What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Port Strikes (1 Viewer)

So the way to avoid their jobs being automated is by demanding a 150% pay raise?

Can't say that I see the logic there.
Saw an interview with one of the "leaders" of this union where they referenced how longshoremen were considered essential during COVID. As a result, many of them got sick and lost their lives. So now they deserve to be paid more for their essential work.

Like, dude, you just made yet another case for automation.
 
I wonder how long before robots replace people that are unionized? The jobs are mostly repetitive. Not always, but many are. And often can be done more accurately by machines. Whether it is a port crane operator, a plane door assembler, or a stewardess serving drinks ... all easily doable by robots. Heck, many white color jobs are too.
Obviously robots are going to replace longshoremen. That has nothing to do with unionization -- it's just that ports are a really good example of enterprises that are good candidates for automation.

(Today is also not a good time to start a new career as a long-haul trucker).
You could not be more wrong, a growing issue for us (uscg) is that the chips in these cranes are made in China. We've already had several hacked that have caused issues in west coast ports and we just had another shaddy thing go down in Florida were a crew (Chinese nationalists) came out to service the crane and entered with a black box but did not leave with it. Unless the goods are made in the US then we are quickly learning that we are not susceptible than more than just ransomware.
It’s gotten to the point for department of energy that all of our chips used in our super computers/R&D are created within the US. We are using governmental overrides to step in front of anybody in line so that R&D can continue uninterrupted. Furthermore, there is an unstated rule that we will no longer hire Chinese nationals.

It’s kind of eye-opening…
i’ll find some public links later today, I happen to vanpool with one of our cyber protection guys who has deployed on these missions. they are not classified and open source or i wouldn’t be talking about it here. 2 months ago it was an alaskan bound ship, seattle and la. the crane was jacksonville
 
We all saw what happened with the fast food workers demanding $20 an hour. The restaurant industry responded with kiosks and less employees.
This isn't what happened, though. In California at least, fast food workers didn't "demand" $20/hour, it was legislation implemented by the government. More important, though, post-legislation there are now more fast food workers than ever in California.
 
We all saw what happened with the fast food workers demanding $20 an hour. The restaurant industry responded with kiosks and less employees.
This isn't what happened, though. In California at least, fast food workers didn't "demand" $20/hour, it was legislation implemented by the government. More important, though, post-legislation there are now more fast food workers than ever in California.
And 15 dollar "value" meals.

California isn't exactly a model of success these days.
 
We all saw what happened with the fast food workers demanding $20 an hour. The restaurant industry responded with kiosks and less employees.
This isn't what happened, though. In California at least, fast food workers didn't "demand" $20/hour, it was legislation implemented by the government. More important, though, post-legislation there are now more fast food workers than ever in California.
Yes. Fast food workers in CA did "demand" higher wages. The legislation was implemented by the gov't in direct response to union pressure.

Nearly 1 million California workers are poised to win major salary increases after labor unions flexed their collective muscle in the state’s Democratic-led Legislature on Monday following a summer of high-profile strikes in the entertainment and hospitality industries.

Most of the state’s 500,000 fast food workers would be paid at least $20 per hour next year under a new bill aimed at ending a standoff between the industry and labor unions over wages and working conditions.

CA fast food workers poised to win large pay increases
 
I just wonder how long before it's quashed. The rail one was quashed mercilessly and it wasn't even 30 days before things we can't speak about.
Agreed. I give it a week.
Maybe it gets let go until its natural conclusion. Looks like it right now.

It also highlights that the rail workers should have waited until now. Miscalculation to do it before politics made it hard to quash.
 
We all saw what happened with the fast food workers demanding $20 an hour. The restaurant industry responded with kiosks and less employees.
This isn't what happened, though. In California at least, fast food workers didn't "demand" $20/hour, it was legislation implemented by the government. More important, though, post-legislation there are now more fast food workers than ever in California.
Yea I didn’t think his post was true but also didn’t want to bother researching it.
 
So the way to avoid their jobs being automated is by demanding a 150% pay raise?

