Solid trade? WHIR (1 Viewer)

[3quinox]

16 team PPR dynasty. 45 man roster. 

I give: 1.03 (this years rookie draft), robert quinn, and Mack Hollins 

I get: 1.11, 1,15, Alex Collins, Mario Edwards, and a 3.15. 

My thoughts are the draft this year has pretty decent depth. 1.03 would most likely be Chubb, but I can use Alex Collins and double down with TWO 1sts.

 

[snoochieboochies]

For me, I would wait till after the draft. I think the truly talented RBs will probably be gone by the 1.11 and 1.15, at which point you are picking up the other positions. If you want a talented dynasty RB, wait until the draft is done so you can be pretty sure it will be player X and you like that player.

Assuming you are not needing to start a rookie RB this year, then I would favor the 1.03 side. I would also prefer a trade where you get a RB/WR that has a more defined role or is higher up the rankings than Collins+ two firsts. You are getting some decent volume in return, but no talent that is similar to the talent offered by the 1.03. The ravens have a history of not starting the best RB from last season, and drafting RBs in the 3rd to 5th rounds. Waiting till after the draft assures that you know the target you want is on a good team, or that Collins and the two later firsts are the better deal. 

 

[NeverEnough]

I'd hold for now

 

[Gally]

I am fairly easily on the 1.03/Quinn side of the equation.  In larger leagues you need studs and you are more likely to get that stud at the 1.03 than at the end of the first.  It could happen but at this point the most likely outcome is it won't.  Stick with the 1.03