Can’t beleive they gave Brock Purdy 50M a year when this guy can get 350 yards out of Mac Jones playing with absolute SCRUB receivers. Should’ve allocated the money elsewhere!
I think when they watched Trey Lance, Jimmy G, Josh Johnson, Brian Hoyer, C.J. Beathard, Nick Mullens, and others they knew to grab and latch on to Purdy.
Jimmy G cost them a Super Bowl (if he makes a throw, they win) and another playoff run died in Los Angeles when everybody had exceeded expectations except for his own albatross self. He was awful during that playoff run also, IIRC, and it probably showed them they needed somebody decent—and decent doesn't come along too often.
It becomes easy to suck it up and say, "Yeah, this is our guy," when you've seen that you can't make soda without drinkable water.
eta* Purdy was like 1st or 2nd in EPA/play in 2023 and has been pretty consistently rated highly, although you can't control for Shanahan. You can't measure it. He's outplaying Mac Jones in some statistical gradations and measures that one might not think matter but do.
I mean, him taking Jimmy G to the Super Bowl kinda makes my point for me doesn’t it?
Not really. I mean you can say if they had gotten lucky they might have won, but the problem with that is that they might have been lucky to be there and that this version of San Francisco isn't as good as that one was. There was an interesting article in ESPN about this exact subject yesterday.
You should read it if you're interested in the real answer regarding why and then how they did it.
The 49ers started to plan Brock Purdy's extension in 2022 -- and their division rivals helped them.
www.espn.com
_________________________________________________________
Owner Jed York:
"When you find somebody that is a top-10 quarterback who can help you continually win football games, then you have to make that decision," 49ers owner Jed York said earlier this year. "And if you do that, it just comes with consequences, and you have to figure it out . . .
For the Niners, the signs that Purdy would be the guy who helps Lynch and Shanahan sleep better revealed themselves early. Shanahan pointed to Purdy's second NFL start, a December 2022 game in Seattle in which Purdy played through a rib injury on short rest to help clinch the NFC West, as the night he knew Purdy had what it takes to succeed.
Purdy further proved that in 2023 when he
overcame a torn ulnar collateral ligament in his right (throwing) elbow to lead the Niners to the Super Bowl, earn his first Pro Bowl nod and finish fourth in league MVP voting as he threw for a franchise-record 4,280 yards.
According to York, the decision to sign Purdy long-term was solidified about halfway through this past season with Lynch circling back to Shanahan once the 6-11 season concluded to ensure that was still the plan.
'You don't burden your head coach until the season's over and you say, 'Hey, now comes the real big decision. Are we going for this? Is Brock our guy?' Lynch said. 'And understanding that with that, we're not going to be able to keep the rest of our guys. That's just the reality in our league.'" - Nick Wagoner, 10/2/2025, espn.com
___________________________________________________________________________-
But it's pretty clear that they do not think that just anybody can come in and do what they need to be done.