RB Rankings ROS (1 Viewer)

[shadyridr]

We're a quarter of the way thru the season. I thought we should rank the RBs top to bottom for ROS. Ill try and do a top 40. This is obviously open to debate which I hope we can discuss.

STUD RB1s:

1. Foster- gets a ton of touches on a run first team, Tate is an afterthought

2. Rice- the team passes too much to put him #1, still a stud

3. McCoy- TDs will come, stud offense

4. Peterson- appears fully healthy, theyll ride him all year

5. Charles- we're finally seeing what he can do when he gets all the touches

Mid tier RB1s (will have the occasional dud):

6. MJD- terrible team but he'll put up his #s by year end

7. McFadden- injury prone and the OLine has issues but still a stud and catches the ball out of the endzone

8. Forte- he's the Bears whole offense, wont get goal line TDs but never did

9. Murray- OLine issues but hes locked in as a big part of DAL offense

Lower tier RB1s (tough to bench but will have a # of duds):

10. Spiller- I see a 60/40 split with FJax but Spiller is such a stud I still think hes an RB1

11. Lynch- boring but gets the job done and will get a ton of carries. Plays in a tough division

12. Richardson- guy is so talented but the team is so bad

13. Bush- guy looks damn good and is locked in to get a ton of touches

14. Sproles- PPR stud

Upper tier RB2s (will put up some RB1 games, matchup plays but you probably cant afford to bench them most weeks):

15. Ridley- ALOT of mouths to feed but the guy is flat out good

16. McGahee- so under rated, just keep performing

17. Mathews- Im starting to lose faith, probably wont get goal line touches. Obviously he can jump into tier 2

18. Morris- I dont fear the Shenanigans anymore, guy is locked in as a fulltime RB, doesnt catch passes

19. BJGE- another under rated player, getting a ton of TDs. Starting to fumble which is worrisome

Mid tier RB2s (the old guard):

20. Gore- Starting to get old, losing touches

21. SJax- tough schedule, alot of miles

22. Johnson- was this week fools gold? I think hes done IMO

23. Turner- he'll get TDs, not much else

Lower tier RB2s (matchup plays):

24. Benson- good offense should give him ample opportunities

25. Martin- he doesnt look good at all, starting to lose touches to Blount. Ill keep him up here for now but can move down

26. Bradshaw- we'll see what happens tonight but I still say 60/40 split with Brown which should be enough. He can easily move up or down

27. LeShoure- getting a lot of touches but Im not sure he can handle the workload or is that good

28. FJackson- worse half of the RBBC IMO

29. DBrown- nothing special, not much competition

RB3s (flex plays):

30. RWilliams- terrible OLine, tough division, little competition

31. DWilliams- getting the goal line looks but splits with Stewart

32. Stewart- gets the catches but splits with Williams

33. Mendenhall- I have no clue if he is healthy but if he is will have little competition and will move up. Putting him here for now

The rest (intriguing handcuffs that can be studs if starters get healthy but still low end flex):

Tate, ABrown, Bolden, Battle, Bush, Thomas, Rogers

Handcuffs that can be studs if starter gets hurt, little value if else:

BPowell, LMiller, Pierce, BBrown, Gerhart, Bell, Blount, Hunter, DRichardson, Turbin

Everyone else is droppable IMO. Feel free to tear this apart/discuss

 

[Ace zero1]

I need to upgrade here badly. Nice write up

 

[ponchsox]

Lynch and Richardson should be top 10.

 

[heropretend]

mcfadden has to drop out the top 10 at least.

mccoy...i no longer trust andy reid to get him the ball.

peterson, sure he's back, but games aren't very explosive.

charles mjd rice and foster look to be above the rest.

 

[sporthenry]

mcfadden has to drop out the top 10 at least.mccoy...i no longer trust andy reid to get him the ball.peterson, sure he's back, but games aren't very explosive. charles mjd rice and foster look to be above the rest.

