What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Starting 2 QBs in a dynasty (1 Viewer)

doughboydeluxe

Footballguy
I am part of a 12 team startup dynasty league (30 man rosters - we haven't drafted yet), and the commish wants to start 2 QB. I suggested starting 1 QB and being allowed to play a QB as a flex, but he didn't go for it. Anyone have any experience with this? Does QB value go through the roof more than a redraft starting 2 QB, or is it about the same?

 
I got into an argument about this earlier, and no one really answered my question, but that was redraft. Basically, IMO, QBs basically become like RBs. Anyway, I'm in a 12-team 2QB dynasty draft right now. Here are the first 3 rounds, almost: (This is also an IDP league)

Round 1:

1. Hells Satans-Adrian Peterson RB/MIN

2. Da Bears-Calvin Johnson WR/DET

3. GH’s Sermon-J.P. Losman QB/BUF

4. JLO -Marshawn Lycnh RB/BUF

5. Quiet Storm-Anthony Gonzalez WR/IND

6. Hazzard Rebels-JaMarcus Russell QB/OAK

7. BIGdigNOttaters-Brady Quinn QB/CLE

8. Crusaders-Robert Meachem WR/NO

9. The P Players-Brandon Jackson RB/GB

10. Wally's World-DJ Hackett WR/SEA

11. Real Men Of Genius-Brandon Marshall WR/DEN

12. fireballs 05 champs-Michael Bush RB/OAK

Round 2:

13. Hells Satans-Drew Stanton QB/DET

14. Da Bears-Dwayne Bowe WR/KC

15. GH’s Sermon-Chris Henry RB/TEN

16. The P Players (f/ JLO)-John Beck QB/MIA

17. Quiet Storm-Patrick Willis LB/BUF

18. Hazzard Rebels-Greg Olsen TE/CHI

19. BIGdigNOtaters-Dwayne Jarrett WR/CAR

20. Crusaders-Paul Posluszny LB/BUF

21. fireballs 05 champs-Lorenzo Booker RB/MIA

22. JLO (f/ Players)-Craig Davis WR/SD

23. Wally's World-Vernand Morency RB/GB

24. Real Men Of Genius-Jerry Porter WR/Oakland

Round 3:

25. Real Men Of Genius-Mike Peterson LB/JAC

26. Players (f/ JLo via Players)-Sidney Rice WR/MIN

27. fireballs 05 champs-LaRon Landry DB/WAS

28. Crusaders-Zach Miller TE/OAK

29. BIGdigNOtaters-Damon Huard QB/KC

30. Hazzard Rebels-Jacoby Jones WR/HOU

31. Quiet Storm-Troy Williamson WR/MIN

32. The P Players (via JLo)-Antonio Pierce LB/NYG

33. GH’s Sermon-Reggie Nelson DB/JAC

34. Da Bears-Joey Harrington QB/ATL

35. Hells Satans-

36. Wally's World-

 
I got into an argument about this earlier, and no one really answered my question, but that was redraft. Basically, IMO, QBs basically become like RBs. Anyway, I'm in a 12-team 2QB dynasty draft right now. Here are the first 3 rounds, almost: (This is also an IDP league)Round 1:1. Hells Satans-Adrian Peterson RB/MIN2. Da Bears-Calvin Johnson WR/DET3. GH’s Sermon-J.P. Losman QB/BUF4. JLO -Marshawn Lycnh RB/BUF5. Quiet Storm-Anthony Gonzalez WR/IND6. Hazzard Rebels-JaMarcus Russell QB/OAK7. BIGdigNOttaters-Brady Quinn QB/CLE8. Crusaders-Robert Meachem WR/NO9. The P Players-Brandon Jackson RB/GB10. Wally's World-DJ Hackett WR/SEA11. Real Men Of Genius-Brandon Marshall WR/DEN12. fireballs 05 champs-Michael Bush RB/OAKRound 2:13. Hells Satans-Drew Stanton QB/DET14. Da Bears-Dwayne Bowe WR/KC15. GH’s Sermon-Chris Henry RB/TEN16. The P Players (f/ JLO)-John Beck QB/MIA17. Quiet Storm-Patrick Willis LB/BUF18. Hazzard Rebels-Greg Olsen TE/CHI19. BIGdigNOtaters-Dwayne Jarrett WR/CAR20. Crusaders-Paul Posluszny LB/BUF21. fireballs 05 champs-Lorenzo Booker RB/MIA22. JLO (f/ Players)-Craig Davis WR/SD23. Wally's World-Vernand Morency RB/GB24. Real Men Of Genius-Jerry Porter WR/OaklandRound 3:25. Real Men Of Genius-Mike Peterson LB/JAC26. Players (f/ JLo via Players)-Sidney Rice WR/MIN27. fireballs 05 champs-LaRon Landry DB/WAS28. Crusaders-Zach Miller TE/OAK29. BIGdigNOtaters-Damon Huard QB/KC30. Hazzard Rebels-Jacoby Jones WR/HOU31. Quiet Storm-Troy Williamson WR/MIN32. The P Players (via JLo)-Antonio Pierce LB/NYG33. GH’s Sermon-Reggie Nelson DB/JAC34. Da Bears-Joey Harrington QB/ATL35. Hells Satans-36. Wally's World-
How have people done with managing 2 QB in the dynasty format? Do people try to horde backup QBs? Have there been instances of people getting stuck with 1 QB very often?
 
How have people done with managing 2 QB in the dynasty format? Do people try to horde backup QBs? Have there been instances of people getting stuck with 1 QB very often?
I am in a 10 team dynasty league that starts 2 QB's, and yes, people horde backup QB's. we actually use a super flex, and if you aren't starting 2 QBs its a real disadvantage. That means you need to have at least 3 starters rostered to cover bye weeks, and with 6 pt passing TD's no managers in my league were stuck without at least 3. i think the addition of the 2 QB/superflex rule was the best addition we've made to our league. it really takes a lot of emphasis off of RB's and places it upon the most important position in the game. with 12 teams i could see there being some serious issues for some owners being without a QB so I would run with the superflex for the 12 team league.
 
I got into an argument about this earlier, and no one really answered my question, but that was redraft. Basically, IMO, QBs basically become like RBs. Anyway, I'm in a 12-team 2QB dynasty draft right now. Here are the first 3 rounds, almost: (This is also an IDP league)
How have people done with managing 2 QB in the dynasty format? Do people try to horde backup QBs? Have there been instances of people getting stuck with 1 QB very often?
Well, it's a dynasty so some teams have a lot and others have barely any. One team started off with only Cpep as their QB and took Losman third overall. Then there's another team with four starters (Rivers, Grossman, Roth, and Rexy) and they're looking to move a QB. Another team is offering some really good players (Holt, TO, D-Will) for QB help. Basically if you get into a rut you're going to have to trade your way out of it. I now have Leinart, Eli, Alex Smith, and Stanton, so I'm feeling pretty good. I like to have two solid starters, one backup starter, and a project. Obviously Stanton is the project.
 
IMO, QBs are worth more in a dynasty than redraft to begin with. Longevity and a somewhat lower turnover among the top 10 (although I might be proven wrong here). I would not hesitate to take Peyton in the 1st in any dynasty, and maybe Palmer as well. In a 2 QB start league, they become possible top 5 picks - possibly #3 and 4, just behind LT and SJax. Lower QBs will rise to the level of RBs, if not higher. Young proven QBs who are generally valued low like Roethlisberger, Rivers, Alex Smith, etc. become a lot more valued. Backup QBs should be valued like good backup RBs.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top