was just never any support for them. OSU was drilled into my head by the old man, just like all my friends so we always just supported them. We went to Akron games but I don't go out of my to find an Akron game on tv.

If you didn't "grow up" rooting for the Buckeyes, then you would have just been rooting for some other large school, possibly in the area (Big10, Pitt, WVU, etc), if you are a college football fan. What's the difference? This "hypothesis" makes zero sense. It's not like you were branded Akron U from birth as the college you were going to go to. I went to Ohio U and didn't start "rooting" for them until I went there. Now they are my MAC team of preference.

Class of 93 Miami University.

Off subject....but neither school seems to be getting much love for hoops this year. I thought OU would be good. I guess it depends on Bassett's impact (IU transfer). Always a great rivaly though!

 

[The Commish]

Oddly enough, there was a whole big thread about that very topic. The OP insisted you could only truly be a fan of a college team if you went there. I wish I could find it.

That's just messed up. Same with the "it's just an observation" schtick.

Ok...why does it bother you so?

Doesn't bother me, you can think how you want and I could care less. My finding something ridiculous doesn't mean I'm losing sleep over it. Surely, being in SC and all, you are finding many Clemson and USC fans that didn't go to college there. That is, if you are being observant.

Of course. And I am also finding folks who are fans that actually graduated from those schools. I acknowledged this early on. It appears to me that you think I am saying something I am not.ETA: Hell, it's even true with my family. Three went to Miami, one to Kent, none to OSU.

 

[BigJohn]

Oddly enough, there was a whole big thread about that very topic. The OP insisted you could only truly be a fan of a college team if you went there. I wish I could find it.

That's just messed up. Same with the "it's just an observation" schtick.

Ok...why does it bother you so?

Doesn't bother me, you can think how you want and I could care less. My finding something ridiculous doesn't mean I'm losing sleep over it. Surely, being in SC and all, you are finding many Clemson and USC fans that didn't go to college there. That is, if you are being observant.

Of course. And I am also finding folks who are fans that actually graduated from those schools. I acknowledged this early on. It appears to me that you think I am saying something I am not.ETA: Hell, it's even true with my family. Three went to Miami, one to Kent, none to OSU.

The whole beef that people have with what you are saying is that you have this expectation that for people to root for a team, they needed to attend the school. Or, that somehow diminishes their "fanhood" because they didn't go to the school. Are people really supposed to hold off having favorite football teams until they go to college? Are people that didn't attend college at all not allowed to root for college teams? Are alumni somehow better fans than people who never went there?

 

[beer 30]

Of course. And I am also finding folks who are fans that actually graduated from those schools. I acknowledged this early on. It appears to me that you think I am saying something I am not.ETA: Hell, it's even true with my family. Three went to Miami, one to Kent, none to OSU.

Who went to Kent? I grew up 3 miles from Dix stadium.

 

[The Commish]

The whole beef that people have with what you are saying is that you have this expectation that for people to root for a team, they needed to attend the school. Or, that somehow diminishes their "fanhood" because they didn't go to the school. Are people really supposed to hold off having favorite football teams until they go to college? Are people that didn't attend college at all not allowed to root for college teams? Are alumni somehow better fans than people who never went there?

They can have thet beef, that's fine, but I am not saying any of that. Why can't people take my words at face value instead of having to read into them? Not sure what that's all about.

 

[The Commish]

Of course. And I am also finding folks who are fans that actually graduated from those schools. I acknowledged this early on. It appears to me that you think I am saying something I am not.ETA: Hell, it's even true with my family. Three went to Miami, one to Kent, none to OSU.

Who went to Kent? I grew up 3 miles from Dix stadium.

My cousin's husband. I went to a few games there...it was a pretty good time. They had their wedding reception on campus.

 

[BigJohn]

The whole beef that people have with what you are saying is that you have this expectation that for people to root for a team, they needed to attend the school. Or, that somehow diminishes their "fanhood" because they didn't go to the school. Are people really supposed to hold off having favorite football teams until they go to college? Are people that didn't attend college at all not allowed to root for college teams? Are alumni somehow better fans than people who never went there?