Can't say that I see the logic there.
Saw an interview with one of the "leaders" of this union where they referenced how longshoremen were considered essential during COVID. As a result, many of them got sick and lost their lives. So now they deserve to be paid more for their essential work.

Like, dude, you just made yet another case for automation.
I was considered an essential worker during COVID also. I worked for Frito Lay. Grocery stores were some of the most crowded places at that time. I said the heck with it and retired. Nobody there is getting paid more, then or now.
 
I just wonder how long before it's quashed. The rail one was quashed mercilessly and it wasn't even 30 days before things we can't speak about.
Agreed. I give it a week.
Maybe it gets let go until its natural conclusion. Looks like it right now.

It also highlights that the rail workers should have waited until now. Miscalculation to do it before politics made it hard to quash.
It's going to be a game of chicken for the next month...how soon the disruptions affect consumers (e.g. perishables) vs. the pressures of certain other unmentionable factors.
 
We all saw what happened with the fast food workers demanding $20 an hour. The restaurant industry responded with kiosks and less employees.
This isn't what happened, though. In California at least, fast food workers didn't "demand" $20/hour, it was legislation implemented by the government. More important, though, post-legislation there are now more fast food workers than ever in California.
And 15 dollar "value" meals.

California isn't exactly a model of success these days.
This in particular seems like a tremendous success. More jobs, higher-paying jobs, businesses responding to consumer demand.
 
Yes. Fast food workers in CA did "demand" higher wages. The legislation was implemented by the gov't in direct response to union pressure.

Nearly 1 million California workers are poised to win major salary increases after labor unions flexed their collective muscle in the state’s Democratic-led Legislature on Monday following a summer of high-profile strikes in the entertainment and hospitality industries.

Most of the state’s 500,000 fast food workers would be paid at least $20 per hour next year under a new bill aimed at ending a standoff between the industry and labor unions over wages and working conditions.

CA fast food workers poised to win large pay increases
Fair enough. I was more responding to "demand" as in "went on strike".
 
We all saw what happened with the fast food workers demanding $20 an hour. The restaurant industry responded with kiosks and less employees.
This isn't what happened, though. In California at least, fast food workers didn't "demand" $20/hour, it was legislation implemented by the government. More important, though, post-legislation there are now more fast food workers than ever in California.
Yeah, instead of eliminating jobs in the fast food industry, it seems that automation has shifted what workers are doing. With some good results.
https://www.cnn.com/2024/09/20/business/self-service-kiosks-mcdonalds-shake-shack/index.html

How automation affects other industries remains to be seen, but assuming that automation automatically leads to job losses doesn't appear to be correct so far.
 
I just wonder how long before it's quashed. The rail one was quashed mercilessly and it wasn't even 30 days before things we can't speak about.
Agreed. I give it a week.
Maybe it gets let go until its natural conclusion. Looks like it right now.

It also highlights that the rail workers should have waited until now. Miscalculation to do it before politics made it hard to quash.
It's going to be a game of chicken for the next month...how soon the disruptions affect consumers (e.g. perishables) vs. the pressures of certain other unmentionable factors.
Apparently all the retailers were aware of this pending strike and many of them got ahead of the curve. The hope is they planned for the shutdown and the supply chain won't sustain a massive hit unless this drags on for an extended period.
 
We all saw what happened with the fast food workers demanding $20 an hour. The restaurant industry responded with kiosks and less employees.
This isn't what happened, though. In California at least, fast food workers didn't "demand" $20/hour, it was legislation implemented by the government. More important, though, post-legislation there are now more fast food workers than ever in California.
And 15 dollar "value" meals.

California isn't exactly a model of success these days.
This in particular seems like a tremendous success. More jobs, higher-paying jobs, businesses responding to consumer demand.
All depends on your perspective. As a fast food worker, big success. As a consumer, not so much. Even as a consumer, depends on your circumstances. I'm personally doing ok so I don't mind paying more so others can have a better life.
 
