Bad judges of talent know this too.So many haters around here lately. Its a good thread - where people should be able to talk about what there "eyes" are seeing in the Pre-Season.Good judges of talent know their eyes dont lie.
yeah, on my radar, wasn't beforeClausen likes Olsen, Cam likes Olsen, now Bass likes Olsen.
Yup, this. I know who Harris is, BigTex.I think he meant, "from who is he taking the #2 spot", Austin or Bryant.Dallas, he's from ECU:Uh, from who?Watching Dwayne Harris play.......WOW!!!! If he keeps that up he'll not just past the #3 spot but take over the #2 spot.
I love hearing this. If I could pick up Roddy at 7WR, I would be doing so with some serious wood.Roddy White down to 5-7 WR range and Fitzgertald back up to top 3 from 5-7 range. All the lockout workouts with Kolb, sounds like they're attached to the hip in camp and in the locker (reminicent of Moss/Brady first year).
I don't think people are saying go get this guy at whatever cost but I play in several zealots leagues and Harris is one of very few players who is showing something that is available at auction right now. Probably a decent player to spend a few zbucks on and stash away.'ffldrew said:Lets remember that Dwayne Harris lit up the 3rd string Bronco defense - which is basically a slight step above a mid Division I college D. Broncos are looking for anyone with a pulse for 3rd string D. I'd slow down on that one. But you have to love a guy that pimps himself after a game -"Big-time players make big-time catches in big-time situations," Harris said. "That's what happened."
not saying Roddy won't be drafted higher than WR7 - he's just getting to high for me to take him after AJ and Calvin....rather have Fitz and Nicks before Roddy this year.'PizzaDeliveryGuy said:I love hearing this. If I could pick up Roddy at 7WR, I would be doing so with some serious wood.'Largent said:Roddy White down to 5-7 WR range and Fitzgertald back up to top 3 from 5-7 range. All the lockout workouts with Kolb, sounds like they're attached to the hip in camp and in the locker (reminicent of Moss/Brady first year).
I can't really argue with you there although the only slam dunk for me would be AJ over Roddy.not saying Roddy won't be drafted higher than WR7 - he's just getting to high for me to take him after AJ and Calvin....rather have Fitz and Nicks before Roddy this year.'PizzaDeliveryGuy said:I love hearing this. If I could pick up Roddy at 7WR, I would be doing so with some serious wood.'Largent said:Roddy White down to 5-7 WR range and Fitzgertald back up to top 3 from 5-7 range. All the lockout workouts with Kolb, sounds like they're attached to the hip in camp and in the locker (reminicent of Moss/Brady first year).
LOL, sorry...........'ConnSKINS26 said:Yup, this. I know who Harris is, BigTex.'Hoosier16 said:I think he meant, "from who is he taking the #2 spot", Austin or Bryant.'BigTex said:Dallas, he's from ECU:Uh, from who?Watching Dwayne Harris play.......WOW!!!! If he keeps that up he'll not just past the #3 spot but take over the #2 spot.

I'd agree with this. If preseason doesn't mean anything to you, find another thread. But lots of people pay very close attention to preseason. I'm one. Obviously, you have to view in the context of what it is, but preseason is important for lots of players.Jnice thread....and tough to understand why all the hate from guys who dismiss preseason games, especially week 1, yet still come into the thread and post nothing that helps at all....if you know it's not your cup of tea, just stay out....I like to see some guys pass the eye ball test...Julio: real dealHarris: let's temper for a second, the 70 yarder was blown coverage, I can see why some are excited but a lot of mouths to feed and Ogletree may give him a run when all is said and done...KC: it is going to be a long year, just got a bad feeling people are going to be disappointed in the production they get from a first rounder (Charles) or a possible second rounder (Bowe)....schedule is brutal...and that team just isn't that good....Cassel worries me...NE: how many offers will they be getting for Mallett...?....some teams kicking themselves right now (hello MIA) for letting NE get this guy....CHI: adding them to the list of teams that I may just avoid all together unless it is crazy value....that Oline is terrible and it all starts there on offense....I'd be worried...