They can have thet beef, that's fine, but I am not saying any of that. Why can't people take my words at face value instead of having to read into them? Not sure what that's all about.

I have YET to meet an OSU fan that actually graduated from there. I know there is one or two floating around here, but even in Cincy, none of the guys or their wives went to school there. It's very odd to me.

What exactly is the "face value" of this statement? Nobody's really digging all that deep to see what you're saying here.

 

[The Commish]

The whole beef that people have with what you are saying is that you have this expectation that for people to root for a team, they needed to attend the school. Or, that somehow diminishes their "fanhood" because they didn't go to the school. Are people really supposed to hold off having favorite football teams until they go to college? Are people that didn't attend college at all not allowed to root for college teams? Are alumni somehow better fans than people who never went there?

They can have thet beef, that's fine, but I am not saying any of that. Why can't people take my words at face value instead of having to read into them? Not sure what that's all about.

I have YET to meet an OSU fan that actually graduated from there. I know there is one or two floating around here, but even in Cincy, none of the guys or their wives went to school there. It's very odd to me.

What exactly is the "face value" of this statement? Nobody's really digging all that deep to see what you're saying here.

That it's odd to me, given all the OSU fans I have run across in person, none of them have graduated from there. Same applies for Southern Cal fans.....never met one that's actually gone to school there, much less graduated. I figure with all the ones I've met, there'd be at least one graduate. Not sure how much more clear I can be.NOTE: I didn't address their "fandom" or that they weren't "real fans" or that they shouldn't be allowed to pull for OSU or that graduates were "better" fans in my eyes etc etc. That's Nipsey's shtick, not mine.

 

[goonsquad]

My beef is that UM has as big, if not bigger bandwagon non-graduate fan base than OSU and you're using this idea to rip OSU fan. I mean seriously dude, do you believe that every sweaty auto factory worker with a 'M' sticker on their truck right next to Calvin peeing on a Ford logo is some sort of UM engineering grad? Fact is any football team that wins as much as OSU or UM will attract the area's football fans. People want to root for the winner, even if they didn't go to school there. I would guess that a school like UM, with their high entrance requirements, has a higher percentage of non-alum fans.

So please address this hypocrisy for us. TIA.

 

[Mad Cow]

My beef is that UM has as big, if not bigger bandwagon non-graduate fan base than OSU and you're using this idea to rip OSU fan. I mean seriously dude, do you believe that every sweaty auto factory worker with a 'M' sticker on their truck right next to Calvin peeing on a Ford logo is some sort of UM engineering grad? Fact is any football team that wins as much as OSU or UM will attract the area's football fans. People want to root for the winner, even if they didn't go to school there. I would guess that a school like UM, with their high entrance requirements, has a higher percentage of non-alum fans. So please address this hypocrisy for us. TIA.

No kidding here. I am in Utah and there is tons of Michigan gear to be had, and very hard to find OSU stuff, even though there are more OSU grads around than UoM.

 

[The Commish]

My beef is that UM has as big, if not bigger bandwagon non-graduate fan base than OSU and you're using this idea to rip OSU fan. I mean seriously dude, do you believe that every sweaty auto factory worker with a 'M' sticker on their truck right next to Calvin peeing on a Ford logo is some sort of UM engineering grad? Fact is any football team that wins as much as OSU or UM will attract the area's football fans. People want to root for the winner, even if they didn't go to school there. I would guess that a school like UM, with their high entrance requirements, has a higher percentage of non-alum fans. So please address this hypocrisy for us. TIA.

please read this again and report back:

NOTE: I didn't address their "fandom" or that they weren't "real fans" or that they shouldn't be allowed to pull for OSU or that graduates were "better" fans in my eyes etc etc. That's Nipsey's shtick, not mine.

