Pujols/Jeter vs Reyes/Beltran (1 Viewer)

[numberSE7EN]

Keep in mind...

1. Keeper league where you can keep up to 3 batters a year

2. The third batter you would be keeping is David Wright.

3. Assume the team losing Pujols has another good 1B and a spot in the OF to put Beltran

4. Assume the team losing Beltran does not have a good 1b, and two other good OFers.

-Pujols is obviously a great player and even if he has a 'down' year this year, his future still looks awesome

-Reyes is not as proven, and wont have the power of Pujols, but will steal a crap load.

-Bleltran in my eyes is better than Jeter and younger

-Would having Reyes,Wright,Beltran as your three offensive keepers be a great or stupid idea?

-Thanks-

 

[my man otis]

5x5?

 

[numberSE7EN]

Yeah, standard 5x5 scoring. Should have stated that in the first post...

 

[ooofffaaa]

In a keeper league I would go with Reyes (23) and Beltran (29) and pair them up with Wright (24).

You'll be set for many years to come.

I might even take Reyes & Beltarn over Pujols & Jeter in a redraft league.

I'm a huge so take it for what it's worth.

 

[numberSE7EN]

So, if you were the Pujols/Jeter owner, would you ask for more than Reyes/Beltran?

 

[shadyridr]

So, if you were the Pujols/Jeter owner, would you ask for more than Reyes/Beltran?

No Reyes/Beltran is more than enough for Pujols/Jeter. Its a VERY even trade.

 

[Wrigley]

So, if you were the Pujols/Jeter owner, would you ask for more than Reyes/Beltran?

No Reyes/Beltran is more than enough for Pujols/Jeter. Its a VERY even trade.

Agree.....although going forward I would rather have the younger tandem of Reyes/Beltran