Was thinking this as well until I read this from Peter King this morning...'Largent said:Fitzgertald back up to top 3 from 5-7 range. All the lockout workouts with Kolb, sounds like they're attached to the hip in camp and in the locker (reminicent of Moss/Brady first year).
Now...• ARIZONA: Larry Fitzgerald Warning Dept.: Kevin Kolb, playing for Philadelphia last year, completed 30.8 percent of his throws that traveled at least 20 yards downfield ... compared to 40.4 percent for the run-out-of-town Derek Anderson.
CHI: adding them to the list of teams that I may just avoid all together unless it is crazy value....that Oline is terrible and it all starts there on offense....I'd be worried...

Kolb didn't have Fitzgerald last season. If Larry keeps making grabs like he did the other night, and he will, Kolb won't have any problem completing plenty of deep balls to Fitz.Was thinking this as well until I read this from Peter King this morning...'Largent said:Fitzgertald back up to top 3 from 5-7 range. All the lockout workouts with Kolb, sounds like they're attached to the hip in camp and in the locker (reminicent of Moss/Brady first year).Now...• ARIZONA: Larry Fitzgerald Warning Dept.: Kevin Kolb, playing for Philadelphia last year, completed 30.8 percent of his throws that traveled at least 20 yards downfield ... compared to 40.4 percent for the run-out-of-town Derek Anderson.![]()
Not as if Maclin and Jackson are scrubs though.Kolb didn't have Fitzgerald last season. If Larry keeps making grabs like he did the other night, and he will, Kolb won't have any problem completing plenty of deep balls to Fitz.Was thinking this as well until I read this from Peter King this morning...'Largent said:Fitzgertald back up to top 3 from 5-7 range. All the lockout workouts with Kolb, sounds like they're attached to the hip in camp and in the locker (reminicent of Moss/Brady first year).Now...• ARIZONA: Larry Fitzgerald Warning Dept.: Kevin Kolb, playing for Philadelphia last year, completed 30.8 percent of his throws that traveled at least 20 yards downfield ... compared to 40.4 percent for the run-out-of-town Derek Anderson.![]()
I think you're oversimplifying it a bit. Those LB's aren't going to be playing the run once they diagnose the play as pass. And if it's 3rd and long, the D is going to be in nickel or dime pre-snap regardless of who the RB is.I don't see how Julio having good numbers lowers Roddy's numbers. If anything it just means that the DF's will not be able to double cover White. Think about it. You have to have at least 7 guys in the box to stop Turner. Gonzo is going to draw coverage over the middle too. You have to have a CB on Julio and will also need to keep deep safety help (probably a cover two DF) to prevent Julio from just going over the top, and how many defenders does that leave on White???I'm bumping down Roddy White out of the top 5 but still in the top 10. FBG projections have him on average at 94 receptions and Julio Jones at 58 (155 total). Jones definitely appears NFL ready and an obvious upgrade to what White had last year on the other side.Julio Jones and the entire Falcons offense
Assuming the same total receptions (and taking into account Smith surely force-fed the ball to the rookie last night), a split of 80-85 for White and 70-75 for Jones seems more likely if Jones continues to impress.
So yes, Turner, Gonzo,and Julio will all get theirs, however, White should face softer coverage than last year underneath. I think that his TD's might go down to like 6-8, but his receptions might actually go up as well as his yards. I think that the real winner in this case might be Matt Ryan.... And J Rogers, if something were to happen to Turner.
In this case it sounds like the player has adjusted you up.'PizzaDeliveryGuy said:I love hearing this. If I could pick up Roddy at 7WR, I would be doing so with some serious wood.'Largent said:Roddy White down to 5-7 WR range and Fitzgertald back up to top 3 from 5-7 range. All the lockout workouts with Kolb, sounds like they're attached to the hip in camp and in the locker (reminicent of Moss/Brady first year).