McCoy will get the ball, just last year he had 20 TDs which wasn't going to be duplicated. I like Peterson going forward. He should continue to get stronger as the year goes on and as the Vikes are apparently a decent team who will win their fair share of games, he'll continue to be used to run the clock out like today. And I still don't like MJD going forward. He'll have his 150+ yard game or two from here on out but he'll have too many games where they stack the box.

 

[flc735]

just my thoughts

i think your too low on trent. his TDs and rec skills will make up for his poor offense.

i think there is a tier drop off after foster and rice

mathews at 17 is lol to me. a lot of question marks but without that fumble, he would have put up a 30 point game today. foster, rice, mccoy, mjd and charles are the only rb's i'd take over him right now

i'd move mcgehee down a bit out of fear he wears down twoards the end of the year

the value of dmac was his #1 rb potential when healthy. he doesn't seem to have that this year. also, i think people are starting to overlook his risk of injury. it's coming. i'd drop him to the next tier

 

[shadyridr]

just my thoughts

i think your too low on trent. his TDs and rec skills will make up for his poor offense.

i think there is a tier drop off after foster and rice

mathews at 17 is lol to me. a lot of question marks but without that fumble, he would have put up a 30 point game today. foster, rice, mccoy, mjd and charles are the only rb's i'd take over him right now

i'd move mcgehee down a bit out of fear he wears down twoards the end of the year

the value of dmac was his #1 rb potential when healthy. he doesn't seem to have that this year. also, i think people are starting to overlook his risk of injury. it's coming. i'd drop him to the next tier

 

[flc735]

just my thoughts

i think your too low on trent. his TDs and rec skills will make up for his poor offense.

i think there is a tier drop off after foster and rice

mathews at 17 is lol to me. a lot of question marks but without that fumble, he would have put up a 30 point game today. foster, rice, mccoy, mjd and charles are the only rb's i'd take over him right now

i'd move mcgehee down a bit out of fear he wears down twoards the end of the year

the value of dmac was his #1 rb potential when healthy. he doesn't seem to have that this year. also, i think people are starting to overlook his risk of injury. it's coming. i'd drop him to the next tier

ronnie brown: 8 ptsbattle: 24 pts

mathews: 10 pts

most of those numbers go to mathews without the fumble last week

i think mathews will be back to being the bell cow very soon

 

[Maurile Tremblay]

Remotely Operated Shutter? Resistant Ovary Syndrome? Right of Survivorship? Robot Operating System? Royal Order of Scotland?

 

[mjohnell]

Remotely Operated Shutter? Resistant Ovary Syndrome? Right of Survivorship? Robot Operating System? Royal Order of Scotland?

I was thinking Rest Of Season but I could be wrong.

 

[Maurile Tremblay]

Remotely Operated Shutter? Resistant Ovary Syndrome? Right of Survivorship? Robot Operating System? Royal Order of Scotland?

I was thinking Rest Of Season but I could be wrong.

That possibility came to me right after I hit "reply."

 

[heropretend]

mcfadden has to drop out the top 10 at least.mccoy...i no longer trust andy reid to get him the ball.peterson, sure he's back, but games aren't very explosive. charles mjd rice and foster look to be above the rest.

McCoy will get the ball, just last year he had 20 TDs which wasn't going to be duplicated. I like Peterson going forward. He should continue to get stronger as the year goes on and as the Vikes are apparently a decent team who will win their fair share of games, he'll continue to be used to run the clock out like today. And I still don't like MJD going forward. He'll have his 150+ yard game or two from here on out but he'll have too many games where they stack the box.

i think going forward, a reasonable expectation for peterson is 80 yards, 1 td, 1-2 catches. for ppr that's a guy outside the top 5.the stack the box argument is sound logic, but mjd's numbers last year were incredlbe and this year should be more of the same.

 

[sporthenry]

mcfadden has to drop out the top 10 at least.mccoy...i no longer trust andy reid to get him the ball.peterson, sure he's back, but games aren't very explosive. charles mjd rice and foster look to be above the rest.

