Rate these RBs (1 Viewer)

[faulkfan]

the top 10 - 15 RBs are pretty clear, but in keeper leagues things get a little muddled when considering the rookies.

Give me some opinions on these guys who are going to go in the middle rounds as far as how you would rate them against themselves. We'll do this one with no PPR.

Gore

D. Williams (Car)

L. White

Maroney

C. Taylor

C. Brown

M. Turner - obviously holds the most value for the LT owner.

Staley

G. Jones

C. Bensen

I'd like to put Bensen at the top of this list, but he hasn't done anything to make anyone believe he can be the man so far this preseason.

Any thoughts?

 

[Armando]

You need to specify how many you keep and so forth. Most of those guys definitely are not middle round picks.

 

[Armando]

King Cedric

Maroney

M.Turner

C.Taylor

D.Williams

C.Brown

F.Gore

L.White

G.Jones

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

..

Staley

 

[traderkirk]

Value for this year.

C. Taylor

Gore

C. Brown

Value for next year and beyond

Maroney

D. Williams (Car)

L. White

C. Bensen -- (traveling along the Salaam/Enis track)

Flyers and handcuffs

G. Jones

M. Turner - obviously holds the most value for the LT owner.

Staley -- no need to draft him at all.

What do you need? production this year or long term value?

 

[tangfoot]

as far as how you would rate them against themselves.

If I'm rating them against themselves, how do we know who wins?

 

[faulkfan]

as far as how you would rate them against themselves.

If I'm rating them against themselves, how do we know who wins?

Good point.Maybe we should rate them against one another.Our league keeps 10 players so it is almost a dynasty league, but not quite. In a redraft these guys would be middle rounders. I got Gore in a redraft for a late middle pick which relly surprised me.I have the #3 overall in our keeper and am personally trying to decide between Gore and Deangleo Williams.