I've argued taking Julio Jones over A.J. Green since the draft but his stock har risen to the point where he's no longer a value in redraft leagues. In dynasty he has been consistently going in the top 4 picks already.Right. The numbers for Kolb apply. It's a small sample so you have to be careful but you can't blame them on his receivers.I can't pin it down exactly but I have an uneasy feeling about Kolb. I keep getting a vague and blurry picture of Scott Mitchell. But that's totally a gut feel and I can't quantify it. So take it for what it's worth.JNot as if Maclin and Jackson are scrubs though.Kolb didn't have Fitzgerald last season. If Larry keeps making grabs like he did the other night, and he will, Kolb won't have any problem completing plenty of deep balls to Fitz.Was thinking this as well until I read this from Peter King this morning...'Largent said:Fitzgertald back up to top 3 from 5-7 range. All the lockout workouts with Kolb, sounds like they're attached to the hip in camp and in the locker (reminicent of Moss/Brady first year).Now...• ARIZONA: Larry Fitzgerald Warning Dept.: Kevin Kolb, playing for Philadelphia last year, completed 30.8 percent of his throws that traveled at least 20 yards downfield ... compared to 40.4 percent for the run-out-of-town Derek Anderson.![]()
Lol...dynasty rookie drafts.Top four overall? Wow.
I'm always careful about making projections based on a perceived weak offensive line, especially in preseason. Sometimes OLs turn out to be as bad as advertised, but sometimes lines just manage to gel when they are not expected to. For us fans, it's hard to truly evaluate unless you get to see them in the trenches on a regular basis. And of course, sometimes talent can manage to produce even without a great OL.CHI: adding them to the list of teams that I may just avoid all together unless it is crazy value....that Oline is terrible and it all starts there on offense....I'd be worried...![]()
Scott Mitchell threw for 4,000+ YDS and 30+ TDs in his first full season in Detroit. If Kolb stays healthy and matches that, I'll take it.Right. The numbers for Kolb apply. It's a small sample so you have to be careful but you can't blame them on his receivers.I can't pin it down exactly but I have an uneasy feeling about Kolb. I keep getting a vague and blurry picture of Scott Mitchell. But that's totally a gut feel and I can't quantify it. So take it for what it's worth.JNot as if Maclin and Jackson are scrubs though.Kolb didn't have Fitzgerald last season. If Larry keeps making grabs like he did the other night, and he will, Kolb won't have any problem completing plenty of deep balls to Fitz.Was thinking this as well until I read this from Peter King this morning...'Largent said:Fitzgertald back up to top 3 from 5-7 range. All the lockout workouts with Kolb, sounds like they're attached to the hip in camp and in the locker (reminicent of Moss/Brady first year).Now...• ARIZONA: Larry Fitzgerald Warning Dept.: Kevin Kolb, playing for Philadelphia last year, completed 30.8 percent of his throws that traveled at least 20 yards downfield ... compared to 40.4 percent for the run-out-of-town Derek Anderson.![]()
they are not in the same class as Fitz. at least when it comes to catching. not many areNot as if Maclin and Jackson are scrubs though.Kolb didn't have Fitzgerald last season. If Larry keeps making grabs like he did the other night, and he will, Kolb won't have any problem completing plenty of deep balls to Fitz.Was thinking this as well until I read this from Peter King this morning...'Largent said:Fitzgertald back up to top 3 from 5-7 range. All the lockout workouts with Kolb, sounds like they're attached to the hip in camp and in the locker (reminicent of Moss/Brady first year).Now...• ARIZONA: Larry Fitzgerald Warning Dept.: Kevin Kolb, playing for Philadelphia last year, completed 30.8 percent of his throws that traveled at least 20 yards downfield ... compared to 40.4 percent for the run-out-of-town Derek Anderson.![]()