McCoy will get the ball, just last year he had 20 TDs which wasn't going to be duplicated. I like Peterson going forward. He should continue to get stronger as the year goes on and as the Vikes are apparently a decent team who will win their fair share of games, he'll continue to be used to run the clock out like today. And I still don't like MJD going forward. He'll have his 150+ yard game or two from here on out but he'll have too many games where they stack the box.

i think going forward, a reasonable expectation for peterson is 80 yards, 1 td, 1-2 catches. for ppr that's a guy outside the top 5.the stack the box argument is sound logic, but mjd's numbers last year were incredlbe and this year should be more of the same.

Well now you are going to PPR, so then Sproles probably becomes a Tier 1 or 2 at worst. I'm not talking about PPR and you can adjust as necessary but I still think he is more involved in the passing game. If he averages 80 yards/TD the rest of the way, he'd finish at 218 points which would have been good enough for #5 RB last year. He has also been used more in the passing game, as he has gotten 4 targets in each of the past 2 weeks compared to just 1 for 3 yards in week 1. They are going to slowly work him back but they are also in a playoff race however early it is so they'll lean on him more and more and to win/control the clock for the defense, it means more AP. As far as MJD, first off he has the most carries since '09 which I think will see a decline. He also has 3 games at 12 points or less compared to 5 all year last year. If you are talking about PPR, then you probably still have some numbers b/c he is a safety valve but last year he had 25% of his points in 2 games.

 

[UFGator0587]

Morris and Lynch should be higher, IMO.

McFadden lower. Maybe Ridley as well.

 

[BobbyLayne]

McGahee has 9 100 yard games 2011-12, tied for first in the NFL. 6 catches today. Consistently underrated.

And who on that roster will take carries from him?

 

[DoubleG]

Remotely Operated Shutter? Resistant Ovary Syndrome? Right of Survivorship? Robot Operating System? Royal Order of Scotland?

6,9.5,8,4,7BTW, great post shady - my only issue is that since this is ROS ( ) and Mednenhall has finished top 20 the last 3 years and is only 1 year removed from a 1200+ rushing season, and is still only 25 year old - I'd easily have him with your mid 2's. I also might bump Trent - but not much, maybe 2-3 spots. (and I own him).

 

[Leroy Hoard]

Remotely Operated Shutter? Resistant Ovary Syndrome? Right of Survivorship? Robot Operating System? Royal Order of Scotland?

lolbtw, these types of threads bring tiers to my eyes.

 

[Nucker101]

I think you have Spiller too high, I see him more in the mid RB2 when Jackson is healthy. I wouldn't feel comfortable starting any New England RB(they won't play the Bills every week and put up 50+) so I would definitely have Ridley lower, personally. I would still have Mathews in the 10-15 range, probably closer to 10. The rest is pretty hard to argue with at this point. Good work overall.

 

[DevilintheDetail]

I hate to say it, since I traded him away a couple of weeks ago, but it is hard for me to see how Alfred Morris is not top 10. He's getting all of the work and has put up top 5 numbers so far. I'd much rather have him than a guy like McFadden. Given his o-line problems, I'd probably put Murray behind him, too.

 

[Not Sleeping]

26. Bradshaw- we'll see what happens tonight but I still say 60/40 split with Brown which should be enough. He can easily move up or down

Up he goes. I've learned never to bet against Bradshaw. For me, it was as a Jacobs owner last year and Bradshaw had a broken foot. A broken FOOT! Reminder: Ahmad Bradshaw is an NFL running back. He needs his feet to be unbroken. I thought, surely, Jacobs is the undisputed primary back now, right? A BROKEN FOOT! What happens? Bradshaw puts up 210 total yards and 4 TD's in the final 3 weeks of the season.All you guys who thought Brown stole the job from Bradshaw because of a tweaked neck and Brown's easy pickings vs. a horrible Carolina run defense have clearly not been on the wrong side of a Bradshaw bet in years past.

