QB Upgrade in a 2QB League (1 Viewer)

[ajgargano]

10 Teams - .5 PPR - Redraft - Starting Roster (2QB-2WR-2RB-1TE-2FLEX)

QB- Jameis Winston, Andy Dalton, Deshaun Watson

WR- Mike Evans, A.J. Green, Doug Baldwin, Adam Thielen, Chris Hogan

RB- Kareem Hunt, Joe Mixon, Mike Gillislee, Tarik Cohen, Mark Ingram, Wendell Smallwood

TE- Jimmy Graham

I'm 3-0 so I'm not really in desperate need to do anything, but I'm slightly worried about my QB situation. I was thinking of offering a Jameis/Gillislee package for Matt Ryan. The Ryan owner lost David Johnson and is very weak at RB (and also a Pats fan) so he could use Gillislee. He also has Tom Brady, so he could probably absorb the QB2 downgrade better than anyone else in the league.

Is going from Jameis to Ryan a big enough upgrade for me to lose Gillislee though? Keep in mind I'd lose another bye week (Jameis already served his bye, Ryan hasn't). Jameis' outlook just seems so volatile depending on who you ask. Some people seem to consider him almost on Ryan's level ROS, some question whether he's even a legit QB1. Thoughts?

 

[loser]

 I wouldn't trade Winston straight up for Ryan.

 

[beerbuff]

Since the bone for him is Gilly why would you pair your top QB with him? I'd throw it out to him with Dalton or Watson and see if he bites on it.

 

[Trelocke]

I don't think there's a huge difference between the two honestly, but I'll take Ryan's playoff schedule of NO, TB, NO over pretty much any QB in the league. Jesus. I think Gillislie is too streaky for you to worry too much about losing. Both Cohen and Smallwood should have higher floors, even in 0.5PPR leagues and you have plenty of WR depth to fill your flex every week. I think you might be paying too much for Ryan but that playoff schedule and the fact that you can afford it make me lean toward yes.