If you want the hypocrisy addressed, ask those who hold the hypocritical position. I can't answer for them. You people want this to be about me not thinking it's ok for someone to be a fan of a team if they didn't go there and I am telling you, that's not my point. I don't know how else to say it. I COULDN'T CARE LESS IF SOMEONE DID/DIDN'T GO TO A PARTICULAR SCHOOL. I SIMPLY FIND IT BIZARRE THAT I HAVE NEVER MET AN OSU GRAD IN PERSON OUT OF ALL THE OSU FANS I HAVE EVER MET.

 

[goonsquad]

My beef is that UM has as big, if not bigger bandwagon non-graduate fan base than OSU and you're using this idea to rip OSU fan. I mean seriously dude, do you believe that every sweaty auto factory worker with a 'M' sticker on their truck right next to Calvin peeing on a Ford logo is some sort of UM engineering grad? Fact is any football team that wins as much as OSU or UM will attract the area's football fans. People want to root for the winner, even if they didn't go to school there. I would guess that a school like UM, with their high entrance requirements, has a higher percentage of non-alum fans.

So please address this hypocrisy for us. TIA.

please read this again and report back:

NOTE: I didn't address their "fandom" or that they weren't "real fans" or that they shouldn't be allowed to pull for OSU or that graduates were "better" fans in my eyes etc etc. That's Nipsey's shtick, not mine.

If you want the hypocrisy addressed, ask those who hold the hypocritical position. I can't answer for them. You people want this to be about me not thinking it's ok for someone to be a fan of a team if they didn't go there and I am telling you, that's not my point. I don't know how else to say it. I COULDN'T CARE LESS IF SOMEONE DID/DIDN'T GO TO A PARTICULAR SCHOOL. I SIMPLY FIND IT BIZARRE THAT I HAVE NEVER MET AN OSU GRAD IN PERSON OUT OF ALL THE OSU FANS I HAVE EVER MET.

That's cool. Problem is your original comment didn't come off as simply a personal anecdote about your experience, it came off as a backhanded swipe at OSU fans. Which I find pretty funny considering you are a UM fan. The moral of the story is that both schools are full of non-alum bandwagon fans. MSU, on the other hand, has only true fans. Because honestly, as bad as we've been over the years only a true fan would root for Spartan football.

 

[The Commish]

My beef is that UM has as big, if not bigger bandwagon non-graduate fan base than OSU and you're using this idea to rip OSU fan. I mean seriously dude, do you believe that every sweaty auto factory worker with a 'M' sticker on their truck right next to Calvin peeing on a Ford logo is some sort of UM engineering grad? Fact is any football team that wins as much as OSU or UM will attract the area's football fans. People want to root for the winner, even if they didn't go to school there. I would guess that a school like UM, with their high entrance requirements, has a higher percentage of non-alum fans.

So please address this hypocrisy for us. TIA.

please read this again and report back:

NOTE: I didn't address their "fandom" or that they weren't "real fans" or that they shouldn't be allowed to pull for OSU or that graduates were "better" fans in my eyes etc etc. That's Nipsey's shtick, not mine.

If you want the hypocrisy addressed, ask those who hold the hypocritical position. I can't answer for them. You people want this to be about me not thinking it's ok for someone to be a fan of a team if they didn't go there and I am telling you, that's not my point. I don't know how else to say it. I COULDN'T CARE LESS IF SOMEONE DID/DIDN'T GO TO A PARTICULAR SCHOOL. I SIMPLY FIND IT BIZARRE THAT I HAVE NEVER MET AN OSU GRAD IN PERSON OUT OF ALL THE OSU FANS I HAVE EVER MET.

That's cool. Problem is your original comment didn't come off as simply a personal anecdote about your experience, it came off as a backhanded swipe at OSU fans. Which I find pretty funny considering you are a UM fan. The moral of the story is that both schools are full of non-alum bandwagon fans. MSU, on the other hand, has only true fans. Because honestly, as bad as we've been over the years only a true fan would root for Spartan football.

