What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Personal Finance Advice and Education! (13 Viewers)

Cool personal note, the 401K check showed up in the mail yesterday. Going to upload it to Fidelity and that's another account we don't have to think about.

At one point, we had:

My 401K: Schwab
My 2nd 401K and Roth: Fidelity
Wife's 401K: Prudential
Wife's Roth and Taxable brokerage Account: Vanguard
HSA $$ account: HSA Bank
HSA Investment account: TD Ameritrade (which became Schwab)
2nd HSA: Health Equity

Now it's down to:
Fidelity for my 401K, All HSA$, Roth
Vanguard for her Roth, Taxable brokerage
Prudential for her 401K.
 
Have a couple of questions

I work for the government. Wife owns an LLC but doesn't earn much. Combined we have $1.1M in 401(k), IRA, and brokerage account. Brokerage is $300k with $150k cost basis.

I plan to retire in 17 years if not sooner. I would draw FERS pension and SS. Wife probably wouldn't get much as she doesn't pay into it.

We have 3 kids with oldest about to be a junior. Oldest kid has 529s valued at $65k.

We have a house on a 30yr note (3.5%, $125k principal left, value $400k) that we don't intend to sell anytime soon.

No other debt.

My questions:
1) Due to a death in the family, we are now joint owners of a house in Nashville. Principal remaining is $325k and valued at 500k. 12 years left on the 15 year note. Joint owner wants to rent for sentimental reasons. I want whatever is best financially. We would need a management company as neither live close.

My concern is that this will really screw my oldest on any financial assistance. Thoughts on what to do?

2) I've been thinking of maxing out my 401(k) and selling from brokerage to make up for living expenses. Would help reduce FAFSA impact but not sure the overall positive gains are worth the financial hit of 15% capital gains. Thoughts?

3) Since wife is sole proprietor of her LLC, can we move money from the brokerage to fund her 401(k)?
 
Last edited:
Btw, I don't remember seeing that new i-bond rate discussed.

Currently a pretty strong 1.1% fixed rate and a combined rate of 3.98%.

That's not much lower than my current HYSA rate and a solid fixed rate for the future.
I go back and forth on it.

I've always said if we got any real fixed rate, I'd be in. My hangup: As you said, HYSA (and even money market accounts) are running similar to slightly better. Obviously, the I-bonds require a 1 year wait until you can redeem. Money market funds and HYSA don't have the liquidity issues.

My other thought: Being 25-30 years from retirement: Do I just want to throw that money into stocks and go for a higher return?

Finally, Thinking out loud: It seems like at times, that 1% is going to add substantial value. But at other times, you're going to be giving up better returns to buy into/hold onto that 1%.
Just another tool in diversification. Like you said, at times it will underperform, other times it will outperform.

Not a bad place to sock away some funds that can be both semi-short term but also be long term if you don't need and the landscape changes.
 
Being 25-30 years from retirement: Do I just want to throw that money into stocks and go for a higher return?
Is retirement the only purpose for these funds?

The only bonds, including I bonds, we own have a much shorter target. Their purpose is 1-15 years out, although we might keep them longer if we don’t have any emergencies, the markets don’t fall our first years in retirement and we decide to not buy the lake house (or use these funds for that).

If your only purpose of the I bonds is 25+ years away, I wouldn’t buy them. They’re not a great way to rebalance a portfolio, so I wouldn’t use them for that purpose if you want a 90/10 - just go 10% BND, SGOV, TLT… etc (I’m not sure which is best but SGOV is almost like cash)
 
1) Due to a death in the family, we are now joint owners of a house in Nashville. Principal remaining is $325k and valued at 500k. 12 years left on the 15 year note. Joint owner wants to rent for sentimental reasons. I want whatever is best financially. We would need a management company as neither live close.
IMO, someone should rent ten houses or zero. This is a huge PIA. Sell it. Simplify, simplify, simplify.

2) I've been thinking of maxing out my 401(k) and selling from brokerage to make up for living expenses. Would help reduce FAFSA impact but not sure the overall positive gains are worth the financial hit of 15% capital gains. Thoughts?