I wonder how long before robots replace people that are unionized? The jobs are mostly repetitive. Not always, but many are. And often can be done more accurately by machines. Whether it is a port crane operator, a plane door assembler, or a stewardess serving drinks ... all easily doable by robots. Heck, many white color jobs are too.
Obviously robots are going to replace longshoremen. That has nothing to do with unionization -- it's just that ports are a really good example of enterprises that are good candidates for automation.

(Today is also not a good time to start a new career as a long-haul trucker).
You could not be more wrong, a growing issue for us (uscg) is that the chips in these cranes are made in China. We've already had several hacked that have caused issues in west coast ports and we just had another shaddy thing go down in Florida were a crew (Chinese nationalists) came out to service the crane and entered with a black box but did not leave with it. Unless the goods are made in the US then we are quickly learning that we are not susceptible than more than just ransomware.
got a link for that?
 
Went to Costco yesterday afternoon for an already-planned trip. Seemed to be business as usual. Only saw a few paper product hoarders.
 
We all saw what happened with the fast food workers demanding $20 an hour. The restaurant industry responded with kiosks and less employees.
This isn't what happened, though. In California at least, fast food workers didn't "demand" $20/hour, it was legislation implemented by the government. More important, though, post-legislation there are now more fast food workers than ever in California.
And 15 dollar "value" meals.

California isn't exactly a model of success these days.
This in particular seems like a tremendous success. More jobs, higher-paying jobs, businesses responding to consumer demand.
All depends on your perspective. As a fast food worker, big success. As a consumer, not so much. Even as a consumer, depends on your circumstances. I'm personally doing ok so I don't mind paying more so others can have a better life.
I'd have to disagree with this, too. At least so far, consumers as a whole have responded by demanding more. Unless one is arguing that fast food is a Giffen good, it seems like consumers, as a group, have voiced their approval.
 
Went to Costco yesterday afternoon for an already-planned trip. Seemed to be business as usual. Only saw a few paper product hoarders.
The typical costco shopper already has 80 rolls in the basement or is that just me?
My mom was preparing for the pandemic since 1960 and by howdy did we all get load of told ya so'oes. And yes, bring on the strike, mom still has enough tp to wipe an army.
 
I just wonder how long before it's quashed. The rail one was quashed mercilessly and it wasn't even 30 days before things we can't speak about.
Agreed. I give it a week.
Maybe it gets let go until its natural conclusion. Looks like it right now.

It also highlights that the rail workers should have waited until now. Miscalculation to do it before politics made it hard to quash.
It's going to be a game of chicken for the next month...how soon the disruptions affect consumers (e.g. perishables) vs. the pressures of certain other unmentionable factors.
Apparently all the retailers were aware of this pending strike and many of them got ahead of the curve. The hope is they planned for the shutdown and the supply chain won't sustain a massive hit unless this drags on for an extended period.
Agreed that many retailers bolstered their inventory months in advance. However, events such as Hurricane Helene will compound the difficulties quicker than most people think.

In addition, many pharmaceuticals ingredients and medical supplies (e.g. IV fluids) are JIT inventory. Many of these will be air freighted, but then costs increase. Ditto for agriculture, etc.

Not predicting Armageddon overnight, but this has the potential to snowball very quickly IMO
 
Went to Costco yesterday afternoon for an already-planned trip. Seemed to be business as usual. Only saw a few paper product hoarders.
I went an hour ago. No TP in sight and I heard an employee tell a customer there was a run on it and to try again first thing in the morning. It was a zoo in there, it was lunch time but still, crazy busy.
 
Went to Costco yesterday afternoon for an already-planned trip. Seemed to be business as usual. Only saw a few paper product hoarders.
I went an hour ago. No TP in sight and I heard an employee tell a customer there was a run on it and to try again first thing in the morning. It was a zoo in there, it was lunch time but still, crazy busy.
Did they have a "one 80 pack per customer" sign up yet?
 
Went to Costco yesterday afternoon for an already-planned trip. Seemed to be business as usual. Only saw a few paper product hoarders.
I went an hour ago. No TP in sight and I heard an employee tell a customer there was a run on it and to try again first thing in the morning. It was a zoo in there, it was lunch time but still, crazy busy.
Did they have a "one 80 pack per customer" sign up yet?
:ROFLMAO: Didn't see one.