So Kolb was 4/7 for 68 yards and Fitzt had 2 for 60 yards . . . 1 of which was a great catch by Fitz. So he had 2 other completions for 8 yards . . . what were those like? Just seems like misleading stats when you consider Fitz.Kolb didn't have Fitzgerald last season. If Larry keeps making grabs like he did the other night, and he will, Kolb won't have any problem completing plenty of deep balls to Fitz.Was thinking this as well until I read this from Peter King this morning...'Largent said:Fitzgertald back up to top 3 from 5-7 range. All the lockout workouts with Kolb, sounds like they're attached to the hip in camp and in the locker (reminicent of Moss/Brady first year).Now...• ARIZONA: Larry Fitzgerald Warning Dept.: Kevin Kolb, playing for Philadelphia last year, completed 30.8 percent of his throws that traveled at least 20 yards downfield ... compared to 40.4 percent for the run-out-of-town Derek Anderson.![]()
how old are those guys though? Kerley could have an impact sooner than laterThe other deep rookie pick that I liked the potential but question the immediate opportunity is Jeremy Kerley. He's been impressive in camp but if Mason and Plaxico stay on the field, he'll have a hard time finding his way to the field (on offense).
This argument looks plausible but be careful here, my timing may be a year off but I believe there was a dude named Barry lined up behind Mitchell in his first full season. Herman Moore and Larry Fitz are probably in the same talent level so at least Fitz will help Kolb look better like Moore did for Mitchell.'Frankbot said:Scott Mitchell threw for 4,000+ YDS and 30+ TDs in his first full season in Detroit. If Kolb stays healthy and matches that, I'll take it.'Joe Bryant said:Right. The numbers for Kolb apply. It's a small sample so you have to be careful but you can't blame them on his receivers.I can't pin it down exactly but I have an uneasy feeling about Kolb. I keep getting a vague and blurry picture of Scott Mitchell. But that's totally a gut feel and I can't quantify it. So take it for what it's worth.J'sho nuff said:Not as if Maclin and Jackson are scrubs though.'Grahamburn said:Kolb didn't have Fitzgerald last season. If Larry keeps making grabs like he did the other night, and he will, Kolb won't have any problem completing plenty of deep balls to Fitz.'wadegarrett said:Was thinking this as well until I read this from Peter King this morning...Fitzgertald back up to top 3 from 5-7 range. All the lockout workouts with Kolb, sounds like they're attached to the hip in camp and in the locker (reminicent of Moss/Brady first year).Now...• ARIZONA: Larry Fitzgerald Warning Dept.: Kevin Kolb, playing for Philadelphia last year, completed 30.8 percent of his throws that traveled at least 20 yards downfield ... compared to 40.4 percent for the run-out-of-town Derek Anderson.![]()
I like what Harris did, and I love his highlight reel, but what really turned me off is that the studs known as Dez and Austin are under contract for several more years. Harris wouldn't get his shot until he leaves via FA and that may not be as good of a situation as a loaded Dallas offense.Another team to avoid at all costs, San Fransisco. Same deal. 1st O line got walked all over. Give Harbaugh another year or two, develop a QB and find another couple lineman and you may have something, but they are a long ways off.'Stinkin Ref said:Harris: let's temper for a second, the 70 yarder was blown coverage, I can see why some are excited but a lot of mouths to feed and Ogletree may give him a run when all is said and done...CHI: adding them to the list of teams that I may just avoid all together unless it is crazy value....that Oline is terrible and it all starts there on offense....I'd be worried...