Monies in a taxable account give you flexibility. Maybe start stuffing monies into a Roth or, even better, an HSA (since you're govt. maybe an HSA isn't possible) than more into pre-tax accounts? Not sure how much it will move the FAFSA needle. Maybe run some scenarios and see if it matters.

3) Since wife is sole proprietor of her LLC, can we move money from the brokerage to fund her 401(k)?

Sounds reasonable, but monetary flexibility is worth something.
 
Using cash, brokerage, savings whatever to pay yourself so you can use the paycheck to funnel money into tax sheltered accounts is a no-brainer. Don't over think it, just do it why you have the means to
 
1) Due to a death in the family, we are now joint owners of a house in Nashville. Principal remaining is $325k and valued at 500k. 12 years left on the 15 year note. Joint owner wants to rent for sentimental reasons. I want whatever is best financially. We would need a management company as neither live close.
IMO, someone should rent ten houses or zero. This is a huge PIA. Sell it. Simplify, simplify, simplify.

2) I've been thinking of maxing out my 401(k) and selling from brokerage to make up for living expenses. Would help reduce FAFSA impact but not sure the overall positive gains are worth the financial hit of 15% capital gains. Thoughts?

Monies in a taxable account give you flexibility. Maybe start stuffing monies into a Roth or, even better, an HSA (since you're govt. maybe an HSA isn't possible) than more into pre-tax accounts? Not sure how much it will move the FAFSA needle. Maybe run some scenarios and see if it matters.

3) Since wife is sole proprietor of her LLC, can we move money from the brokerage to fund her 401(k)?

Sounds reasonable, but monetary flexibility is worth something.
apparently you can only do up to 25% of the companies gross income.
 
401K landed on Fidleity. It's finally all done. Investments consolidated down to Fidelity, Vanguard, and her 401K on Prudential. And I-bonds, but those are zero monitoring/effort once you've bought them.

I'm a few purchases away from being able to start DCA'ing into the taxable account. We're getting a deck built for our above ground pool. And then we plan to get new living room furniture. We have quite a bit in savings/checking, but want to figure out what's left after those purchases.
 
This seems to be the right place for this since the bill is now law. A good breakdown of the OBBB provisions. Big changes for seniors (time limited good ones), changes to the ACA, changes to charitable donations, etc.

 
This seems to be the right place for this since the bill is now law. A good breakdown of the OBBB provisions. Big changes for seniors (time limited good ones), changes to the ACA, changes to charitable donations, etc.

:blackdot:
Thanks, was looking for a good summary. The big ones for me: TCJA tax bracket made permanent and TCJA standard deduction made permanent. I'd like to see the SS deduction made permanent or eliminate taxes on SS all together. Wonder if they'll try again in 2028. Nothing else affects me much.
 
This seems to be the right place for this since the bill is now law. A good breakdown of the OBBB provisions. Big changes for seniors (time limited good ones), changes to the ACA, changes to charitable donations, etc.

:blackdot:
Thanks, was looking for a good summary. The big ones for me: TCJA tax bracket made permanent and TCJA standard deduction made permanent. I'd like to see the SS deduction made permanent or eliminate taxes on SS all together. Wonder if they'll try again in 2028. Nothing else affects me much.
Good article on what this bill did for taxation of SS.

 
Extra savings were going into VTI in my brokerage account. Future money is going into a MMF. Not selling or changing retirement account mixes, but more liquidity will help me sleep at night. Cutting expenses for the near term as well.
Sure feels like the market upside is really low right now and the market downside is really high. Like SP500 could be at max +5%, but also -15% or worse.
Really should have listened to my own advice here. Instead, I'm riding it doooooooown.
Tariffs threatening to make a comeback on Aug 1. What are you feeling this time?
 
