packersfan
Footballguy
I disagree. I would say the following RBs would find a way to be MUCH more productive than McGahee has been this season -- especially the last several weeks:LTI think 90+% of NFL RBs would struggle behind the Bills offensive line of this year.For about 50 yards.I still think he's a talented player who will do much better with improved blocking up front. The offensive line play of the Bills this year has probably been in the bottom 5 of the league.I still feel pretty good about having him as the Bills RB for the future. If they make a coaching change this offseason, I hope whoever they brings in rides him a lot more than Mularkey has been willing to do lately. He's still a workhorse who you can rely on for 20-25 carries every week.The bigger question now is did the Bills over-rate McGahee and do they need to be worried about their RB situation?I will now concede that Willis McGahee was indeed overrated this year.
good call by JoeT and others.![]()
Edge
Alexander
Barber
Larry Johnson
Clinton Portis
Corey Dillon
Rudi Johnson
That group without question and I would be willing to bet these RBs would also be more productive:
Thomas Jones
Domanick Davis
Reuben Droughns
Cadillac Williams
McGahee has become nothing more than an average starting RB - and that's probably being kind. He runs with no power, no aggressiveness and no authority. He's as a big a problem as Mularkey or the line or Losman or anything else going on with the Bills right now.