QB Bucket/Tier thread 2006 (1 Viewer)

[Ministry of Pain]

Too high: Eli, Plummer, Favre, and Alex Smith.

Too low: McNabb, Vick, and Phil Rivers.

Why am I not surprised he isn't high enough for you. You and MT need to get a Rivers Bong and keep passing it back and forth. I think I was fair with Rivers...quite fair actually. Top of the QB2 for the most part.

 

[Ministry of Pain]

Some of you guys are forgetting that McNabbs best days were WITHOUT T.O., when he practically had "no one."

Just cause you win a few heads up holding J-4o in your hand, doesn't mean you should always keep playing those 2 cards.

 

[Judge Smails]

Some of you guys are forgetting that McNabbs best days were WITHOUT T.O., when he practically had "no one."

Just cause you win a few heads up holding J-4o in your hand, doesn't mean you should always keep playing those 2 cards.

Comeback player of the year - without question. He moves the chains with short passes to Westbrook and TE's. 40+ attempts = a lot of fantasy points. Best QB value of the draft IMHO. (if he falls as I expect him to)

 

[Ministry of Pain]

Some of you guys are forgetting that McNabbs best days were WITHOUT T.O., when he practically had "no one."

Just cause you win a few heads up holding J-4o in your hand, doesn't mean you should always keep playing those 2 cards.

Comeback player of the year - without question. He moves the chains with short passes to Westbrook and TE's. 40+ attempts = a lot of fantasy points. Best QB value of the draft IMHO. (if he falls as I expect him to)

Was taken in the 5th round in most of my drafts...is that value to you?