Redraft WR Tiers from the "Not In Touch" Perspective (1 Viewer)

[SeniorVBDStudent]

Here, fwiw, is my first cut Tiers List for redraft WRs in a non-ppr default scoring yahoo league (except INTs -2 for QBs).

Feel free to critique or argue with me as you see fit...

I like philly, ne, san fran, gb, caro, buffalo to exceed common perceptions.

I like dallas, indy, and denver passing to underperform expectations.

Tier I

Randy Moss

Larry Fitzgerald

Andre Johnson

Calvin Johnson

Greg Jennings

Reggie Wayne

Marques Colston

Steve Smith

Tier II

Roddy White

Anquan Boldin

Brandon Marshall

Terrell Owens

TJ Houshmandzadeh

Chad Ochocinco

Dwayne Bowe

Vincent Jackson

Santana Moss

Tier III

Braylon Edwards

Santonio Holmes

DeSean Jackson

Wes Welker

Roy Williams

Lee Evans

Antonio Bryant

Bernard Berrian

Hines Ward

Anthony Gonzalez

Jerricho Cotchery

Tier IV

Ted Ginn Jr.

Devin Hester

Donald Driver

Torry Holt

Eddie Royal

Laveranues Coles

Lance Moore

Kevin Walter

Derrick Mason

Steve Breaston

Kevin Curtis

The Rest

Donnie Avery

Josh Morgan

Joey Galloway

Hakeem NIcks

Chaz Schilens

Devin Hester

Michael Crabtree

Deion Branch

Steve Smith

Percy Harvin

Ted Ginn

Chris Henry

Chris Chambers

Mark Clayton

Muhsin Muhammad

Patrick Crayton

Michael Jenkins

Josh Morgan

Greg Camarillo

Antwaan Randle El

Jeremy Maclin

Nate Washington

Domenik Hixon

Darrius Heyward-Bey

Mark Bradley

Isaac Bruce

Jordy Nelson

 

[Keith1]

don't think Santana Moss makes it to Tier 2. Otherwise I thought the first two tiers were spot on.

 

[SeniorVBDStudent]

don't think Santana Moss makes it to Tier 2. Otherwise I thought the first two tiers were spot on.

yeah; I'm tempted to break out the group from vincent jackson down to wes welker as a separate tier (and moving welker up to near the top of that group - pats homer).

 

[nysfl2]

I'd swap Boldin and Colston in Tier 1 and 2. Colston mostly due to health concerns. Santana Moss doesn't below in Tier 2. I'd probably also put Vincent Jackson at the top of Tier 3, probably along with Housh. Ochocinco has enough upside that he can probably stay at the bottom of Tier 2, but it's borderline. I think there's a huge gap between Tiers 1 and 2 and the rest.

 

[Gr00vus]

There's Fitz and Moss and then everybody else.

 

[jurb26]

Your tier 1 is far to big IMO. Here is how I see it, using all the same players as you listed.... BTW you know you listed Ginn twice (tier 4 and tier 5).

Tier I

Randy Moss

Tier II

Andre Johnson

Larry Fitzgerald

Calvin Johnson

Greg Jennings

Reggie Wayne

Marques Colston

Tier III

Steve Smith

Roddy White

Anquan Boldin

Brandon Marshall

Terrell Owens

TJ Houshmandzadeh

Chad Ochocinco

Dwayne Bowe

Roy Williams

Tier IV

Vincent Jackson

Santana Moss

Braylon Edwards

Santonio Holmes

DeSean Jackson

Wes Welker

Lee Evans

Antonio Bryant

Bernard Berrian

Ted Ginn Jr.

Tier V

Devin Hester

Hines Ward

Anthony Gonzalez

Jerricho Cotchery

Donald Driver

Eddie Royal

Laveranues Coles

Lance Moore

Kevin Walter

Derrick Mason

Steve Breaston

Kevin Curtis

The Rest

Torry Holt

Donnie Avery

Josh Morgan

Joey Galloway

Hakeem Nicks

Chaz Schilens

Devin Hester

Michael Crabtree

Deion Branch

Steve Smith

Percy Harvin

Chris Henry

Chris Chambers

Mark Clayton

Muhsin Muhammad

Patrick Crayton

Michael Jenkins

Josh Morgan

Greg Camarillo

Antwaan Randle El

Jeremy Maclin

Nate Washington

Domenik Hixon

Darrius Heyward-Bey

Mark Bradley

Isaac Bruce

Jordy Nelson

 

[BobbyLayne]

Your tier 1 is far to big IMO. Here is how I see it, using all the same players as you listed.... Tier I Randy MossTier IIAndre JohnsonLarry FitzgeraldCalvin JohnsonGreg JenningsReggie WayneMarques ColstonTier IIISteve SmithRoddy WhiteAnquan BoldinBrandon MarshallTerrell OwensTJ HoushmandzadehChad OchocincoDwayne BoweRoy Williams

Merely semantics, as I love the order you have them listed...but I would put Moss/Fitz/AJ/CJ in Tier I together. I know everyone wants to annoint the Freak as otherworldly and without peer, but if we're being honest, any of those four could end up as the #1 FF WR.Jennings, Wayne, Colston, Smith, White and Boldin make up my Tier II.Marshall/Owens/Housh/85/RoY are have reasonable questions which dictate them being in Tier III.Bowe, however, probably should move up one. Anyway, great listing, very similar to the way I see it.

 

[FUBAR]

Royal belongs in whatever tier DeSean, Holmes and Braylon are in.

 

[fightingillini]

Here, fwiw, is my first cut Tiers List for redraft WRs in a non-ppr default scoring yahoo league (except INTs -2 for QBs).Feel free to critique or argue with me as you see fit...I like philly, ne, san fran, gb, caro, buffalo to exceed common perceptions.I like dallas, indy, and denver passing to underperform expectations.Tier I Randy MossLarry FitzgeraldAndre JohnsonCalvin JohnsonGreg JenningsReggie WayneMarques ColstonSteve SmithTier IIRoddy WhiteAnquan BoldinBrandon MarshallTerrell OwensTJ HoushmandzadehChad OchocincoDwayne BoweVincent JacksonSantana MossTier IIIBraylon EdwardsSantonio HolmesDeSean JacksonWes WelkerRoy WilliamsLee EvansAntonio BryantBernard BerrianHines WardAnthony GonzalezJerricho CotcheryTier IVTed Ginn Jr.Devin HesterDonald DriverTorry HoltEddie RoyalLaveranues ColesLance MooreKevin WalterDerrick MasonSteve BreastonKevin CurtisThe RestDonnie AveryJosh MorganJoey GallowayHakeem NIcksChaz SchilensDevin HesterMichael CrabtreeDeion BranchSteve SmithPercy HarvinTed GinnChris HenryChris ChambersMark ClaytonMuhsin MuhammadPatrick CraytonMichael JenkinsJosh MorganGreg CamarilloAntwaan Randle ElJeremy MaclinNate WashingtonDomenik HixonDarrius Heyward-BeyMark BradleyIsaac BruceJordy Nelson

I would make Fitz, R Moss, and A Johnson into their own Tier 1. IMO, they are the cream of the crop.I would move White and Boldin up a tier.Welker needs to move up, espeically in PPR.

 

[swirvenirvin]

Josh Moran twice?

 

[FF Newbie]

Other than Welker, Royal and S. Moss, this list looks pretty much like every other list out there. I'm not sure what you want us to comment on.