Quetionable Tackles (1 Viewer)

[jhframing]

I lost my game this week by 1 point and the guy I was playing got credited for two solo tackles by DeAngelo Hall on the plays below. Click on link to view plays:

Questionable tackle 1

Questionable tackle 2

And I was not credited with a pass break up on the play below by Stephen Nicholas.

Pass breakup

Does anyone how to get NFL.com to review these plays?

 

[thedudesdude]

I lost my game this week by 1 point and the guy I was playing got credited for two solo tackles by DeAngelo Hall on the plays below. Click on link to view plays:

Questionable tackle 1

Questionable tackle 2

And I was not credited with a pass break up on the play below by Stephen Nicholas.

Pass breakup

Does anyone how to get NFL.com to review these plays?

lol.........give it a rest

 

[chrish]

I see a lot of complaints about defensive scoring, but for once there's something specific. Wrong, but specific.

Hall was given the tackle in both cases because the runner stepped out of bounds to avoid being hit. Maybe in the first case you could make a case for McIntosh getting the tackle, but it's not strong enough to overrule the original scoring. It's certainly reasonable to give Hall the tackle, and in the second example there's no doubt he should get credit.

No pass defense because the ball wasn't catchable. The defender didn't break up the pass, he just stood behind the runner and made a play on a ball that was overthrown. Scored correctly.

 

[clarkstonwolves]

I lost my game this week by 1 point and the guy I was playing got credited for two solo tackles by DeAngelo Hall on the plays below. Click on link to view plays:

Questionable tackle 1

Questionable tackle 2

And I was not credited with a pass break up on the play below by Stephen Nicholas.

Pass breakup

Does anyone how to get NFL.com to review these plays?

lol.........give it a rest

jhframing asked a simple question.. which is the basis behind a "forum".. maybe instead of typing useless respones to questions you have no care for, you should find one that you can be helpful with! And I appoligize for waisting anyone elses' time for having to read this!

 

[TheBottomLine]

I have no idea how anyone would be able to go about fixing it. The way I look at it is, there's always going to be luck involved in anything you do. I'm with you though, that if the play is so obvious, why wouldn't they correct it? Or how would they get it wrong in the first place? I got very upset earlier in the year due to Patrick Willis being robbed of one of the more obvious solos you'll see, but since then I've heard a ton of people complain and I realized that this is definitely a legit problem, and not something that I just happened to be a victim of one time. I would also love to know how, if at all possible, these plays could be corrected. I know it's not gonna happen tomorrow, but even if it was next year.

 

[johnnyboy8102]

My opponent this week had Urlacher and besides his sack and 1 clear solo his 3 other tackles he was credited with were gifts. 2 were misses where he still got credit for slowing the guy up and the 3rd was a player giving himself up and there was a scramble to touch him down.

Last week 3 solos were credited to #53 McClain on Baltimore when it was CLEARLY Ray Lewis on all 3 and McClain wasn't even on the field.

This thinks stink but they happen every week.