Mark Davis
Footballguy
Interesting pick tomorrow given who is out there. Wondering if the pick gets traded.
Eh, scouting reports are opinions, and they differ depending on who you listen to. I'm not a college guy so ill wait to form an opinion until I see him play.On the broadcast they said he was a hitter and poor in coverage. That's the worst possible compliment to Whitner. Maybe they are thinking Reid replaces Whitner next year and someone else plays FS.I don't watch college but from what I've read he will be a great compliment to Whitner and all he needs to do is play within himself in this defense and he will be fine. Let's hope soScouting reports aren't glowing and he doesn't appear to be a coverage guy. After the Taylor mays experiment I'm terrified of safeties with good combine numbers and no ball skills. Can't say I'm pumped about the pick.Pick 18, round one, SF takes Safety Eric Reid from LSU.We got our safety. Anyone still think Dahl will start at S? Lol
I agree with you.I'm not so sure Reid is any better than Matt Elam who just got taken at 32. I know the cost wasn't a ton to move up but Reid doesn't really do it for me. Hope I'm wrong but just didn't see the need.
I thought thats what was happening too. After last years uber questionable pick of AJ Jenkins, I was hoping for more of an impact player like Floyd when he started slipping. I know S was a need but so was DT with Justin Smith getting older.I agree with you.I'm not so sure Reid is any better than Matt Elam who just got taken at 32. I know the cost wasn't a ton to move up but Reid doesn't really do it for me. Hope I'm wrong but just didn't see the need.
I was really fired up thinking we were moving up for Shariff or Tank.
Pick 34....gimme Tank or Jesse. Please.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=msB2cYNL_o4Wingnut said:Eh, scouting reports are opinions, and they differ depending on who you listen to. I'm not a college guy so ill wait to form an opinion until I see him play.thecatch said:On the broadcast they said he was a hitter and poor in coverage. That's the worst possible compliment to Whitner. Maybe they are thinking Reid replaces Whitner next year and someone else plays FS.Wingnut said:I don't watch college but from what I've read he will be a great compliment to Whitner and all he needs to do is play within himself in this defense and he will be fine.Let's hope sothecatch said:Scouting reports aren't glowing and he doesn't appear to be a coverage guy. After the Taylor mays experiment I'm terrified of safeties with good combine numbers and no ball skills. Can't say I'm pumped about the pick.Wingnut said:Pick 18, round one, SF takes Safety Eric Reid from LSU.
We got our safety. Anyone still think Dahl will start at S? Lol
The lack of a move for a S in FA all pointed to S in the first round of the draft. Reid might not be a flashy pick, but I like defensive players out of LSU so i'm not disappointed. They still can go OLB and DT/NT later as well as CB, with a WR mixed in, who maybe can push Jenkins (which I agree was a questionable pick where he was drafted). Ertz would be awesome as well. I thought he would go higher with a price, but this years 1st round is all trenches and defense. Weird draft with no Blue Chip at QB.JHuber77 said:I thought thats what was happening too. After last years uber questionable pick of AJ Jenkins, I was hoping for more of an impact player like Floyd when he started slipping. I know S was a need but so was DT with Justin Smith getting older.I agree with you. I was really fired up thinking we were moving up for Shariff or Tank. Pick 34....gimme Tank or Jesse. Please.I'm not so sure Reid is any better than Matt Elam who just got taken at 32. I know the cost wasn't a ton to move up but Reid doesn't really do it for me. Hope I'm wrong but just didn't see the need.
Yeah, Ertz was kind of a 'wish pick' for me if they could get him, and DT is a greater need. Ertz might not had been on their board anyway.I actually like the trade down to net the extra 3rd we lost trading up in the 1st and the extra 7th. I think at 34 the pick should have been Carradine or Ertz, likely Carradine. The 49ers got the guy they likely wanted anyway and restocked the pick lost in the 1st round trade up.
They still need to find a cow for RB. Gore came out of the 3rd, so let's hope they find another.Anyone else feel like the biggest need left is CB? I'm just not sure there is one out there I really like.. I'd probably rather have Jesse Williams. Williams should fit the scheme pretty well. Although I may be biased a bit having seen him play so much around here.
I thought along those lines as well as a possibility. I'm guessing as a replacement for Anthony Dixon. Hunter and James are kind of the same type player and neither would seem to be able to handle the every down duties. Not sure really who is out there though that would fit. I still like Williams and also think someone eventually gets a good player in Corey Lemonier who not many are discussing. Not sure Lemonier fits with the 49ers though.They still need to find a cow for RB. Gore came out of the 3rd, so let's hope they find another.Anyone else feel like the biggest need left is CB? I'm just not sure there is one out there I really like.. I'd probably rather have Jesse Williams. Williams should fit the scheme pretty well. Although I may be biased a bit having seen him play so much around here.
Really bummed we took Vance and Lemon instead of Williams. Dang.What about Jesse Williams DT Alabama next?
Me too. They should trade right back up and snag him. They still have quite a few picksReally bummed we took Vance and Lemon instead of Williams. Dang.What about Jesse Williams DT Alabama next?
Lemon and Tank are edge guys, we have no inside depth.Williams at the least can rotate at nose, all we have therE now is Dorsey (who played de for kc).Williams still could happen I guess. Something must be out there about him though to not be off the board after many projected him as a late 1st round guy. I don't know if the Niners would do a 3rd DL as well. I'm hoping they have a CB out there they like but it very well could be that there just wasn't one in this class they really covet. As far as players dropping goes I thought the Chargers got a steal with Keenan Allen.

Really solid pick IMO, perfect replacement for Delanie Walker.With pick #55 they take TE Vance McDonald from Rice.
Still 2 more freakin' days to go with the draft. If they could, they would stretch it out all week.Lemon and Tank are edge guys, we have no inside depth.Williams at the least can rotate at nose, all we have therE now is Dorsey (who played de for kc).Williams still could happen I guess. Something must be out there about him though to not be off the board after many projected him as a late 1st round guy. I don't know if the Niners would do a 3rd DL as well. I'm hoping they have a CB out there they like but it very well could be that there just wasn't one in this class they really covet. As far as players dropping goes I thought the Chargers got a steal with Keenan Allen.![]()
Lulz, thank God. That's how much I have been paying attention. Why they started it yesterday I dunno.Saturday is the last day of the draft.
A stud pass rush up front can help the backfield more. Losing Smith for a few games and he not being 100% in the post season really exposed a hole in the defense. Looks like they are stocking up bodies for the DL which is a good thing overall.I don't think CB is a huge immediate need. They will need some bodies to replace Brock and Rogers next year, and probably Whitner at safety as well. I'm not sure they will be able to afford boldin and/or Crabtree, so they will have to look at WR as well. Unlikely any DL they could draft at this point would be capable of breaking into the rotation.
Yeah, could be huge and would be a great story to see a kid come back from such a horrrific injury.Love the Lattimore pick.
bothYeah, could be huge and would be a great story to see a kid come back from such a horrrific injury.Love the Lattimore pick.
Williams injuries must be much worse than people thought.......
Yeah, that suckedSeattle trades up for Williams. Bastahds.
Sounds like he is someone who can move inside if needed, so diffferent than Carridine in that regard.Dial is the first pick I really don't totally understand. I know the guys from here on in are long shots to make the roster. I'd rather have spent what we had left to move up for Williams. I just don't see the need for Dial after drafting Carradine. Lemonier should be more of an OLB. I guess he's just DL depth.