Steve- What are some things you like about Hanson compared to Pfitzinger?
1) More emphasis on MP runs. I can't find my copy of Pfitzinger at the moment, but I was pretty sure he only had a MP session scheduled every 3-4 weeks, whereas the Hanson's plan have a MP session every week. I like the specificity of their plan better. 2) I feel like some of the VO2max sessions in the later part of the Pfitzinger plans are kind of pointless as its a little too late to get any real VO2max gains at that point. Most people are probably better served by another MP or threshold session.
3) The lack of emphasis on 20-mile+ long runs. I just don't believe slogging through a 20-24 miler is the best way to train for a marathon. The wear and tear from these runs on most beginning runners are just not worth it. (especially if you have to take more than 1-2 easy days after them to recover). I actually sort of experimented with this last year where I ran a marathon in January, and didn't do a single run longer than 18.5 miles between then and my September marathon. I did cramp up at around 25.5 miles in my September marathon, but I honestly believe it was more due to the fact that my legs were shot from racing 5 weekends in a row leading up to the race than the lack of long runs. That's not to say I don't plan on doing any runs that are 20+ miles in this training cycle, but they're going to happen because I will be doing 15-16 mile MP runs with a 2-3 mile warmup + 2-3 mile cooldown rather than because I set out to cover that specific distance.
4) This one is more personal than anything else. I like how they basically have the same set of workouts each week. (i.e. speed or strength workouts as the first workout of the week depending on the phase you are in, then MP/tempo a couple of days later, then long run on the weekends). This makes it easier for me to get in a rhythm and build momentum week-to-week.
With that said, I don't follow their plan exactly. In addition to doing longer MP sessions than they recommend (which maxes out at 10 miles) and incorporating it into my long run, I had to modify the schedule and dial back the mileage a little bit the last month to try to run a fast half last weekend. For the next 5 weeks though my week will basically look like this:
Tuesday - tempo or speed.
Wednesday - medium long run. (13-16)
Saturday - long run with 10-16 miles of it at goal marathon pace.
(then easy running the other days)
My apologies for the novel, but most times when someone ask me a running-related question I have trouble giving them a short answer.