zcollins14
Footballguy
Need some outside opinions make sure I'm being rational. Firstly, league is 12 teams, 1/2 PPR, start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 2 R/W/T Flex, kicker, defense. My current Roster is: QB: Carr, Palmer; RB: D. Johnson, M. Gordon, G. Bernard, T. Coleman, J. Starks; WR: OD Beckhan, TY Hilton, D. THomas, Tyrell Williams, S. Coats, P. Dorsett; TE: M. Bennett, C. Fleener. As you can see, a little weak at QB, TE and RB depth.
My brother is gonna be 0-5 after this week, and is trying to get some keeper options for next year (keep 2 players). He really wants David Johnson (DJ will be a 6th rounder next year), I have turned down a few proposals already but he is basically offering the world for him. His latest proposal is Cam Newton, Jordy Nelson, Jordan Reed and ARI D for johnson straight up. That would leave me quite thin at RB, I would probably try get him to throw in an RB, but I am still hesitant. Value wise I am getting upgrades at QB, TE, WR and Defense, and logically it seems like a good trade, however I am leaning towards declining. My trade philosophy is generally to try to upgrade RB position and take depth hits elsewhere, which this trade does the opposite. Also (and the reason I need an outside oppinion), I drafted D. Johnson last year and held onto him throughout a poor season, to finally have him breakout at the end of the year, and he looks every bit a stud workhorse RB this year. My gut is telling me to ride or die with Johnson and let the rest work itself out. Am I crazy??? If so, (if you would trade away Johnson), what combo would you pick? He also has J. Hill and Ingram or Gronk I could probably work in somehow, maybe Cam, Reed, Hill and ARI for Johnson. Thanks for the help!!
My brother is gonna be 0-5 after this week, and is trying to get some keeper options for next year (keep 2 players). He really wants David Johnson (DJ will be a 6th rounder next year), I have turned down a few proposals already but he is basically offering the world for him. His latest proposal is Cam Newton, Jordy Nelson, Jordan Reed and ARI D for johnson straight up. That would leave me quite thin at RB, I would probably try get him to throw in an RB, but I am still hesitant. Value wise I am getting upgrades at QB, TE, WR and Defense, and logically it seems like a good trade, however I am leaning towards declining. My trade philosophy is generally to try to upgrade RB position and take depth hits elsewhere, which this trade does the opposite. Also (and the reason I need an outside oppinion), I drafted D. Johnson last year and held onto him throughout a poor season, to finally have him breakout at the end of the year, and he looks every bit a stud workhorse RB this year. My gut is telling me to ride or die with Johnson and let the rest work itself out. Am I crazy??? If so, (if you would trade away Johnson), what combo would you pick? He also has J. Hill and Ingram or Gronk I could probably work in somehow, maybe Cam, Reed, Hill and ARI for Johnson. Thanks for the help!!
