Hey Joe.
This is great stuff. I have a 22.5" Weber Platinum and love it. I use the chimney with hard wood lump charcoal. Swore off gas grills a long time ago. :X
I've done alot of grilling, but not much smoking as of yet. I think I will take the plunge next weekend following the instructions in this post. Tally Ho!
One poster asked about heat and setting the vents. I might have missed it, but I didn't see a response. Can you tell me how you adjust your vents for the duration? Do you use a meat thermometer to check before you pull them off or is the four hour duration full proof? The little details will kill you. Thanks!
Hi El,My standard rule for all smoking is all the vents wide open all the time. You want as much air flowing through there as you can.
I learned this the hard way when I first started smoking. I learned that you could choke the vents down and it would let the wood smolder and smoke but not go out. That meant I could go longer in between putting wood on the fire. What I learned though was that smoke from a smoldering fire is way different than smoke from a burning fire. The science guys can explain but smoke from a fire is much "cleaner" than smoke from a smolder. The smoldering smoke leaves a nasty tar like creosote on the lid of the grill and the food.
I learned that you want your fire burning as hot and as "clean" as you can. If you need less heat, make a smaller fire. But keep it burning cleanly.
So bottom line is I keep the vents wide open, both on the bottom under the coals and on top of the lid.
For doneness, definitely use a meat thermometer. After you do a bunch, you "know" when it's done but I always am paranoid about undercooked meats. A chicken that is done is easiest to tell as the leg will pretty much just break off if you lift it. But still use a thermometer to be safe.
I love my big offset smoker burning straight hickory but if I had to be honest, you can do just about as well with a Weber kettle grill with the coals off to the sides and a chunk of hickory burning on top. Especially for chicken.
Good luck.
J