Wife went to a different Costco (coincidence) and said they also had none. And our daughter lives in another state and a friend told her there was a "crier" outside of Sam's yelling "no toilet paper!"

Bidet for the win!
 
Went to Costco yesterday afternoon for an already-planned trip. Seemed to be business as usual. Only saw a few paper product hoarders.
I went an hour ago. No TP in sight and I heard an employee tell a customer there was a run on it and to try again first thing in the morning. It was a zoo in there, it was lunch time but still, crazy busy.
Did they have a "one 80 pack per customer" sign up yet?
:ROFLMAO: Didn't see one.

Wife went to a different Costco (coincidence) and said they also had none. And our daughter lives in another state and a friend told her there was a "crier" outside of Sam's yelling "no toilet paper!"

Bidet for the win!
They still had bidets?
 
This Harold Daggett is a pretty interesting guy

Charged with racketeering in 2005, Mr Daggett, took the witness stand and portrayed himself as a mob target, despite evidence against him from a turncoat Mafia enforcer saying he was under the mob’s control, the New York Times reported.

“During that trial, one of Mr Daggett’s co-defendants, a renowned mobster named Lawrence Ricci, disappeared. His decomposing body was found in the trunk of a car outside a New Jersey diner several weeks later, with the killing still unsolved. “
There are aspects of this particular story that very much feel like an episode of The Wire. I don't want to go too far down this road for obvious reasons, but it's really kind of uncanny how this guy is a walking stereotype.
We used to make **** in this country, build ****
Too many smart and energetic people only want to push bits around and not actually make physical things. I get it. If you're young and smart, you can make more money and have a better life if you can make AI manipulate images and video instead of designing cranes that aren't reliant on Chinese engineering.
 
Went to Costco yesterday afternoon for an already-planned trip. Seemed to be business as usual. Only saw a few paper product hoarders.
I went an hour ago. No TP in sight and I heard an employee tell a customer there was a run on it and to try again first thing in the morning. It was a zoo in there, it was lunch time but still, crazy busy.
Did they have a "one 80 pack per customer" sign up yet?
:ROFLMAO: Didn't see one.

Wife went to a different Costco (coincidence) and said they also had none. And our daughter lives in another state and a friend told her there was a "crier" outside of Sam's yelling "no toilet paper!"

Bidet for the win!
They still had bidets?
Not that I know of. Amazon!
 
Too many smart and energetic people only want to push bits around and not actually make physical things. I get it. If you're young and smart, you can make more money and have a better life if you can make AI manipulate images and video instead of designing cranes that aren't reliant on Chinese engineering.
I strongly agree. In the interest of criticizing my own "tribe" a bit, I think you can toss in there that we steer an awful lot of intellectual firepower into figuring out how to accurately price esoteric financial derivatives, and maybe those skills could be put to better use elsewhere.
 
Too many smart and energetic people only want to push bits around and not actually make physical things. I get it. If you're young and smart, you can make more money and have a better life if you can make AI manipulate images and video instead of designing cranes that aren't reliant on Chinese engineering.
I strongly agree. In the interest of criticizing my own "tribe" a bit, I think you can toss in there that we steer an awful lot of intellectual firepower into figuring out how to accurately price esoteric financial derivatives, and maybe those skills could be put to better use elsewhere.
Accurate pricing of financial derivatives such as asset-backed securities is enabling solar developers to both free up and lower their cost of capital, thereby spurring accelerated deployment of solar to decarbonize the U.S. electric grid.

Seems like a pretty sensible use of intellectual firepower to me.
 
Too many smart and energetic people only want to push bits around and not actually make physical things. I get it. If you're young and smart, you can make more money and have a better life if you can make AI manipulate images and video instead of designing cranes that aren't reliant on Chinese engineering.
I strongly agree. In the interest of criticizing my own "tribe" a bit, I think you can toss in there that we steer an awful lot of intellectual firepower into figuring out how to accurately price esoteric financial derivatives, and maybe those skills could be put to better use elsewhere.
Accurate pricing of financial derivatives such as asset-backed securities is enabling solar developers to both free up and lower their cost of capital, thereby spurring accelerated deployment of solar to decarbonize the U.S. electric grid.

