Should I accept a proposed trade where i receive Jonathan Taylor for Mark Ingram III? (1 Viewer)

[Washfootballteam]

I love both of these backs but I don't know if it would be smarter to bank on Taylor taking time away from Marlon Mack or Ingram taking the lions share of snaps in Baltimore's 4 man backfield.

For reference my other running backs are:

Joe Mixon

Raheem Mostert

James Robinson

Joshua Kelley

Adrian Peterson

 

[Mongidig]

I would. 

I like Ingram but I think his TD's regress this year plus the more crowded backfield. The RB coach talked about wanting to keep everybody fresh this year. 

Taylor seems to be a future star running behind a fantastic line. He has a QB who likes to throw to his backs. Mack tends to get dinged up so He may be the man sooner than later. You seem to have enough at RB right now to wait it out. 

 

[Gally]

I assume this is in a redraft because in a dynasty it is a very easy decision to be on the Taylor side.  

For a redraft I think I still lean to Ingram but its basically a coin flip.

 

[themeistersinger]

Most of what I've heard about those 2 guys is you want Ingram the first half of the season (before Dobbins pushes him aside) and you want Taylor for second half of season (once he pushes Mack aside).  So I'd weigh if I need the help more now or later.

Here's mine

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/788338-ros-ppr-end-of-bench-whir/

 

[Torchdave]

Yes

 

[JoeSteeler]

I would stick with Ingram 

 

[kerosenedan]

You know what you’re getting with Ingram...the upside is with Taylor.

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/788399-jeudy-or-boyd/

 

[DaBearsTN]

I would take the upside of JT all day!

Ingram will have TD regression and "might" lose the job soon.