David Yudkin
Footballguy
From all accounts, Welker should be fine and does not appear to be all that banged up. Welker has said and shown that he has recovered from his knee injury. I wouldn't worry about him. He's been a full participant at practice for almost a week.Ocho is a different story, and I agree he could be an issue (but we won't know for awhile).Whether they won the SB or not, all teams should try to get better. But I will repeat the question. Does adding Moss make the Pats a better team?Did they win the Super Bowl? No? Then they SHOULD be trying to get better.%26%2339%3BDavid Yudkin said:They were 14-2 without him. Would he really make them that much better?I think the answer is Yes. Welker is banged-up, dealing with a neck injury, and possibly still not 100% from his torn ACL. Ochocinco is 32 years old. Both players are on the downsides of their career, at a position where players are known to hit the wall quickly and permanently.
In either case, Welker (age 30), Ochocinco (33), and even Branch (32) are all younger than Moss (34). If "players on the downsides of their career, at a position where players are known to hit the wall quickly and permanently" applies to the other guys, why does that not apply to Moss? Maybe Moss last year was trying but has lost a step, can't seperate, and is easily knocked off the line.
I think it's odd that we should think Moss can turn the switch on and light things up again while the younger guys almost by default have eroded skills.
In summary, at this point Moss needs the Patriots far more than the Patriots need Moss. Maybe that will change when 1) they stop scoring 35 points a game, 2) they have injuries at receiver, and/or 3) they stop winning.
I think some people are putting the microscope to the Jets loss and ignoring the other 16 games during the season. I've read many places that the Pats don't have a deep threat and they can't beat the Jets. If we look at only the last game NE played, it's easy to conclude that, but IMO that's a rush to judgment and shortsighted.
At this point, let's see if Moss even signs back with the Pats, as neither side can be right or wrong at this point as he isn't even on the team.