Seems like a pretty sensible use of intellectual firepower to me.
I'm not saying that finance is bad. I'm just saying that the US is probably over-invested in that area.
 
Too many smart and energetic people only want to push bits around and not actually make physical things. I get it. If you're young and smart, you can make more money and have a better life if you can make AI manipulate images and video instead of designing cranes that aren't reliant on Chinese engineering.
I strongly agree. In the interest of criticizing my own "tribe" a bit, I think you can toss in there that we steer an awful lot of intellectual firepower into figuring out how to accurately price esoteric financial derivatives, and maybe those skills could be put to better use elsewhere.
Accurate pricing of financial derivatives such as asset-backed securities is enabling solar developers to both free up and lower their cost of capital, thereby spurring accelerated deployment of solar to decarbonize the U.S. electric grid.

Seems like a pretty sensible use of intellectual firepower to me.
I'm not saying that finance is bad. I'm just saying that the US is probably over-invested in that area.
I'm more a fan of people choosing their own career path
 
Too many smart and energetic people only want to push bits around and not actually make physical things. I get it. If you're young and smart, you can make more money and have a better life if you can make AI manipulate images and video instead of designing cranes that aren't reliant on Chinese engineering.
I strongly agree. In the interest of criticizing my own "tribe" a bit, I think you can toss in there that we steer an awful lot of intellectual firepower into figuring out how to accurately price esoteric financial derivatives, and maybe those skills could be put to better use elsewhere.
Accurate pricing of financial derivatives such as asset-backed securities is enabling solar developers to both free up and lower their cost of capital, thereby spurring accelerated deployment of solar to decarbonize the U.S. electric grid.

Seems like a pretty sensible use of intellectual firepower to me.
I'm not saying that finance is bad. I'm just saying that the US is probably over-invested in that area.
You should look at Britain. They have hollowed out their industrial base and now so much of their tax revenue comes from finance it's crazy.
 
Too many smart and energetic people only want to push bits around and not actually make physical things. I get it. If you're young and smart, you can make more money and have a better life if you can make AI manipulate images and video instead of designing cranes that aren't reliant on Chinese engineering.
I strongly agree. In the interest of criticizing my own "tribe" a bit, I think you can toss in there that we steer an awful lot of intellectual firepower into figuring out how to accurately price esoteric financial derivatives, and maybe those skills could be put to better use elsewhere.
Accurate pricing of financial derivatives such as asset-backed securities is enabling solar developers to both free up and lower their cost of capital, thereby spurring accelerated deployment of solar to decarbonize the U.S. electric grid.

Seems like a pretty sensible use of intellectual firepower to me.
I'm not saying that finance is bad. I'm just saying that the US is probably over-invested in that area.
I'm more a fan of people choosing their own career path
Just making a general observation, not calling for the forcible reorganization of the labor force. I'm an economist. I have nothing against finance. It would maybe just be nice if a few people on the margin had chosen a different path, and I'm increasingly thinking about how we might incentivize that sort of thing without being heavy-handed or even nudge-y about it.
 
Too many smart and energetic people only want to push bits around and not actually make physical things. I get it. If you're young and smart, you can make more money and have a better life if you can make AI manipulate images and video instead of designing cranes that aren't reliant on Chinese engineering.
I strongly agree. In the interest of criticizing my own "tribe" a bit, I think you can toss in there that we steer an awful lot of intellectual firepower into figuring out how to accurately price esoteric financial derivatives, and maybe those skills could be put to better use elsewhere.
Accurate pricing of financial derivatives such as asset-backed securities is enabling solar developers to both free up and lower their cost of capital, thereby spurring accelerated deployment of solar to decarbonize the U.S. electric grid.