 

[Cliff Clavin]

I'd say my top 3 tiers would look like this. The Vikings offense looks even worse than Cleveland's. Peterson has 2 touchdowns through 4 games and I don't see the potential for him to have a monster 3-TD day. 120 yards and a TD may be his ceiling with 85 yards and 0 TDs more often than you would like. Richardson is tough because it looks like he could be overvalued with 4 touchdowns driving a lot of his value so far. But week 1 he was just coming back from injury and they're just working him into 3rd down situations, so I see his value continuing to go up.STUD RB1s:1. Foster2. RiceVERY GOOD RB1s:3. McCoy4. CharlesMid tier RB1s (will have the occasional dud):5. MJD6. Lynch7. Richardson8. Peterson9. McFadden10. Forte11. Murray

Not even a mention of the guy who is 4th in carries, 7th in points and is clearly the feature back?

 

[shadyridr]

26. Bradshaw- we'll see what happens tonight but I still say 60/40 split with Brown which should be enough. He can easily move up or down

Up he goes. I've learned never to bet against Bradshaw. For me, it was as a Jacobs owner last year and Bradshaw had a broken foot. A broken FOOT! Reminder: Ahmad Bradshaw is an NFL running back. He needs his feet to be unbroken. I thought, surely, Jacobs is the undisputed primary back now, right? A BROKEN FOOT! What happens? Bradshaw puts up 210 total yards and 4 TD's in the final 3 weeks of the season.All you guys who thought Brown stole the job from Bradshaw because of a tweaked neck and Brown's easy pickings vs. a horrible Carolina run defense have clearly not been on the wrong side of a Bradshaw bet in years past.

agreed. he moves into the middle of the 4th tier now

 

[Cliff Clavin]

I'd say my top 3 tiers would look like this. The Vikings offense looks even worse than Cleveland's. Peterson has 2 touchdowns through 4 games and I don't see the potential for him to have a monster 3-TD day. 120 yards and a TD may be his ceiling with 85 yards and 0 TDs more often than you would like. Richardson is tough because it looks like he could be overvalued with 4 touchdowns driving a lot of his value so far. But week 1 he was just coming back from injury and they're just working him into 3rd down situations, so I see his value continuing to go up.STUD RB1s:1. Foster2. RiceVERY GOOD RB1s:3. McCoy4. CharlesMid tier RB1s (will have the occasional dud):5. MJD6. Lynch7. Richardson8. Peterson9. McFadden10. Forte11. Murray

Not even a mention of the guy who is 4th in carries, 7th in points and is clearly the feature back?

Morris?Thought about it; not sure where on this list he'd go. I'm still bothered by Shanhan's history and RGIII's propensity to try to run it himself on big downs. I wouldn't say it would be wrong to put him 8th or lower but I don't know if I'd trade one of the guys on the list for him.

How many weeks of being the feature back will it take for you (and lots of others) to not be bothered by this? The only threat to take carries now is Royster and he hasn't seen more than 5 touches in a week. He hasn't had more than 2 carries in a week!The only legitimate arguments are RG3 thieving goal-line carries and Morris not getting any receptions. Those are a lot less worrisome to me than a stuff like a potential nagging ankle injury to Forte (plus a well performing Bush) or terrible offenses in Oakland and Dallas

 

[Run It Up]

PPR

Top Tier Producers:

1. Rice

2. Foster

3. MJD

4. Peterson

Great to Good:

5. Mccoy

6. Charles

7. R. Bush

8. Sproles

9. Mcfadden

Producers:

10. Richardson

11. Bradshaw

12. Morris

13. Lynch

14. FJax

15. BJGE

Great to Bad:

16. Gore

17. Ridley

18. SJax

19. Murray

20. Turner

Good to Bad:

21. Forte

22. Leshoure

23. Martin

24. Benson

25. Brown/Williams/Mendenhall

Ryan Mathews tier:

28. Mathews

 

[BobbyLayne]

PPR

Top Tier Producers:

1. Rice

2. Foster

3. MJD

4. Peterson

Great to Good:

5. Mccoy

6. Charles

7. R. Bush

8. Sproles

9. Mcfadden

Producers:

10. Richardson

11. Bradshaw

12. Morris

13. Lynch

14. FJax

15. BJGE

Great to Bad:

16. Gore

17. Ridley

18. SJax

19. Murray

20. Turner

Good to Bad:

21. Forte

22. Leshoure

23. Martin

24. Benson

25. Brown/Williams/Mendenhall

Ryan Mathews tier:

28. Mathews

No Willis, eh?

