Portis or Thomas Jones (1 Viewer)

[Heinz 57]

Forget the past lets talk 2007 please.

Both have some injury problems, RBBC looming ( ) what do you think.

 

[BroadwayG]

I think Portis, but I'm sure you'll find some detailed discussion in their player profile pages and their spotlight threads.

 

[Blackstar]

The quick and easy answer is T.Jones. L.Betts is going to eat up a ton more carries from C.Portis than L.Washington will. I like Leon a lot but I have a feeling they'll use him primarily as a 3rd down back/punt returner.

But, Clinton has more of an upside, even if he hasn't shown it since Denver.

 

[Heinz 57]

I think Portis, but I'm sure you'll find some detailed discussion in their player profile pages and their spotlight threads.

No ####, but I'm asking a straight forward question here.

 

[BroadwayG]

I think Portis, but I'm sure you'll find some detailed discussion in their player profile pages and their spotlight threads.

No ####, but I'm asking a straight forward question here.

May as well make it a poll, then, Ace.

 

[Heinz 57]

The quick and easy answer is T.Jones. L.Betts is going to eat up a ton more carries from C.Portis than L.Washington will. I like Leon a lot but I have a feeling they'll use him primarily as a 3rd down back/punt returner. But, Clinton has more of an upside, even if he hasn't shown it since Denver.

Agreed. Someone is offering me Jones for Portis. I think its a steal, somebody pinch me?

 

[Heinz 57]

I think Portis, but I'm sure you'll find some detailed discussion in their player profile pages and their spotlight threads.

No ####, but I'm asking a straight forward question here.

May as well make it a poll, then, Ace.

Im lookin for some reasons, doosh.

 

[BroadwayG]

The quick and easy answer is T.Jones. L.Betts is going to eat up a ton more carries from C.Portis than L.Washington will. I like Leon a lot but I have a feeling they'll use him primarily as a 3rd down back/punt returner. But, Clinton has more of an upside, even if he hasn't shown it since Denver.

Agreed. Someone is offering me Jones for Portis. I think its a steal, somebody pinch me?

Mods, please move to the ACF, TIA.

 

[Chaka]

The quick and easy answer is T.Jones. L.Betts is going to eat up a ton more carries from C.Portis than L.Washington will. I like Leon a lot but I have a feeling they'll use him primarily as a 3rd down back/punt returner. But, Clinton has more of an upside, even if he hasn't shown it since Denver.

Agreed. Someone is offering me Jones for Portis. I think its a steal, somebody pinch me?

Oh. Well in that case...dude, wrong forum.

 

[Heinz 57]

The quick and easy answer is T.Jones. L.Betts is going to eat up a ton more carries from C.Portis than L.Washington will. I like Leon a lot but I have a feeling they'll use him primarily as a 3rd down back/punt returner. But, Clinton has more of an upside, even if he hasn't shown it since Denver.

Agreed. Someone is offering me Jones for Portis. I think its a steal, somebody pinch me?

Oh. Well in that case...dude, wrong forum.

This applies to their seasons as well as fantasy seasons. I think its a pretty well rounded question dont you.

 

[BroadwayG]

I think Portis, but I'm sure you'll find some detailed discussion in their player profile pages and their spotlight threads.

No ####, but I'm asking a straight forward question here.

May as well make it a poll, then, Ace.

Im lookin for some reasons, doosh.

Please see their player profile pages and their spotlight threads, Gary.

 

[Heinz 57]

This is a comparison thread.

 

[suchislife]

I think Portis, but I'm sure you'll find some detailed discussion in their player profile pages and their spotlight threads.

No ####, but I'm asking a straight forward question here.

May as well make it a poll, then, Ace.

Im lookin for some reasons, doosh.

Wow, some serious Pool pissing here. Just a little advice - when someone's trying to give you helpful advice, you may want to come off as being grateful and a bit less childish. At least around these boards.

 

[Chaka]

The quick and easy answer is T.Jones. L.Betts is going to eat up a ton more carries from C.Portis than L.Washington will. I like Leon a lot but I have a feeling they'll use him primarily as a 3rd down back/punt returner. But, Clinton has more of an upside, even if he hasn't shown it since Denver.

Agreed. Someone is offering me Jones for Portis. I think its a steal, somebody pinch me?

Oh. Well in that case...dude, wrong forum.

This applies to their seasons as well as fantasy seasons. I think its a pretty well rounded question dont you.

It's a fine question, for the ACF.

