Rotoworlds RB rankings (1 Viewer)

[biggamer3]

http://www.rotoworld.com/content/features/...articleid=31592

Tier 1

1. Adrian Peterson

2. Frank Gore

3. Marion Barber

4. Matt Forte

5. Joseph Addai

6. LaDainian Tomlinson

7. Clinton Portis

8. Brandon Jacobs

9. Brian Westbrook

10. Thomas Jones

11. Chris Johnson

Tier 2

12. Ronnie Brown

13. Ryan Grant

14. Michael Turner

15. Marshawn Lynch

16. Maurice Jones-Drew

17. Reggie Bush

18. Steve Slaton

19. Steven Jackson

20. DeAngelo Williams

21. Larry Johnson

22. Willie Parker

Tier 3

23. Warrick Dunn

24. Jamal Lewis

25. Lendale White

26. Jonathan Stewart

27. Justin Fargas

28. Kevin Smith

29. Tim Hightower

30. Willis McGahee

31. Sammy Morris

32. Derrick Ward

33. Ricky Williams

34. Julius Jones

35. Ray Rice

Only gripes with his list is that Forte is way to high IMO, Kevin Smith is in Tier 2 IMO, and that Lynch is now tier 1 once again.

 

[PosterNutBag]

Only gripes with his list is that Forte is way to high IMO, Kevin Smith is in Tier 2 IMO, and that Lynch is now tier 1 once again.

I could rank Forte that high if we were talking PPR, but the author doesn't mention his basis from what I read.

 

[the spanker]

Only gripes with his list is that Forte is way to high IMO, Kevin Smith is in Tier 2 IMO, and that Lynch is now tier 1 once again.

I could rank Forte that high if we were talking PPR, but the author doesn't mention his basis from what I read.

Author says it's non-PPR. Did you really read it?

 

[PosterNutBag]

Only gripes with his list is that Forte is way to high IMO, Kevin Smith is in Tier 2 IMO, and that Lynch is now tier 1 once again.

I could rank Forte that high if we were talking PPR, but the author doesn't mention his basis from what I read.

Author says it's non-PPR. Did you really read it?

Yes, I did. Now I see it....but it is under Adrien Peterson's comments, which is not where I expected to see it.

 

[Buffaloes]

I would switch Addai and Thomas Jones...kind of hard to see Addai that high right now.

 

[SaintsInDome2006]

"]http://www.rotoworld.com/content/features/column.aspx?sport=NFL&columnid=131&articleid=31592"]

Only gripes with his list is that Forte is way to high IMO, Kevin ... .

Fyi, one of those guys at Rotoworld went to Tulane, can't remember which one....

 

[PosterNutBag]

I would switch Addai and Thomas Jones...kind of hard to see Addai that high right now.

I can see how you might have tempered optimism regarding Addai, but his schedule going forward is very kind.

 

[biggamer3]

I would switch Addai and Thomas Jones...kind of hard to see Addai that high right now.

I can see how you might have tempered optimism regarding Addai, but his schedule going forward is very kind.

Agreed i really like Addia moving forward

 

[Sgt_Russia]

Curious list. MJD has outscored 6-10 guys ahead of him, depending on scoring format.

 

[bcr8f]

Makes my trade of SJax for Thomas Jones, Steve Smith and a 1st round pick(probably 1.10 rookie) look good.

 

[biggamer3]

Makes my trade of SJax for Thomas Jones, Steve Smith and a 1st round pick(probably 1.10 rookie) look good.

I dont believe this!Even if this trade was made at SJAX peak this year, no way would someone also throw in a first rounder!God thats a sick deal

 

[Black]

Author says it's non-PPR. Did you really read it?

I didn't read it. That's why I am here...to let you read it and tell me what's interesting about it.Now, what's interesting about it? Seems a bit of Hindsight's 20/20 to me.

 

[Jeff Pasquino]

http://www.rotoworld.com/content/features/...articleid=31592

Tier 1

1. Adrian Peterson

2. Frank Gore

3. Marion Barber

4. Matt Forte

5. Joseph Addai

6. LaDainian Tomlinson

7. Clinton Portis

8. Brandon Jacobs

9. Brian Westbrook

10. Thomas Jones

11. Chris Johnson

Tier 2

12. Ronnie Brown

13. Ryan Grant

14. Michael Turner

15. Marshawn Lynch

16. Maurice Jones-Drew

17. Reggie Bush

18. Steve Slaton

19. Steven Jackson

20. DeAngelo Williams

21. Larry Johnson

22. Willie Parker

Tier 3

23. Warrick Dunn

24. Jamal Lewis

25. Lendale White

26. Jonathan Stewart

27. Justin Fargas

28. Kevin Smith

29. Tim Hightower

30. Willis McGahee

31. Sammy Morris

32. Derrick Ward

33. Ricky Williams

34. Julius Jones

35. Ray Rice

Only gripes with his list is that Forte is way to high IMO, Kevin Smith is in Tier 2 IMO, and that Lynch is now tier 1 once again.

I'd argue that (1) the tiers are too big and (2) I like this list better, but I'm biased about that one.

 

[Jeff Pasquino]

FWIW, I'll likely do another list like FBG Futures next week.