That wasn't the intent and exactly why I have tried to clarify it 50 times already. Something tells me that had folks not known that I am a UM guy, they probably wouldn't have thought twice about it.

 

[wadegarrett]

Michigan +18 @ Ohio State

 

[CBusAlex]

2,557

 

[wadegarrett]

Ohio State + 7.5 this year.

Hey, you guys might win one!

 

[beer 30]

Ohio State + 7.5 this year.Hey, you guys might win one!

NOT A ####### CHANCE!tOSU 31 - scUM - 3

 

[The Commish]

Ohio State + 7.5 this year.Hey, you guys might win one!

NOT A ####### CHANCE!tOSU 31 - scUM - 3

Was thinking at least 45. Is OSU down or something?

 

[beer 30]

Ohio State + 7.5 this year.Hey, you guys might win one!

NOT A ####### CHANCE!tOSU 31 - scUM - 3

Was thinking at least 45. Is OSU down or something?

or something, yea

 

[Leroy Hoard]

um 27 osu 24

 

[Raider Nation]

Tap.

Anyone like the Wolverines +16 at home? They gotta show a little pride, no?

 

[Sinrman]

Sad Michigan fan here. Will be rooting like crazy, but not feeling good vibes on this one. There's a reason we're 14 or so point underdogs AT home this year. :X

 

[Doctor Detroit]

This is not the most recent thread

ETA: Never mind, last two years were individual game threads I suppose. Doesn't make Ohio State players any less likely to cheat, so just use this thread I suppose.

 

[Raider Nation]

 

[Raider Nation]

Urban vs. Tom Brady Hoke is not a fair fight. Urban should be forced to coach blindfolded.

 

[Homer J Simpson]

Tap.

Anyone like the Wolverines +16 at home? They gotta show a little pride, no?

OSU needs the style points. If they don't win by 28, I'd consider it a loss.

 

[ShaqAttaq]

Tap.

Anyone like the Wolverines +16 at home? They gotta show a little pride, no?

unfortunately, no

 

[Dan Lambskin]

we're going to get pounded

tOSU 42, Hokes 10

 

[quickhands]

prediction. Buckeyes turn the big house into horseshoe north with tons of scalped tix.

 

[xulf]

Tap.

Anyone like the Wolverines +16 at home? They gotta show a little pride, no?

OSU needs the style points. If they don't win by 28, I'd consider it a loss.

 

[The Commish]

Yeah...offense has regressed so much that I don't see this being close. The defense is going to be on the field way too long and isn't deep enough yet to carry the team.

 

[jon_mx]

The defense sucks. The offense has disappeared. I would take OSU and the points. The only thing keeping the point spread 'low' is that it is a major rivalry and maybe Michigan might show up and play better.

 

[whoknew]

prediction. Buckeyes turn the big house into horseshoe north with tons of scalped tix.

I'll be there freezing my ### off to watch this #### team.

Go Blue! Remember Biakabatuka!

 

[cheese]

Tap.

Anyone like the Wolverines +16 at home? They gotta show a little pride, no?

OSU needs the style points. If they don't win by 28, I'd consider it a loss.

Don't agree at all. They need style points less than anyone. If they win both games by 1 the scenerio is the same. Either Bama or FSU lose and they are 100% in or bama/FSU don't lose and they're 100% out.

 

[MAC_32]

 

[CBusAlex]

Don't agree at all. They need style points less than anyone. If they win both games by 1 the scenerio is the same. Either Bama or FSU lose and they are 100% in or bama/FSU don't lose and they're 100% out.

I don't think they'd be 100% in over a 1-loss SEC champ.

 

[Homer J Simpson]

Don't agree at all. They need style points less than anyone. If they win both games by 1 the scenerio is the same. Either Bama or FSU lose and they are 100% in or bama/FSU don't lose and they're 100% out.

I don't think they'd be 100% in over a 1-loss SEC champ.

Exactry.

They need to beat the snot out of both Michigans.