 

[Run It Up]

PPR

Top Tier Producers:

1. Rice

2. Foster

3. MJD

4. Peterson

Great to Good:

5. Mccoy

6. Charles

7. R. Bush

8. Sproles

9. Mcfadden

Producers:

10. Richardson

11. Bradshaw

12. Morris

13. Lynch

14. FJax

15. BJGE

Great to Bad:

16. Gore

17. Ridley

18. SJax

19. Murray

20. Turner

Good to Bad:

21. Forte

22. Leshoure

23. Martin

24. Benson

25. Brown/Williams/Mendenhall

Ryan Mathews tier:

28. Mathews

No Willis, eh?

Forgot Mcgahee, I would put him near the bottom of the good to bad, I thought at the beginning of the year that he would be great in that system, but I was wrong.

 

[BobbyLayne]

PPR

Top Tier Producers:

1. Rice

2. Foster

3. MJD

4. Peterson

Great to Good:

5. Mccoy

6. Charles

7. R. Bush

8. Sproles

9. Mcfadden

Producers:

10. Richardson

11. Bradshaw

12. Morris

13. Lynch

14. FJax

15. BJGE

Great to Bad:

16. Gore

17. Ridley

18. SJax

19. Murray

20. Turner

Good to Bad:

21. Forte

22. Leshoure

23. Martin

24. Benson

25. Brown/Williams/Mendenhall

Ryan Mathews tier:

28. Mathews

No Willis, eh?

Forgot Mcgahee, I would put him near the bottom of the good to bad, I thought at the beginning of the year that he would be great in that system, but I was wrong.

He's RB10 in PPR, but I def play matchups with him. He's had a couple solid games. I just think it's interesting he has the most 100 yard games in the NFL over the last 2 seasons, but nobody gives him any credit.

 

[Run It Up]

He's RB10 in PPR, but I def play matchups with him. He's had a couple solid games. I just think it's interesting he has the most 100 yard games in the NFL over the last 2 seasons, but nobody gives him any credit.

Yeah, I might have to reevaluate him, two bad games against top run Ds, and two great games against bad to okay run Ds. If he can continue the trend hes pretty close to a producer imo, ~RB14-20

 

[Not Sleeping]

As a McFadden and Mathews owner (yes, I'm 1-3), I feel a lot better about Mathews right now than McFadden. With Mathews, there's still hope that yesterday's little AJ/Norv stunt is behind us, he will go off against New Orleans this week, and all will be right with the world after that. With McFadden...I don't know...I'm running out of positive ways to spin it. #9 might be too high for him.

 

[MNTom]

I'd say my top 3 tiers would look like this. The Vikings offense looks even worse than Cleveland's. Peterson has 2 touchdowns through 4 games and I don't see the potential for him to have a monster 3-TD day. 120 yards and a TD may be his ceiling with 85 yards and 0 TDs more often than you would like. Richardson is tough because it looks like he could be overvalued with 4 touchdowns driving a lot of his value so far. But week 1 he was just coming back from injury and they're just working him into 3rd down situations, so I see his value continuing to go up.

STUD RB1s:

1. Foster

2. Rice

VERY GOOD RB1s:

3. McCoy

4. Charles

Mid tier RB1s (will have the occasional dud):

5. MJD

6. Lynch

7. Richardson

8. Peterson

9. McFadden

10. Forte

11. Murray

Against the Lions on Sunday, Peterson had 3 runs that were almost 50+ TD runs. You could see an additional burst he didn't have the first 3 games. And it will only get better.

