JRob is expected to make a TEN YEAR offer to Mariota.
I would say this
rookie year- see the intelligence, awesome demeanor and work ethic, mistakes but impressive.
second year- good, progress, til injury
third year- offense wayyyy bad giving him horrible choices and few of them- way too often he either had to take a sack or force it. Incredible demeanor, many lesser men wouldn't have been supportive of the O and the coach in such a situation. Performance, not so good. Two very bad games which he honorably took on the chin even after the coach blamed the WRs. Outstanding ability to call his own plays. It was often the only time fans liked the offense.
The progress we all want (an increase in yardage and touchdowns) hasn't been there. He has the top level brain, top level poise, top level determination to make a clutch read and pass as evidence of Matthews and Walker being two of the best on 3rd down, top level (maybe best ever) inside the red zone. He has led the NFL either all three years or two of three years in red zone efficiency. (He has not had a top WR. Hunter and DGB didn't pan out, Davis was very much a wet behind the ears rookie. ) He's gonna get the bulk of the hopeful 4k yards 30 TDs on everything else though, between the twenties and maybe even in much of the first three quarters. This is just football. Chill and make some passes. I am very confident he can do it but he hasn't
There is no great year. There are no super stats which might make most people say sign him long term and give him a truckload of $.
Fifth year option guys make a lot of money for one year. I don't know what his is but I'd guess 15-20 mil. The Titans GM, JRob, is looking to sign Lewan and then Mariota to TEN YEAR contracts. The NFL, the NFLPA, and so many will be extremely intrigued by this. It will be pattern setting. Lewan is arguably the top T and Mariota is a nice looking young QB with potential like a handful of others. Ten years is odd and not the usual. The Titans will want them both, so why not? Contracts are not guaranteed, so why not? JRob is widely viewed as an interesting GM. Some love him, some not so much, but he sure has the NFL world's attention. This is going to be interesting