Good point on Barry, as for Herman Moore - I grew up in Detroit watching that Lions team and as an adult it's never occured to me once that Moore was in the same class as Fitzgerald. Either way though, I don't think Kolb will actually hit those numbers necessarily, I just wanted to point out that even if the Scott Mitchell comparison turns out to be true over the longhaul, that doesn't mean he won't have value in a redraft.This argument looks plausible but be careful here, my timing may be a year off but I believe there was a dude named Barry lined up behind Mitchell in his first full season. Herman Moore and Larry Fitz are probably in the same talent level so at least Fitz will help Kolb look better like Moore did for Mitchell.'Frankbot said:Scott Mitchell threw for 4,000+ YDS and 30+ TDs in his first full season in Detroit. If Kolb stays healthy and matches that, I'll take it.'Joe Bryant said:Right. The numbers for Kolb apply. It's a small sample so you have to be careful but you can't blame them on his receivers.I can't pin it down exactly but I have an uneasy feeling about Kolb. I keep getting a vague and blurry picture of Scott Mitchell. But that's totally a gut feel and I can't quantify it. So take it for what it's worth.J
Awesome post.Good observation about Miami...... I laughed'Stinkin Ref said:nice thread....and tough to understand why all the hate from guys who dismiss preseason games, especially week 1, yet still come into the thread and post nothing that helps at all....if you know it's not your cup of tea, just stay out....I like to see some guys pass the eye ball test...Julio: real dealHarris: let's temper for a second, the 70 yarder was blown coverage, I can see why some are excited but a lot of mouths to feed and Ogletree may give him a run when all is said and done...KC: it is going to be a long year, just got a bad feeling people are going to be disappointed in the production they get from a first rounder (Charles) or a possible second rounder (Bowe)....schedule is brutal...and that team just isn't that good....Cassel worries me...NE: how many offers will they be getting for Mallett...?....some teams kicking themselves right now (hello MIA) for letting NE get this guy....CHI: adding them to the list of teams that I may just avoid all together unless it is crazy value....that Oline is terrible and it all starts there on offense....I'd be worried...
Really? For what they gave up and paid? He started 9 games in '94 and had a 62.0 passer rating in those games. '95 was his peak and it was downhill from there. I'm not sure many Cardinal fans would take a Scott Mitchell career out of Kolb.J'Frankbot said:Scott Mitchell threw for 4,000+ YDS and 30+ TDs in his first full season in Detroit. If Kolb stays healthy and matches that, I'll take it.'Joe Bryant said:Right. The numbers for Kolb apply. It's a small sample so you have to be careful but you can't blame them on his receivers.I can't pin it down exactly but I have an uneasy feeling about Kolb. I keep getting a vague and blurry picture of Scott Mitchell. But that's totally a gut feel and I can't quantify it. So take it for what it's worth.J'sho nuff said:Not as if Maclin and Jackson are scrubs though.'Grahamburn said:Kolb didn't have Fitzgerald last season. If Larry keeps making grabs like he did the other night, and he will, Kolb won't have any problem completing plenty of deep balls to Fitz.'wadegarrett said:Was thinking this as well until I read this from Peter King this morning...Fitzgertald back up to top 3 from 5-7 range. All the lockout workouts with Kolb, sounds like they're attached to the hip in camp and in the locker (reminicent of Moss/Brady first year).Now...• ARIZONA: Larry Fitzgerald Warning Dept.: Kevin Kolb, playing for Philadelphia last year, completed 30.8 percent of his throws that traveled at least 20 yards downfield ... compared to 40.4 percent for the run-out-of-town Derek Anderson.![]()