here’s a question i think i know the answer to, but i want to spitball. finished working a year ago and this year i hit the dreaded 59.5, an interesting 1/2 birfday since i can now access retirement monies penalty free. i worked half year 2024, wife has same job, same salary. filed our taxes and fed refund was aboot 10k. i use turbo tax. essentially, i reran the program removing my w2 and our refund increased. my goal is to -0- out at year end, no pay and no refund. am i right to think i should take non roth retirement funds during 2025 equal to an amount that will reduce that tax refund down to -0-? in this way i am offsetting taxable income that may occur when our or her income is less or nil?

edit to say i will reinvest these funds into mutuals i already have at vanguard.
 
here’s a question i think i know the answer to, but i want to spitball. finished working a year ago and this year i hit the dreaded 59.5, an interesting 1/2 birfday since i can now access retirement monies penalty free. i worked half year 2024, wife has same job, same salary. filed our taxes and fed refund was aboot 10k. i use turbo tax. essentially, i reran the program removing my w2 and our refund increased. my goal is to -0- out at year end, no pay and no refund. am i right to think i should take non roth retirement funds during 2025 equal to an amount that will reduce that tax refund down to -0-? in this way i am offsetting taxable income that may occur when our or her income is less or nil?

edit to say i will reinvest these funds into mutuals i already have at vanguard.
I dont think so. Without knowing a bunch more specifics it sounds like you're trying to up your income to pay more taxes so you don't get a refund. That's the opposite of what you want to do.

Unless you're doing a 401k or IRA rollover to Roth. That way you'd be using the money the govmt owes you to pay the tax now and get it into Roth and eventually pay less taxes in the long run. It is a 100% tax avoidance adventure from here on out.

Since you said you don't need the money (would be reinvesting) I would not take it out of a retirement (tax sheltered) account. The goal is to keep those accounts invested as long as possible. I'd take the biggest refund I could get and invest that before taking stuff out of a retirement account.
 
here’s a question i think i know the answer to, but i want to spitball. finished working a year ago and this year i hit the dreaded 59.5, an interesting 1/2 birfday since i can now access retirement monies penalty free. i worked half year 2024, wife has same job, same salary. filed our taxes and fed refund was aboot 10k. i use turbo tax. essentially, i reran the program removing my w2 and our refund increased. my goal is to -0- out at year end, no pay and no refund. am i right to think i should take non roth retirement funds during 2025 equal to an amount that will reduce that tax refund down to -0-? in this way i am offsetting taxable income that may occur when our or her income is less or nil?

edit to say i will reinvest these funds into mutuals i already have at vanguard.
I dont think so. Without knowing a bunch more specifics it sounds like you're trying to up your income to pay more taxes so you don't get a refund. That's the opposite of what you want to do.

Unless you're doing a 401k or IRA rollover to Roth. That way you'd be using the money the govmt owes you to pay the tax now and get it into Roth and eventually pay less taxes in the long run. It is a 100% tax avoidance adventure from here on out.

Since you said you don't need the money (would be reinvesting) I would not take it out of a retirement (tax sheltered) account. The goal is to keep those accounts invested as long as possible. I'd take the biggest refund I could get and invest that before taking stuff out of a retirement account.
but if the account isn’t a Roth, it’s not tax sheltered, or is it? have i been looking at it wrong? no matter when i pull it, i am responsible for taxes, no? or is a simple matter of i am in better shape tax wise to pull it when neither of us are working?
 
here’s a question i think i know the answer to, but i want to spitball. finished working a year ago and this year i hit the dreaded 59.5, an interesting 1/2 birfday since i can now access retirement monies penalty free. i worked half year 2024, wife has same job, same salary. filed our taxes and fed refund was aboot 10k. i use turbo tax. essentially, i reran the program removing my w2 and our refund increased. my goal is to -0- out at year end, no pay and no refund. am i right to think i should take non roth retirement funds during 2025 equal to an amount that will reduce that tax refund down to -0-? in this way i am offsetting taxable income that may occur when our or her income is less or nil?

edit to say i will reinvest these funds into mutuals i already have at vanguard.
I dont think so. Without knowing a bunch more specifics it sounds like you're trying to up your income to pay more taxes so you don't get a refund. That's the opposite of what you want to do.