 

[Heinz 57]

I think Portis, but I'm sure you'll find some detailed discussion in their player profile pages and their spotlight threads.

No ####, but I'm asking a straight forward question here.

May as well make it a poll, then, Ace.

Im lookin for some reasons, doosh.

Wow, some serious Pool pissing here. Just a little advice - when someone's trying to give you helpful advice, you may want to come off as being grateful and a bit less childish. At least around these boards.

Whatever man, I believe theres a cow that needs milking somewhere...oh wait thats your wife. Better take care of her, shes moo-ing loudly I can hear it from here.

 

[Heinz 57]

Fine then let the thread be moved. Until then Ill just piss off some men who like to cry.

 

[Chaka]

This is a comparison thread.

He's right. In fact I am making several comparisons between Heinz 57 and various objects in my office.Right now H57 is going toe-to-toe with the desk lamp. Outcome uncertain.

 

[Heinz 57]

This is a comparison thread.

He's right. In fact I am making several comparisons between Heinz 57 and various objects in my office.Right now H57 is going toe-to-toe with the desk lamp. Outcome uncertain.

aww . poor guy. heres a tissue.

 

[suchislife]

I think Portis, but I'm sure you'll find some detailed discussion in their player profile pages and their spotlight threads.

No ####, but I'm asking a straight forward question here.

May as well make it a poll, then, Ace.

Im lookin for some reasons, doosh.

Wow, some serious Pool pissing here. Just a little advice - when someone's trying to give you helpful advice, you may want to come off as being grateful and a bit less childish. At least around these boards.

Whatever man, I believe theres a cow that needs milking somewhere...oh wait thats your wife. Better take care of her, shes moo-ing loudly I can hear it from here.

Well you're certainly doing a fine job of making yourself look like an idiot. Nothing more from me is needed.

 

[NoFBinLA]

This COULD have been a good discussion - instead...

 

[Chaka]

This is a comparison thread.

He's right. In fact I am making several comparisons between Heinz 57 and various objects in my office.Right now H57 is going toe-to-toe with the desk lamp. Outcome uncertain.

aww . poor guy. heres a tissue.

Thanks, but it doesn't look like you stack up to well to used tissue either. But don't worry, I am having my secretary go through the recycling bin right now, I am sure there is an old can of Fresca that you would compare favorably too.I will keep you updated.

 

[Heinz 57]

I know it had potential. Theres just too many guys pissin on my threads. Whatever. I have a few weeks to think about it.

I like Portis and T Jones this year. Portis just scares me.

 

[Michael Fox Fan]

I know it had potential. Theres just too many guys pissin on my threads. Whatever. I have a few weeks to think about it.I like Portis and T Jones this year. Portis just scares me.

Maybe next time you should actually turn it into a generic comparison thread rather than making it so obvious it's an ACF question. FWIW - I just traded away T Jones for Portis in a keeper league. It was an easy decision.

 

[gman8343]

Portis has top 5 potential, Jones doesn't. If you don't trust Portis' health or think he'll cede considerable touches to Betts, then trade him for Jones. Me, I'd take the risk with Portis. Too much upside.

 

[Heinz 57]

Thats what it really boils down to. Is Portis's upside worth risking for a pretty much sure fire RB2 worthy season from T Jones.

 

[BroadwayG]

Thats what it really boils down to. Is Portis's upside worth risking for a pretty much sure fire RB2 worthy season from T Jones.

Yes

 

[Nigel Tufnel]

 

[LBH]

I wouldnt give up Jones for Portis. Portis and his injury issues make me way too nervous.

 

[by_the_sea_wannabe]

Can we get this moved to the FFA instead of closing ?

 

[Nigel Tufnel]

I think Portis, but I'm sure you'll find some detailed discussion in their player profile pages and their spotlight threads.

No ####, but I'm asking a straight forward question here.

May as well make it a poll, then, Ace.

Im lookin for some reasons, doosh.

Wow, some serious Pool pissing here. Just a little advice - when someone's trying to give you helpful advice, you may want to come off as being grateful and a bit less childish. At least around these boards.

Whatever man, I believe theres a cow that needs milking somewhere...oh wait thats your wife. Better take care of her, shes moo-ing loudly I can hear it from here.

 

[switz]

But, Clinton has more of an upside, even if he hasn't shown it since Denver.

two 1500+ yard seasons in WAS isn't upside?

 

[Real Man of Genius]

Somebody thinks this is the Sportsline MB.