I think he was referring to having those numbers this year / not about his careerReally? For what they gave up and paid? He started 9 games in '94 and had a 62.0 passer rating in those games. '95 was his peak and it was downhill from there. I'm not sure many Cardinal fans would take a Scott Mitchell career out of Kolb.J'Frankbot said:Scott Mitchell threw for 4,000+ YDS and 30+ TDs in his first full season in Detroit. If Kolb stays healthy and matches that, I'll take it.'Joe Bryant said:Right. The numbers for Kolb apply. It's a small sample so you have to be careful but you can't blame them on his receivers.I can't pin it down exactly but I have an uneasy feeling about Kolb. I keep getting a vague and blurry picture of Scott Mitchell. But that's totally a gut feel and I can't quantify it. So take it for what it's worth.J'sho nuff said:Not as if Maclin and Jackson are scrubs though.'Grahamburn said:Kolb didn't have Fitzgerald last season. If Larry keeps making grabs like he did the other night, and he will, Kolb won't have any problem completing plenty of deep balls to Fitz.'wadegarrett said:Was thinking this as well until I read this from Peter King this morning...Fitzgertald back up to top 3 from 5-7 range. All the lockout workouts with Kolb, sounds like they're attached to the hip in camp and in the locker (reminicent of Moss/Brady first year).Now...• ARIZONA: Larry Fitzgerald Warning Dept.: Kevin Kolb, playing for Philadelphia last year, completed 30.8 percent of his throws that traveled at least 20 yards downfield ... compared to 40.4 percent for the run-out-of-town Derek Anderson.![]()
Yeah, I guess I can see that. Although I hope Kolb lasts more than 9 games like Mitchell did. 1995 was nice and I'm sure people would take that. But I'm looking at it more from a career thing.JI think he was referring to having those numbers this year / not about his careerReally? For what they gave up and paid? He started 9 games in '94 and had a 62.0 passer rating in those games. '95 was his peak and it was downhill from there. I'm not sure many Cardinal fans would take a Scott Mitchell career out of Kolb.J'Frankbot said:Scott Mitchell threw for 4,000+ YDS and 30+ TDs in his first full season in Detroit. If Kolb stays healthy and matches that, I'll take it.'Joe Bryant said:Right. The numbers for Kolb apply. It's a small sample so you have to be careful but you can't blame them on his receivers.I can't pin it down exactly but I have an uneasy feeling about Kolb. I keep getting a vague and blurry picture of Scott Mitchell. But that's totally a gut feel and I can't quantify it. So take it for what it's worth.J'sho nuff said:Not as if Maclin and Jackson are scrubs though.'Grahamburn said:Kolb didn't have Fitzgerald last season. If Larry keeps making grabs like he did the other night, and he will, Kolb won't have any problem completing plenty of deep balls to Fitz.'wadegarrett said:Was thinking this as well until I read this from Peter King this morning...Fitzgertald back up to top 3 from 5-7 range. All the lockout workouts with Kolb, sounds like they're attached to the hip in camp and in the locker (reminicent of Moss/Brady first year).Now...• ARIZONA: Larry Fitzgerald Warning Dept.: Kevin Kolb, playing for Philadelphia last year, completed 30.8 percent of his throws that traveled at least 20 yards downfield ... compared to 40.4 percent for the run-out-of-town Derek Anderson.![]()
See Michael Crabtree and Dez Bryant for recent examples.I wouldn't bank on rookie wide receivers with zero OTAs under and an abbreviated training camp.I'm just saying.
Crabtree 48 catches, 625 yards, 2 TDBryant - 45 catches, 561 yards, 6 TD (pro rated for 16 games to 60 catches, 748 yards, 8 TD).Yippee?See Michael Crabtree and Dez Bryant for recent examples.I wouldn't bank on rookie wide receivers with zero OTAs under and an abbreviated training camp.I'm just saying.
Definitely a guy who has some upside. I could see Forte just being the third down guy.Bumped up Marion barber and bumped down forte
In favor of Barber on first and second down? Seriously?'jon_mx said:Definitely a guy who has some upside. I could see Forte just being the third down guy.'LHUCKS said:Bumped up Marion barber and bumped down forte
Ya, If Corky Thatcher is drafting for the rest of the teams in your league.This. I'm drafting #3. I may be able to snag him in the 3rd if Julio keeps it up.My hope is that the Julio Hype will drop White's ADP some.
In favor of Barber on first and second down? Seriously?'jon_mx said:Just projections, not depth chartDefinitely a guy who has some upside. I could see Forte just being the third down guy.'LHUCKS said:Bumped up Marion barber and bumped down forte