Unless you're doing a 401k or IRA rollover to Roth. That way you'd be using the money the govmt owes you to pay the tax now and get it into Roth and eventually pay less taxes in the long run. It is a 100% tax avoidance adventure from here on out.

Since you said you don't need the money (would be reinvesting) I would not take it out of a retirement (tax sheltered) account. The goal is to keep those accounts invested as long as possible. I'd take the biggest refund I could get and invest that before taking stuff out of a retirement account.
but if the account isn’t a Roth, it’s not tax sheltered, or is it? have i been looking at it wrong? no matter when i pull it, i am responsible for taxes, no? or is a simple matter of i am in better shape tax wise to pull it when neither of us are working?
I’d pull out the funds when you need them. If you are at a marginal tax rate now that is lower than you would be in the future, I’d do Roth Conversions up to that next level. I would not use the amount being withheld as a factor in the decision.
 
here’s a question i think i know the answer to, but i want to spitball. finished working a year ago and this year i hit the dreaded 59.5, an interesting 1/2 birfday since i can now access retirement monies penalty free. i worked half year 2024, wife has same job, same salary. filed our taxes and fed refund was aboot 10k. i use turbo tax. essentially, i reran the program removing my w2 and our refund increased. my goal is to -0- out at year end, no pay and no refund. am i right to think i should take non roth retirement funds during 2025 equal to an amount that will reduce that tax refund down to -0-? in this way i am offsetting taxable income that may occur when our or her income is less or nil?

edit to say i will reinvest these funds into mutuals i already have at vanguard.
I dont think so. Without knowing a bunch more specifics it sounds like you're trying to up your income to pay more taxes so you don't get a refund. That's the opposite of what you want to do.

Unless you're doing a 401k or IRA rollover to Roth. That way you'd be using the money the govmt owes you to pay the tax now and get it into Roth and eventually pay less taxes in the long run. It is a 100% tax avoidance adventure from here on out.

Since you said you don't need the money (would be reinvesting) I would not take it out of a retirement (tax sheltered) account. The goal is to keep those accounts invested as long as possible. I'd take the biggest refund I could get and invest that before taking stuff out of a retirement account.
but if the account isn’t a Roth, it’s not tax sheltered, or is it? have i been looking at it wrong? no matter when i pull it, i am responsible for taxes, no? or is a simple matter of i am in better shape tax wise to pull it when neither of us are working?
I’d pull out the funds when you need them. If you are at a marginal tax rate now that is lower than you would be in the future, I’d do Roth Conversions up to that next level. I would not use the amount being withheld as a factor in the decision.
so, i have an existing Roth IRA. with wife’s income i have to be at a higher rate now, no? theoretically, instead of pulling out x amount and paying taxes on it, you are saying i should convert the portion i want from regular to roth, pay the income taxes now and let that money accumulate free?
 
here’s a question i think i know the answer to, but i want to spitball. finished working a year ago and this year i hit the dreaded 59.5, an interesting 1/2 birfday since i can now access retirement monies penalty free. i worked half year 2024, wife has same job, same salary. filed our taxes and fed refund was aboot 10k. i use turbo tax. essentially, i reran the program removing my w2 and our refund increased. my goal is to -0- out at year end, no pay and no refund. am i right to think i should take non roth retirement funds during 2025 equal to an amount that will reduce that tax refund down to -0-? in this way i am offsetting taxable income that may occur when our or her income is less or nil?

edit to say i will reinvest these funds into mutuals i already have at vanguard.
I dont think so. Without knowing a bunch more specifics it sounds like you're trying to up your income to pay more taxes so you don't get a refund. That's the opposite of what you want to do.

Unless you're doing a 401k or IRA rollover to Roth. That way you'd be using the money the govmt owes you to pay the tax now and get it into Roth and eventually pay less taxes in the long run. It is a 100% tax avoidance adventure from here on out.

