Take a look at this trade proposed to me (1 Viewer)

[Waggle]

Would you do this? If so, WHY? I can't, for the life of me, come up with one good reason to do this.

I am missing something?

Joe Crede

José Reyes

Manny Ramírez

Moisés Alou

Roy Halladay

Armando Benítez

Ben Sheets

For (my team)

Édgar Rentería

Brad Hawpe

Álex Rodríguez

Álex Ríos

Bobby Jenks

Bob Wickman

Javier Vázquez

tia

 

[Bobcat10]

I'd ask for the league setup...but it probably doesn't matter in this case.

I'd want the group with Reyes, Manny and Halladay hands down. The only "stud" on the bottom team is ARod.

 

[eoMMan]

My question is why are you trading away most of your team a few weeks into the season.

 

[fred_1_15301]

I'd ask for the league setup...but it probably doesn't matter in this case.I'd want the group with Reyes, Manny and Halladay hands down. The only "stud" on the bottom team is ARod.

Can't tell from the OP's post but it sure sounds like he's getting the better end of the deal.

 

[Angry Beavers]

Is this a keeper league or not?

 

[Waggle]

Is this a keeper league or not?

Not.

 

[Bobcat10]

Is this a keeper league or not?

You'd take the ARod team if it was?

 

[Waggle]

My question is why are you trading away most of your team a few weeks into the season. :(

This trade was proposed to me.

 

[shadyridr]

Would you do this? If so, WHY? I can't, for the life of me, come up with one good reason to do this.

I am missing something?

Joe Crede

José Reyes

Manny Ramírez

Moisés Alou

Roy Halladay

Armando Benítez

Ben Sheets

For (my team)

Édgar Rentería

Brad Hawpe

Álex Rodríguez

Álex Ríos

Bobby Jenks

Bob Wickman

Javier Vázquez

tia

Is this ? The bolded team is leaps and bounds better than your team

 

[Angry Beavers]

Is this a keeper league or not?

You'd take the ARod team if it was?

No, just trying to figure out if there is some angle we are missing here!

 

[Bobcat10]

Is this a keeper league or not?

You'd take the ARod team if it was?

No, just trying to figure out if there is some angle we are missing here!

I agree.Waggle, I hope you are not sitting on this.......

 

[my man otis]

e-rod man love

 

[Waggle]

Would you do this? If so, WHY? I can't, for the life of me, come up with one good reason to do this. I am missing something?Joe CredeJosé ReyesManny RamírezMoisés AlouRoy HalladayArmando BenítezBen SheetsFor (my team) Édgar RenteríaBrad HawpeÁlex RodríguezÁlex RíosBobby JenksBob WickmanJavier Vázqueztia

I took the trade. I was looking to see if this guy had some sort of agenda. Thanks for the input. You never know what people are thinking.

 

[Waggle]

Would you do this? If so, WHY? I can't, for the life of me, come up with one good reason to do this. I am missing something?ProposedJoe CredeJosé ReyesManny RamírezMoisés AlouRoy HalladayArmando BenítezBen SheetsFor (my team) Édgar RenteríaBrad HawpeÁlex RodríguezÁlex RíosBobby JenksBob WickmanJavier Vázqueztia

How does this trade look now?

 

[shadyridr]

Would you do this? If so, WHY? I can't, for the life of me, come up with one good reason to do this. I am missing something?ProposedJoe CredeJosé ReyesManny RamírezMoisés AlouRoy HalladayArmando BenítezBen SheetsFor (my team) Édgar RenteríaBrad HawpeÁlex RodríguezÁlex RíosBobby JenksBob WickmanJavier Vázqueztia

How does this trade look now?

Still very lopsided

 

[The Houston Stallions]

Would you do this? If so, WHY? I can't, for the life of me, come up with one good reason to do this. I am missing something?ProposedJoe CredeJosé ReyesManny RamírezMoisés AlouRoy HalladayArmando BenítezBen SheetsFor (my team) Édgar RenteríaBrad HawpeÁlex RodríguezÁlex RíosBobby JenksBob WickmanJavier Vázqueztia

How does this trade look now?

Still very lopsided

Still week 4 of the season. I like the top team for the long haul.

 

[The Houston Stallions]

Would you do this? If so, WHY? I can't, for the life of me, come up with one good reason to do this. I am missing something?Joe CredeJosé ReyesManny RamírezMoisés AlouRoy HalladayArmando BenítezBen SheetsFor (my team) Édgar RenteríaBrad HawpeÁlex RodríguezÁlex RíosBobby JenksBob WickmanJavier Vázqueztia

I took the trade. I was looking to see if this guy had some sort of agenda. Thanks for the input. You never know what people are thinking.

His agenda is to get A-rod, Rios (RF), and 2 closers. I'm commenting on Rios because your league might have seperate OF postions.

 

[shadyridr]

Would you do this? If so, WHY? I can't, for the life of me, come up with one good reason to do this. I am missing something?ProposedJoe CredeJosé ReyesManny RamírezMoisés AlouRoy HalladayArmando BenítezBen SheetsFor (my team) Édgar RenteríaBrad HawpeÁlex RodríguezÁlex RíosBobby JenksBob WickmanJavier Vázqueztia

How does this trade look now?

Still very lopsided

Still week 4 of the season. I like the top team for the long haul.

Umm yeah thats what Im saying. Lopsided for Waggle

 

[The Houston Stallions]

Would you do this? If so, WHY? I can't, for the life of me, come up with one good reason to do this. I am missing something?ProposedJoe CredeJosé ReyesManny RamírezMoisés AlouRoy HalladayArmando BenítezBen SheetsFor (my team) Édgar RenteríaBrad HawpeÁlex RodríguezÁlex RíosBobby JenksBob WickmanJavier Vázqueztia

How does this trade look now?

Still very lopsided

Still week 4 of the season. I like the top team for the long haul.

Umm yeah thats what Im saying. Lopsided for Waggle

I quoted you but only to agree with you. I know what side you were on. I think you posted higher in the thread too. My comment was because the side shouldn't chage because of players performance 1 or 2 weeks later. It would only change if one of these players was down for the season.