Seems like a pretty sensible use of intellectual firepower to me.
I'm not saying that finance is bad. I'm just saying that the US is probably over-invested in that area.
I'm more a fan of people choosing their own career path
Just making a general observation, not calling for the forcible reorganization of the labor force. I'm an economist. I have nothing against finance. It would maybe just be nice if a few people on the margin had chosen a different path, and I'm increasingly thinking about how we might incentivize that sort of thing without being heavy-handed or even nudge-y about it.
The system is perverse. All the money flows to venture capital instead of infrastructure and physical goods. There's so much money in flipping bits and coming up with the new Viagra that the brains and smart labor are going there.
 
Those union port workers make some good money.
Its ok. Its max $39/hr with 1.5x for OT. So yeah some make 200k, but they're working like 100 hrs per week. Certainly is an excellent job for someone with no education.
I've been told they game the overtime system, so they aren't actually working nearly the hours logged.
I think most of us white collar folks can relate
Yeah, most people don’t work 100% of the time. But these guys do stuff like have their buddies cover while they sleep for several hours, during “overtime”. And the guys with seniority poach many of the extra hours.

Overtime doesn’t exist in my white collar job, and my hours aren’t really tracked, so I cannot relate.
 
Those union port workers make some good money.
Its ok. Its max $39/hr with 1.5x for OT. So yeah some make 200k, but they're working like 100 hrs per week. Certainly is an excellent job for someone with no education.
I've been told they game the overtime system, so they aren't actually working nearly the hours logged.
I think most of us white collar folks can relate
Yeah, most people don’t work 100% of the time. But these guys do stuff like have their buddies cover while they sleep for several hours, during “overtime”. And the guys with seniority poach many of the extra hours.

Overtime doesn’t exist in my white collar job, and my hours aren’t really tracked, so I cannot relate.
Oh i'm sure. I mean that's what a lot of us would do if we could get away with it. Its well documented on this board how little people work at their white collar jobs. But regardless, its not like they're making $200k for working a 40 hour week which is how a lot of these posts above read to me. Sleeping or not, they have to be at the job for 100 hours per week. Certainly not a job I'd want.
 
Last edited:
Those union port workers make some good money.
Its ok. Its max $39/hr with 1.5x for OT. So yeah some make 200k, but they're working like 100 hrs per week. Certainly is an excellent job for someone with no education.
I've been told they game the overtime system, so they aren't actually working nearly the hours logged.
I think most of us white collar folks can relate
Yeah, most people don’t work 100% of the time. But these guys do stuff like have their buddies cover while they sleep for several hours, during “overtime”. And the guys with seniority poach many of the extra hours.

Overtime doesn’t exist in my white collar job, and my hours aren’t really tracked, so I cannot relate.
Oh i'm sure. I mean that's what a lot of us would do if we could get away with it. Its well documented on this board how little people work at their white collar jobs. But regardless, its not like they're making $200k for working a 40 hour week which is how a lot of these posts above read to me. Sleeping or not, they have to be at the job for 100 hours per week. Certainly not a job I'd want.

Panic toilet paper buying has begun.
I took an early retirement last winter after 50-60 weeks since the pandemic being paid a 40 hour salary but had hourly employees kill it with OT . One went over 200k working every bit of OT 6-7 days a week. Half my office went over 100k delivering mail but it’ forced OT etc. The money is great but there is a definite work/home imbalance. Some people see the $$ total and get jealous but it’s blood money with all the time spent at work
 
Saw something from the NY Post article where they were offered a 50% raise over the life of their 6 year contract but they are insisting on at least 61% or something.

Good grief. Let the robots take over please.
 
So the way to avoid their jobs being automated is by demanding a 150% pay raise?

Can't say that I see the logic there.
Saw an interview with one of the "leaders" of this union where they referenced how longshoremen were considered essential during COVID. As a result, many of them got sick and lost their lives. So now they deserve to be paid more for their essential work.

Like, dude, you just made yet another case for automation.
I was considered an essential worker during COVID also. I worked for Frito Lay. Grocery stores were some of the most crowded places at that time. I said the heck with it and retired. Nobody there is getting paid more, then or now.
I’m very familiar with how FL pays the drivers. They are making less now because of the price and the economy. That market has really changed in the Chicago area.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top