Since you said you don't need the money (would be reinvesting) I would not take it out of a retirement (tax sheltered) account. The goal is to keep those accounts invested as long as possible. I'd take the biggest refund I could get and invest that before taking stuff out of a retirement account.
but if the account isn’t a Roth, it’s not tax sheltered, or is it? have i been looking at it wrong? no matter when i pull it, i am responsible for taxes, no? or is a simple matter of i am in better shape tax wise to pull it when neither of us are working?
It is because it's tax defered. Gains compound over and over and it only counts as income when you eventually cash out. We spend a lot of effort getting every penny we can into retirement accounts, then lose a big part of that ability when you no longer have a paycheck, so you don't want to take them out until you absolutely need to.

And yes using it as income when the time comes you want to be in as low a tax bracket as possible. It's all about tax avoidance, and that includes pushing deferred accounts out out in time cashing only when you need at a low tax bracket.

Paying tax and converting to a Roth is a very good idea if and when you're in a low tax bracket.
 
here’s a question i think i know the answer to, but i want to spitball. finished working a year ago and this year i hit the dreaded 59.5, an interesting 1/2 birfday since i can now access retirement monies penalty free. i worked half year 2024, wife has same job, same salary. filed our taxes and fed refund was aboot 10k. i use turbo tax. essentially, i reran the program removing my w2 and our refund increased. my goal is to -0- out at year end, no pay and no refund. am i right to think i should take non roth retirement funds during 2025 equal to an amount that will reduce that tax refund down to -0-? in this way i am offsetting taxable income that may occur when our or her income is less or nil?

edit to say i will reinvest these funds into mutuals i already have at vanguard.
I dont think so. Without knowing a bunch more specifics it sounds like you're trying to up your income to pay more taxes so you don't get a refund. That's the opposite of what you want to do.

Unless you're doing a 401k or IRA rollover to Roth. That way you'd be using the money the govmt owes you to pay the tax now and get it into Roth and eventually pay less taxes in the long run. It is a 100% tax avoidance adventure from here on out.

Since you said you don't need the money (would be reinvesting) I would not take it out of a retirement (tax sheltered) account. The goal is to keep those accounts invested as long as possible. I'd take the biggest refund I could get and invest that before taking stuff out of a retirement account.
but if the account isn’t a Roth, it’s not tax sheltered, or is it? have i been looking at it wrong? no matter when i pull it, i am responsible for taxes, no? or is a simple matter of i am in better shape tax wise to pull it when neither of us are working?
It is because it's tax defered. Gains compound over and over and it only counts as income when you eventually cash out. We spend a lot of effort getting every penny we can into retirement accounts, then lose a big part of that ability when you no longer have a paycheck, so you don't want to take them out until you absolutely need to.

And yes using it as income when the time comes you want to be in as low a tax bracket as possible. It's all about tax avoidance, and that includes pushing deferred accounts out out in time cashing only when you need at a low tax bracket.

Paying tax and converting to a Roth is a very good idea if and when you're in a low tax bracket.
so, better to wait for my marginal tax rate to be 12% rather than 24%?
 
here’s a question i think i know the answer to, but i want to spitball. finished working a year ago and this year i hit the dreaded 59.5, an interesting 1/2 birfday since i can now access retirement monies penalty free. i worked half year 2024, wife has same job, same salary. filed our taxes and fed refund was aboot 10k. i use turbo tax. essentially, i reran the program removing my w2 and our refund increased. my goal is to -0- out at year end, no pay and no refund. am i right to think i should take non roth retirement funds during 2025 equal to an amount that will reduce that tax refund down to -0-? in this way i am offsetting taxable income that may occur when our or her income is less or nil?

edit to say i will reinvest these funds into mutuals i already have at vanguard.
I dont think so. Without knowing a bunch more specifics it sounds like you're trying to up your income to pay more taxes so you don't get a refund. That's the opposite of what you want to do.

Unless you're doing a 401k or IRA rollover to Roth. That way you'd be using the money the govmt owes you to pay the tax now and get it into Roth and eventually pay less taxes in the long run. It is a 100% tax avoidance adventure from here on out.