 

[Khy]

PPR

Top Tier Producers:

1. Rice

2. Foster

3. MJD

4. Peterson

Great to Good:

5. Mccoy

6. Charles

7. R. Bush

8. Sproles

9. Mcfadden

Producers:

10. Richardson

11. Bradshaw

12. Morris

13. Lynch

14. FJax

15. BJGE

Great to Bad:

16. Gore

17. Ridley

18. SJax

19. Murray

20. Turner

Good to Bad:

21. Forte

22. Leshoure

23. Martin

24. Benson

25. Brown/Williams/Mendenhall

Ryan Mathews tier:

28. Mathews

Bump Richardson and downgrade McFadden. Not sure how you have McFadden above him... Richardson is currently 6th in my PPR league compared to McFadden at 19. By the same token, Lynch is 8th, Morris is 9th. Ahead of Reggie Bush, ahead of McGahee and ahead of Shady. Seems like nobody gives these three the credit they deserve for the 4 weeks they have put up so far. As for non-ppr, people that are still tossing McFadden, Forte and Murray ahead of T Rich, Morris and Lynch are basing it purely off of name-brand value. In my non-ppr league Morris is behind only Foster and Ray Rice. It's a shame the kid still is getting the "Shanhanigans" vote of non-confidence. Clearly he's a fantasy stud and easily in the top 10 in non-ppr rankings going forward.

Note: Yeah, I'm owners of Morris, Lynch and T Rich that said I'm not saying this with bias. My ownership doesn't change the facts that right now Lynch is leading the league in rushing and Morris and Richardson are top 5 non-ppr RBs.

 

[shadyridr]

ok i think most are in agreement... move down mcfadden, move up richardson and lynch. good work fellas

 

[Run It Up]

PPR9. Mcfadden10. Richardson

Bump Richardson and downgrade McFadden. Not sure how you have McFadden above him... Richardson is currently 6th in my PPR league compared to McFadden at 19. By the same token, Lynch is 8th, Morris is 9th. Ahead of Reggie Bush, ahead of McGahee and ahead of Shady. Seems like nobody gives these three the credit they deserve for the 4 weeks they have put up so far. As for non-ppr, people that are still tossing McFadden, Forte and Murray ahead of T Rich, Morris and Lynch are basing it purely off of name-brand value. In my non-ppr league Morris is behind only Foster and Ray Rice. It's a shame the kid still is getting the "Shanhanigans" vote of non-confidence. Clearly he's a fantasy stud and easily in the top 10 in non-ppr rankings going forward. Note: Yeah, I'm owners of Morris, Lynch and T Rich that said I'm not saying this with bias. My ownership doesn't change the facts that right now Lynch is leading the league in rushing and Morris and Richardson are top 5 non-ppr RBs.

In my defense, they are touching each other lol.The same argument I would make for Mcfadden being ahead of Richardson is the same one people have been making for him all offseason, we've seen what Mcfadden do if healthy, we havent seen enough of Richardson yet. Oakland is gonna have to revert back to old habits sooner or later, Palmer is a liability, a liability that will kill their chances at winning games and they will have to begin leaning on Mcfadden again. Which I think they will do and thats the only reason I have him ranked above Richardson.Also, as many leagues as im in I own practically all of these guys, I may have a bias with Rice over Foster, but its close enough already that if need be I could make an argument for my case.

 

[Khy]

PPR9. Mcfadden10. Richardson

Bump Richardson and downgrade McFadden. Not sure how you have McFadden above him... Richardson is currently 6th in my PPR league compared to McFadden at 19. By the same token, Lynch is 8th, Morris is 9th. Ahead of Reggie Bush, ahead of McGahee and ahead of Shady. Seems like nobody gives these three the credit they deserve for the 4 weeks they have put up so far. As for non-ppr, people that are still tossing McFadden, Forte and Murray ahead of T Rich, Morris and Lynch are basing it purely off of name-brand value. In my non-ppr league Morris is behind only Foster and Ray Rice. It's a shame the kid still is getting the "Shanhanigans" vote of non-confidence. Clearly he's a fantasy stud and easily in the top 10 in non-ppr rankings going forward. Note: Yeah, I'm owners of Morris, Lynch and T Rich that said I'm not saying this with bias. My ownership doesn't change the facts that right now Lynch is leading the league in rushing and Morris and Richardson are top 5 non-ppr RBs.