Since you said you don't need the money (would be reinvesting) I would not take it out of a retirement (tax sheltered) account. The goal is to keep those accounts invested as long as possible. I'd take the biggest refund I could get and invest that before taking stuff out of a retirement account.
but if the account isn’t a Roth, it’s not tax sheltered, or is it? have i been looking at it wrong? no matter when i pull it, i am responsible for taxes, no? or is a simple matter of i am in better shape tax wise to pull it when neither of us are working?
I’d pull out the funds when you need them. If you are at a marginal tax rate now that is lower than you would be in the future, I’d do Roth Conversions up to that next level. I would not use the amount being withheld as a factor in the decision.
so, i have an existing Roth IRA. with wife’s income i have to be at a higher rate now, no? theoretically, instead of pulling out x amount and paying taxes on it, you are saying i should convert the portion i want from regular to roth, pay the income taxes now and let that money accumulate free?
Is wife retiring soon? If so wait until the year after you're both retired, look at the tax brackets and see how much. If you have zero other income you can convert $96,000 before you jump up to the 22% tax bracket. Pay your 11.5% on that and it will be all tax free from then on out. If you're living good you can make 11% up in a single year invested.

That's what I'm going to start doing next year. Rinse and repeat every year until RMDs kick in to minimize their effect as much as I can.

You have to be careful of some other things though like ACA subsidies that have income limits too.
 
here’s a question i think i know the answer to, but i want to spitball. finished working a year ago and this year i hit the dreaded 59.5, an interesting 1/2 birfday since i can now access retirement monies penalty free. i worked half year 2024, wife has same job, same salary. filed our taxes and fed refund was aboot 10k. i use turbo tax. essentially, i reran the program removing my w2 and our refund increased. my goal is to -0- out at year end, no pay and no refund. am i right to think i should take non roth retirement funds during 2025 equal to an amount that will reduce that tax refund down to -0-? in this way i am offsetting taxable income that may occur when our or her income is less or nil?

edit to say i will reinvest these funds into mutuals i already have at vanguard.
I dont think so. Without knowing a bunch more specifics it sounds like you're trying to up your income to pay more taxes so you don't get a refund. That's the opposite of what you want to do.

Unless you're doing a 401k or IRA rollover to Roth. That way you'd be using the money the govmt owes you to pay the tax now and get it into Roth and eventually pay less taxes in the long run. It is a 100% tax avoidance adventure from here on out.

Since you said you don't need the money (would be reinvesting) I would not take it out of a retirement (tax sheltered) account. The goal is to keep those accounts invested as long as possible. I'd take the biggest refund I could get and invest that before taking stuff out of a retirement account.
but if the account isn’t a Roth, it’s not tax sheltered, or is it? have i been looking at it wrong? no matter when i pull it, i am responsible for taxes, no? or is a simple matter of i am in better shape tax wise to pull it when neither of us are working?
It is because it's tax defered. Gains compound over and over and it only counts as income when you eventually cash out. We spend a lot of effort getting every penny we can into retirement accounts, then lose a big part of that ability when you no longer have a paycheck, so you don't want to take them out until you absolutely need to.

And yes using it as income when the time comes you want to be in as low a tax bracket as possible. It's all about tax avoidance, and that includes pushing deferred accounts out out in time cashing only when you need at a low tax bracket.

Paying tax and converting to a Roth is a very good idea if and when you're in a low tax bracket.
so, better to wait for my marginal tax rate to be 12% rather than 24%?
BINGO. see above
 
Lots of value in this thread - currently reading up on 72(t) and rule of 55 and using both to tap retirement savings before 55. Not sure if it is possible for me, as health care still seems to be the wild card, but having the option seems nice.
 
Lots of value in this thread - currently reading up on 72(t) and rule of 55 and using both to tap retirement savings before 55. Not sure if it is possible for me, as health care still seems to be the wild card, but having the option seems nice.
Another reading assignment: https://www.reddit.com/r/Fire/comments/1lttnnh/reconciliation_billobbba_megathread_please_direct/

In particular, look at the first reply that goes through Bronze Plans and all being treated as HSAs. You can perform all kinds of shenanigans to stay under the 400% FPL limit using this. The OBBB did early retirement folks a solid.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top