In my defense, they are touching each other lol.The same argument I would make for Mcfadden being ahead of Richardson is the same one people have been making for him all offseason, we've seen what Mcfadden do if healthy, we havent seen enough of Richardson yet. Oakland is gonna have to revert back to old habits sooner or later, Palmer is a liability, a liability that will kill their chances at winning games and they will have to begin leaning on Mcfadden again. Which I think they will do and thats the only reason I have him ranked above Richardson.Also, as many leagues as im in I own practically all of these guys, I may have a bias with Rice over Foster, but its close enough already that if need be I could make an argument for my case.

It's a valid point with McFadden but I haven't seen any of what he can do all season besides one big run last week.As for Foster vs Rice, it's like arguing with difference between $1,000,000 and $1,000,001. The only thing I think that makes me always bump Foster slightly higher are those random weeks 1-2 times a year where the Ravens forget Rice is on the team.

 

[Mile High]

PPR

Top Tier Producers:

1. Rice

2. Foster

3. MJD

4. Peterson

Great to Good:

5. Mccoy

6. Charles

7. R. Bush

8. Sproles

9. Mcfadden

Producers:

10. Richardson

11. Bradshaw

12. Morris

13. Lynch

14. FJax

15. BJGE

Great to Bad:

16. Gore

17. Ridley

18. SJax

19. Murray

20. Turner

Good to Bad:

21. Forte

22. Leshoure

23. Martin

24. Benson

25. Brown/Williams/Mendenhall

Ryan Mathews tier:

28. Mathews

No Willis, eh?

Forgot Mcgahee, I would put him near the bottom of the good to bad, I thought at the beginning of the year that he would be great in that system, but I was wrong.

Mcgahee might still pick it up. Yesterday Denver running backs caught 9 passes, I think they only had 7 total in the 3 games before yesterday..

 

[althepostman]

PPR

Top Tier Producers:

1. Rice

2. Foster

3. MJD

4. Peterson

Great to Good:

5. Mccoy

6. Charles

7. R. Bush

8. Sproles

9. Mcfadden

Producers:

10. Richardson

11. Bradshaw

12. Morris

13. Lynch

14. FJax

15. BJGE

Great to Bad:

16. Gore

17. Ridley

18. SJax

19. Murray

20. Turner

Good to Bad:

21. Forte

22. Leshoure

23. Martin

24. Benson

25. Brown/Williams/Mendenhall

Ryan Mathews tier:

28. Mathews

No Spiller?

 

[kutta]

Take out the OP's top tier (Foster, Rice, McCoy, Peterson, Charles), and I'm having trouble finding two guys I'd rather have than Morris and McGahee.

These guys are both putting up very good yardage totals, they score TD's, and they have almost zero competition for carries. What's not to like?

 

[mjohnell]

Take out the OP's top tier (Foster, Rice, McCoy, Peterson, Charles), and I'm having trouble finding two guys I'd rather have than Morris and McGahee.These guys are both putting up very good yardage totals, they score TD's, and they have almost zero competition for carries. What's not to like?

That is where I am at as well. They are both still extremely undervalued.

 

[Rovers]

No Shon Greene? LOL... how bad are my Jets? Is there now ANY Jet player who could make the top 30? Oh boy.

I'd drop Benson a bit. He just faced the N.O. D and didn't do much with it. Agree with dropping McFadden,even if I did waste a 1st rounder on him. Oakland is similar to the Jets in that they suck. McFadden's main value is in his potential to get looong TD's, and that won't happen every week. Oakland's O line is gawd awful.

Very nice list, not much there to pik a nit over.

 

[hines]

No Shon Greene? LOL... how bad are my Jets? Is there now ANY Jet player who could make the top 30? Oh boy. I'd drop Benson a bit. He just faced the N.O. D and didn't do much with it. Agree with dropping McFadden,even if I did waste a 1st rounder on him. Oakland is similar to the Jets in that they suck. McFadden's main value is in his potential to get looong TD's, and that won't happen every week. Oakland's O line is gawd awful. Very nice list, not much there to pik a nit over.

Benson had a strong game, only Graham Harrell tripping and fumbling as he went to hand off at the 1 yd line kept him from a 20 point game. He's had 3 straight solid 13-17 point games

 

[donkshow]

I feel Foster and Rice are in their own tier.